Ridings v. PeaceHealth: A Religious Exemption Letter Counts Even When Not Attached to the Complaint

Karly Ridings, a pregnant nurse, asked her Oregon hospital for a religious exemption from its COVID-19 vaccine requirement. PeaceHealth placed her on indefinite unpaid leave in her third trimester, leaving her without income or health insurance. When she sued, the district court dismissed her complaint as too conclusory about her religious belief, without discussing the exemption letter that explained it.
In Ridings v. PeaceHealth, No. 24-7282 (9th Cir. Sept. 24, 2026), the Ninth Circuit reversed. A letter that the complaint referenced, and whose authenticity no one disputed, was part of the complaint because her claim depended on it. Read with the letter, her objection to a vaccine she believed was derived from aborted fetal cells “easily satisfies the plausibility threshold” for a Title VII religious-accommodation claim. The case returns to the district court; the ruling decides only that the claim may go forward.
What the letter said, and what the complaint left out
Ridings’s letter gave two religious grounds. Pregnant at the time, she wrote that her faith required her to “honor and protect” her body as a “temple” and not risk harm to her unborn child. She also wrote that using “an aborted child’s body for science against his will violates my religious conscience,” and quoted Jeremiah 1:5. She suggested alternatives, such as non-patient care and masks.
Her complaint, under Title VII and Oregon’s parallel statute, mentioned “her religious exception request” and said that, as a devout Christian, she did not believe the vaccine was consistent with her faith. It did not attach the letter or describe it in detail. PeaceHealth moved to dismiss for failure to plead the first element of the claim: a conflict between the vaccine policy and a bona fide religious belief. Ridings attached the letter to her opposition and asked for leave to amend if needed. The magistrate judge recommended denying the motion. The district judge rejected that recommendation, dismissed “without prejudice” and entered judgment without leave to amend. Neither order discussed the letter.
Why the unattached letter counted
On a motion to dismiss, courts ordinarily look only at the complaint and the documents attached to it. The incorporation-by-reference doctrine is an exception: If a claim necessarily relies on a document and no one disputes its authenticity, the court may treat the document as part of the complaint.
Ridings’s claim relied on her letter. In the Ninth Circuit, an accommodation plaintiff must show not only that a job duty conflicted with a sincere religious belief, but also that she “informed [her] employer of the belief and conflict.” The request letter was that notice; without it, the court said, it could not assess the claim. The complaint expressly mentioned the request, and PeaceHealth did not contest the letter’s authenticity, so the district court should have read it.
In a footnote, the panel added an alternative holding. Entering judgment without letting Ridings amend to attach the letter was an abuse of discretion, because dismissal without leave to amend is improper unless no amendment could save the complaint.
Why the fetal-cell objection was enough
At the pleading stage, a religious-discrimination claim must be as plausible as any other claim, but courts may not probe whether a belief is genuine or reasonable. Taking the letter into account, the panel held that Ridings plausibly alleged she opposes the vaccine because of her religious objection to abortion. Her letter stated “with specificity” that her faith bars her from using products derived from fetal cells obtained through abortion, and she supported that objection with Scripture. In a footnote, the court added that a belief need not be shared by every member of a faith to be protected.
How Ridings fits with Detwiler
PeaceHealth relied on Detwiler v. Mid-Columbia Medical Center, 156 F.4th 886 (9th Cir. 2025), which requires a plaintiff to plead enough facts to show her belief is religious “rather than purely secular.” Detwiler created a circuit split, rejecting as “far too permissive” standards used in the Sixth, Seventh and Eighth Circuits.
The Ridings panel reasoned that Detwiler did not change the core question: whether the employee’s professed beliefs, taken at face value, conflict with the policy. That is “a low bar,” asking only whether, in Detwiler’s words, “there is any nexus between religion and [her] viewpoint.” Detwiler’s objection to nasal-swab testing rested on her own conclusion, drawn from secular sources, that the swabs would harm her; she then invoked a general teaching that the body is a temple. Where a personal or scientific judgment overlaps with a religious duty, the panel noted, the overlap is presumably protected. Detwiler’s objection rested only on the medical judgment, while Ridings’s was religious at its root.
Detwiler itself had pointed the way. It distinguished an unpublished decision, Keene v. City & County of San Francisco, in which employees pleaded a specific Christian objection to fetal cells used in developing the vaccines. Ridings, the panel said, makes the same objection.
What the remand leaves open
Because the fetal-cell objection was enough, the panel expressly left undecided whether Ridings’s body-as-temple objection would state a claim on its own. It reversed the dismissal and remanded for further proceedings. The ruling holds only that the first element is adequately pleaded. Under the framework the opinion describes, once a plaintiff makes out a prima facie case, the burden shifts to the employer to justify its decision, and an employer must accommodate unless doing so would cause undue hardship. The panel decided the Oregon claim the same way, because Oregon’s statute follows the Title VII framework.
What to keep if your accommodation request was denied
For a worker, the request itself is often the proof of both notice and the religious basis. Keep the complete request and any attachments, proof that it reached the employer, the employer’s response, the alternatives you proposed, and every leave, pay and benefits notice. A complaint should describe the belief, the specific conflict with the policy, the notice given and what the employer did next.
In our reading, incorporation cuts both ways. Once the letter is part of the record, all of it is, including any passage that frames the objection as medical rather than religious. If your request was denied or you were placed on leave, our employment litigation practice can review the letter and the employer’s response with you.
Was Your Accommodation Letter Considered?
Bring the original request, proof it reached the employer, the employer’s response, and any complaint or dismissal order. We can review whether the letter states the religious basis and the conflict clearly, and what the next step should be. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.