Your QME Deferred the Spine to Another Specialty: Additional Panel, Replacement or Consult?

When your qualified medical evaluator (QME) writes that your neck or back is outside the doctor’s expertise, you do not automatically get a new doctor. California rules send a new medical question back to the same evaluator first. Another evaluator comes in only through a specific route: an additional panel in a different specialty, which requires good cause under section 31.7; a replacement panel on a ground the regulations list; an agreed medical evaluator; or a consultation the judge orders.
Which route fits depends on what the QME wrote, when your claim forms were filed and which doctors are already involved. A 2025 Appeals Board decision about a hand specialist who deferred the spine shows how easily the routes get mixed up.
Read the deferral before choosing a remedy
Start with the doctor’s own words. Is the QME recommending treatment, declining to say what caused a condition, or saying records are missing? A recommendation for care is not a request for another evaluator.
The first stop is usually the same doctor. When a new medical issue comes up after a report, the parties, “to the extent possible,” are to use the evaluator who already reported, under Labor Code section 4062.3(k) and title 8, section 31.7(a). A short supplemental report can separate what this doctor can answer from what the doctor cannot. If expertise is the real problem, asking the same question again will not supply it.
Separate an additional panel from a replacement
Thomas Gallegos, a correctional supervising cook, had two claims for injuries to his right hand, wrist and upper extremity. A hand specialist served as QME. After both claims were amended to add the neck, spine and other body parts, that doctor deferred the spine and psychiatric questions as outside his expertise. The employer asked for an additional panel in spine, and the judge granted it. In Gallegos v. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, Nos. ADJ15539216 and ADJ15538700 (Cal. WCAB Oct. 3, 2025), an Appeals Board panel rescinded that order and returned the case for further development of the record.
An additional panel adds QMEs from a different specialty alongside the evaluator already in the case. Section 31.7(b) requires good cause, such as a written agreement of the parties in a represented case, an agreement reached with an Information and Assistance Officer in an unrepresented case, or a judge’s order for the panel. The request goes on Form 31.7. In Gallegos’s case the judge made no good-cause finding, and the Board doubted the route fit: Hand and spine can both fall under orthopedic surgery. Otherwise, it reasoned, there could be “an additional panel for each and every body part that an orthopedist should be able to comment on.”
A replacement swaps out the evaluator or the panel on a ground listed in section 31.5, using Form 31.5. Two grounds matter after a deferral. Under section 31.5(a)(10), the party who did not choose the specialty may ask the Medical Director to find it “medically or otherwise inappropriate for the disputed medical issue(s),” filing the Doctor’s First Report and the latest treating-physician report with the request. In a represented case, either party may appeal the Medical Director’s decision on the specialty to a judge under section 31.1(b). Under section 31.5(a)(15), an evaluator who otherwise appears qualified may be replaced if, when asked, the evaluator refuses to give either a complete evaluation or a written statement explaining why he or she is not qualified on an issue. In our reading, a QME who has already written that explanation has not refused it.
The Gallegos panel said it was “plausible that another hand specialist would be able to comment on all orthopedic complaints,” so a replacement in the same specialty might work, but it made no determination either way and left that choice for the trial level.
Check the claim forms and first appointment
If you have more than one claim, line up the date of each claim form against the date of the first QME appointment. Under section 4062.3(j), the evaluation must address contested issues from all injuries reported on claim forms before that appointment. Gallegos’s claim forms were dated September and November 2021, and the hand specialist first examined him on February 8, 2022. So that doctor should have been the QME for both claims, and adding body parts later did not change that.
Conduct also counted. Gallegos had obtained a second panel, in physical medicine and rehabilitation, in January 2022. The employer never objected to that request, the appointment, the report or the supplemental report, so the Board found the employer had waived its objection and left that doctor as QME in the other claim. But Gallegos could not use that doctor to cover the spine in the hand specialist’s claim. Making him “a de facto additional QME” without everyone’s agreement “would undermine the abundance of appropriate procedures” the rules provide. Keep panel requests, appointment notices, reports and objections together; they decide what each side can still argue.
Obtain a supported plan for the missing opinion
When a report is incomplete, the Board described the preferred sequence. First, return to the doctors who have already reported. If they cannot fill the gap, consider an agreed medical evaluator (AME), a doctor both sides accept. If the parties cannot agree, the judge can appoint a physician under Labor Code section 5701. In Gallegos’s case, a section 5701 consultation was one option to supplement the missing spine opinion.
Before anyone schedules another exam, name the new doctor’s role. A consultant supplements the reports already in the file; a newly selected evaluator is different, and an AME agreement should say which issues it covers. Otherwise a useful exam can get caught in a fight over how the doctor was chosen. The case analysis of Gallegos covers the removal procedure and the waiver ruling in more depth.
Practical steps for workers
- Put every claim form beside the date of the first QME appointment and mark which claims were reported before it.
- Quote the exact sentence where the QME defers, and list each disputed body part the report leaves unanswered.
- Match any request for another doctor to its rule: Form 31.7 with good cause under section 31.7(b), Form 31.5 with a listed ground, an AME agreement, or a request that the judge order a consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a QME’s deferral automatically entitle me to another panel?
No. A deferral shows that an opinion is missing. An additional panel still needs good cause under section 31.7(b), and a replacement needs a ground listed in section 31.5.
Are a spine panel and a hand panel always different specialties?
Not necessarily. In Gallegos, the Board panel noted that both can fall under orthopedic surgery and was not convinced the difference justified an additional panel on that record.
Can the other claim’s evaluator simply take over?
Not without a proper basis. Gallegos rejected using a QME from the worker’s other claim as a de facto additional QME without the agreement of all parties.
When a deferral has stalled your claim, the QME reports and panel history are where our California workers’ compensation practice starts.
Reviewing QME panel and deferral disputes
We can review whether a QME’s deferral supports a supplemental report, an additional panel, a replacement or a consultation, and prepare the request. Bring your claim forms, every QME report, the panel request and selection papers, any objections and any pending WCAB filings. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.