California Court Enforces WCAB Pretrial Evidence Rules in DPR Construction

A worker can prevail on a credibility issue and still need the claim reconsidered because medical reports were improperly admitted. That is what happened in DPR Construction. The Court of Appeal rejected the attack on the judge’s explanation of credibility, but separately enforced the rule excluding two unlisted reports. Those were different objections with different results.
In DPR Construction v. WCAB (McClanahan) (2025) 111 Cal. App. 5th 1136, the Third District Court of Appeal annulled (set aside) a WCAB decision after two medical reports were admitted even though they had not been identified on the parties’ pretrial conference statement. The court rejected the WCAB’s position that the error could be treated as harmless and ordered reconsideration without the reports.
Read the filed appellate opinion and publication order.
What Happened in the Shoulder-Injury Claim?
Alonzo McClanahan sought workers’ compensation benefits for a right-shoulder injury that he said occurred on July 25, 2017, while he was working for DPR Construction. He testified that he spent several hours moving approximately 200 twenty-foot-long boards and developed stiffness between his shoulder and neck. According to McClanahan, he mentioned the problem to his foreman and superintendent but initially declined to prepare a report because he did not believe the injury was serious.
DPR disputed that account. Three DPR employees testified that McClanahan did not report an injury that day, and a sign-out sheet indicated that he had checked a box stating he was not injured. The record also contained prior medical treatment involving McClanahan’s right shoulder and differing accounts of how his later symptoms arose.
The workers’ compensation judge nevertheless found McClanahan credible and concluded that he sustained an industrial shoulder injury. The judge relied on his testimony, treatment records, and the opinions of qualified medical evaluator Dr. McGahan.
The Dispute Over Two Unlisted Medical Reports
Before trial, the parties participated in a mandatory settlement conference. Their pretrial conference statement identified Dr. McGahan as the agreed qualified medical evaluator and listed his reports as exhibits. It did not list two earlier reports prepared by Dr. Hanley, a previously designated qualified medical evaluator.
Over DPR’s objection, the workers’ compensation judge admitted the Hanley reports because DPR had received them before the settlement conference. The WCAB later acknowledged that omitting the reports from the pretrial statement was an error, but a majority affirmed the result. It reasoned that the judge did not rely on the reports to find an industrial injury and that the judge retained discretion to admit evidence as a matter of due process.
The Credibility Explanation Was Sufficient
DPR raised a separate challenge under Cal. Lab. Code § 5313, arguing that the WCAB failed to explain adequately why it found McClanahan credible.
The Court of Appeal rejected that argument. Section 5313 requires findings on the ultimate facts, a summary of the evidence received and relied upon, and the reasons supporting the determination. It did not require the judge to provide a separate, detailed explanation addressing every reason for accepting or rejecting a witness’s testimony.
Here, the judge identified the ultimate finding—that McClanahan sustained an industrial injury—and tied it to his testimony, the treatment records, and Dr. McGahan’s findings. That explanation was sufficient for review even though the record contained inconsistencies.
Why the Unlisted Reports Required Annulment
The result was different under Cal. Lab. Code § 5502. In California workers’ compensation cases, discovery generally closes on the date of the mandatory settlement conference. If the matter does not resolve, the parties must identify disputed issues, witnesses, and exhibits in the pretrial conference statement. Evidence not disclosed at that stage is generally inadmissible unless the proponent shows that it was unavailable or could not have been discovered through due diligence before the conference.
The Court of Appeal held that the Hanley reports did not satisfy that exception. They were already available, but McClanahan had not identified them. The fact that DPR had previously received the reports did not eliminate the statutory disclosure requirement. Nor did the earlier evaluator’s replacement make the older reports automatically part of the listed later evaluator’s reports. They remained separate exhibits whose omission had to be addressed. DPR Construction, slip opinion, pages 2, 8–9.
The court also rejected the WCAB’s harmless-error analysis. Relying on longstanding precedent, it explained that allowing undisclosed evidence whenever the opposing party cannot prove specific prejudice would weaken the pretrial rules and make the statutory consequence largely meaningless.
The Court’s Disposition
The Court of Appeal annulled the WCAB’s decision and remanded the matter for reconsideration without reference to the Hanley reports. It awarded DPR and its insurer their costs in the writ proceeding.
The court did not hold that McClanahan’s injury was nonindustrial or finally deny him benefits. It upheld the sufficiency of the judge’s credibility explanation while requiring the WCAB to reconsider the claim without the two improperly admitted reports. This distinction matters: The court did not itself decide what result the remaining evidence required. DPR Construction, slip opinion, pages 7–10.
Practical Lessons for California Workers’ Compensation Cases
DPR Construction makes the mandatory settlement conference a genuine litigation deadline, not a paperwork formality. Before that conference, parties should confirm that each report, witness and exhibit they may need at trial is identified. Possession by the other side is not a substitute for disclosure. Where a later evaluator has replaced an earlier one, check the earlier reports separately rather than assuming that listing the current evaluator includes every prior report.
The decision also distinguishes two concepts that are sometimes blurred. A WCJ’s credibility explanation can be legally adequate even if a party strongly disputes the factual conclusion. But the evidence used to reach that conclusion must still be admitted in compliance with the governing procedural rules.
When discussing an adverse decision with counsel, identify the actual problem: Was the judge’s explanation inadequate, was particular evidence inadmissible or does the properly admitted evidence fail to support the finding? A disagreement with credibility is not a substitute for identifying the governing procedural error. Equally, identifying that error does not establish the final medical or benefit outcome.
Current-status note: The opinion was filed on May 16, 2025, and certified for publication on June 11, 2025. The attached June 11 publication order certified the opinion for publication. Later official WCAB decisions cite its published reporter citation; it is appellate authority, unlike the fact-specific Rhodes panel application. Because the matter was remanded, the appellate opinion should not be described as a final adjudication of McClanahan’s entitlement to benefits.
Have Your Pretrial Evidence and Disclosures Reviewed
Mishra X Trial Lawyers reviews mandatory settlement conference statements, medical exhibit lists, and WCAB hearing records to enforce pretrial disclosure rules. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com to discuss your workers’ compensation case.