WCAB Distinguishes DPR Construction in Post-MSC Evidence Dispute
Decision: Rhodes v. Ontario Montclair Sch. Dist., Nos. ADJ10333462 & ADJ21853030 (WCAB July 9, 2026).

In Rhodes, four disputed medical exhibits were admitted and a fifth item remained deferred. The panel did not treat everything offered after a mandatory settlement conference (MSC) as one category. It separated later reports obtained through court-authorized development, older reports already reviewed in the medical record and a still-unresolved request for another specialty. The result was admission of evidence, not a final award for every claimed condition.
Read the official WCAB panel decision.
A Dispute Over Reports Offered After the MSC
Wanda Rhodes sustained admitted injury while working as a physical-education teacher. The litigation later involved additional claimed conditions and a dispute over supplemental QME reports, older pain-psychology reports, and a proposal for additional QME panels.
Exhibits 1 and 2 were supplemental orthopedic QME reports dated September 15 and August 25, 2025, after the May 7 MSC. Exhibits 3 and 4 were pain-psychology reports from 2021 that had not been separately listed on the conference statement. Exhibit 7 was a November 2025 letter proposing additional QME panels. Their different histories mattered. Rhodes, pages 5–6, 14–17.
Later QME Reports Were Properly Admitted
The orthopedic evaluator had identified a need to review earlier MRI images and reconsider the lumbar impairment method. The judge continued trial to permit that reporting after finding that the images were unavailable or could not have been discovered with due diligence before the MSC. The employer then requested supplemental reporting and later continuances while waiting for it.
The panel admitted Exhibits 1 and 2 in that procedural setting. The judge’s development order, the finding that the MRI evidence was previously unavailable despite diligence, and the parties’ later discovery conduct supported admission. Rhodes, pages 4–5, 14–16.
The panel observed that the employer had not sought prompt review of the order allowing further development and had participated in obtaining the resulting reports. The panel relied on that sequence when rejecting the defendant’s objection to the resulting reports. Rhodes, pages 15–16.
Why the Older Treatment Reports Also Entered the Record
The 2021 pain-psychology reports presented a different question: They existed before the MSC but were omitted from its exhibit list. The panel traced their prior review by treating physicians and the orthopedic QME. It cited Labor Code sections 4062.3(a) and 5703(a), together with the still-developing record and opportunity to respond. The panel relied on these particular reports’ prior review by treating and medical-legal physicians and the opportunity to challenge their weight before a final merits decision. Rhodes, pages 16–17.
Admission and persuasive weight remained different issues. The judge still had to assess what the reports proved. Exhibit 7, proposing further QME panels, was not admitted: Its admission was deferred because the relevant psychology and pain-management panel issues had not been decided. That unresolved item is a useful limit on reading the case as blanket permission to add documents. Rhodes, pages 14–15, 18–19.
How Rhodes Distinguished DPR Construction
The panel explained that published appellate authority, DPR Construction, involved unlisted reports used in a final merits decision. Here, the challenged supplemental reports followed the judge’s development order, and the older reports had already been reviewed within the medical record. The merits of the additional body-part and rating issues were still being developed. Rhodes, pages 16–17.
The panel therefore concluded that admitting the documents would not deprive the defendant of a fair opportunity to challenge their weight or develop responsive evidence.
Practical Lessons About the MSC Cutoff
- List every known report and witness on the pretrial conference statement.
- Make a clear record when evidence did not exist or could not be discovered earlier.
- Review a discovery order promptly. Rule 10955 generally requires a removal petition within 20 days after service of the order or occurrence of the challenged action; applicable service extensions require separate review.
- Do not assume that participation in post-MSC discovery preserves every later objection.
- Distinguish admissibility from the weight ultimately assigned to a medical report.
Rule 10955 also requires significant prejudice or irreparable harm and a showing that reconsideration after a final decision would not be an adequate remedy. Rule 10605 addresses applicable service extensions. Do not calculate a deadline from “20 days” alone or assume a petition stops the scheduled proceeding. As a WCAB panel decision, Rhodes provides persuasive guidance on applying Labor Code section 5502(d)(3) to post-MSC supplemental QME evaluations and previously incorporated treatment records before a final merits decision.
Review Your Post-MSC Evidence Strategy
Mishra X Trial Lawyers assists injured workers with California workers’ compensation trial procedure and evidence disputes. Bring your Pretrial Conference Statement, MSC summary, and QME reports for a case analysis. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.