Gallegos: No Extra Spine QME Panel Without Good Cause

Separate medical-report sleeves beside hand and spine models

Thomas Gallegos, a correctional supervising cook, had two right-arm injury claims and two QMEs. After he added his neck and back, the hand QME said the spine was outside his expertise, and the trial judge ordered a new spine panel. In Gallegos v. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation–California Health Care Facility, Nos. ADJ15539216 and ADJ15538700 (Cal. WCAB Oct. 3, 2025), a Board panel rescinded that order. Hand falls under orthopedic surgery and spine potentially does too, so the record did not show good cause for an additional panel in a different specialty. The judge must now choose a supported route to the missing spine opinion.

Two claims, two QMEs and an added spine

On December 8, 2021, Gallegos filed two applications: a cumulative-trauma claim and a specific-injury claim from opening metal food carts, both for the upper extremity and wrist. The defendant obtained a hand panel on December 16, 2021, and Dr. Michael Moore became the QME. On January 3, 2022, Gallegos obtained a physical medicine and rehabilitation panel without objection, and Dr. Nader Achackzad was selected.

Dr. Moore examined him in February 2022. Dr. Achackzad did not examine him until May 13, 2024, and his report rated the cervical spine among other parts. In June 2024, Gallegos amended both applications to add the shoulders, spine, neck and left arm. When Dr. Moore examined him again in December 2024, he found only the right hand, fingers and wrist industrial and deferred the spine and psyche to another specialty.

At the April 2025 trial of the cumulative-trauma case, the defendant asked for an additional spine panel and argued that Dr. Achackzad was the QME in neither case. Gallegos said Dr. Achackzad should address the neck and spine. The judge found Dr. Moore the QME in the cumulative-trauma case, Dr. Achackzad the QME in the specific-injury case, and a new spine panel appropriate.

Why the Board reviewed the order as removal

Gallegos sought reconsideration, arguing that another panel would delay both cases and that Dr. Achackzad had already addressed the back and neck. The Board held that the findings were interlocutory procedural findings that decided no substantive right and no threshold issue. It dismissed the petition as one for reconsideration and reviewed it as one for removal, an extraordinary remedy that requires a showing of substantial prejudice or irreparable harm.

The first QME should have covered both claims

Under the en banc decision in Navarro v. City of Montebello and Labor Code sections 4062.3(j) and 4064(a), an evaluation addresses all issues from injuries reported on claim forms filed before that evaluation. Both claim forms predated Dr. Moore’s first exam, so he should have been the QME for both claims, and amending the body parts did not change that.

But the defendant never objected to the second panel request, the May 2024 appointment, the June 2024 report or the July 2024 supplement. The Board found waiver, and because Gallegos attended the exam in good faith, it found the defendant estopped as well. It left the judge’s QME findings intact.

That did not let Dr. Achackzad cross over. Gallegos argued that the second panel was meant to cover his spine complaints. The Board answered that Dr. Achackzad “was never intended to be an additional panel QME” in the cumulative-trauma case, and that making him a “de facto additional QME” without the agreement of all parties would undermine the existing procedures.

No good cause for a different-specialty panel

Rule 31.7 tells parties, to the extent possible, to return to the same evaluator when a new medical dispute arises. It allows an additional panel in a different specialty only on good cause, such as a written agreement in a represented case or a judge’s order that sets the specialty or names who picks it. Here no good-cause finding had been made. Hand is a specialty within orthopedic surgery, and spine potentially is too. “We are not convinced that there is enough of a difference,” the Board wrote, warning that the contrary rule would produce an additional panel for every body part an orthopedist should be able to address.

The routes the Board left open

On return, the judge should consider whether Dr. Moore should be replaced, or whether a replacement panel in a different specialty that can address all the orthopedic body parts should issue under rule 31.5. The defendant, as the party that first requested a panel, had the right to designate the specialty. The other side may ask the Medical Director for a replacement panel on the ground that the specialty “is medically or otherwise inappropriate” for the dispute, with an appeal to the judge. Gallegos had not made that showing. The Board thought another hand specialist might be able to address all the orthopedic complaints but made no determination either way.

The Board saw no apparent dispute that Dr. Moore’s opinions were incomplete as to the spine. Under McDuffie, the first step is to return to the existing physicians; if they cannot cure the gap, the parties should consider an agreed medical evaluator, and without agreement the judge may appoint a physician under Labor Code section 5701. The Board urged the parties to discuss an AME.

The order dismissed reconsideration, granted removal, rescinded “the decision of July 21, 2025” and returned the matter for further development of the record.

What to check when a QME defers a body part

Line up four dates: each claim form, each panel request, each first exam and each amendment adding body parts. They show which QME covers which claim. Then list every report and appointment the other side received without objecting; in Gallegos, silence through four events locked in the second QME’s role in his own claim. Read the deferral itself: Does the QME say the body part is outside his specialty, or only that a consultation would help? Our guide on what to do when your QME defers the spine walks through choosing among the routes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Board forbid any new spine evaluator?

No. It rescinded the additional-panel order because good cause was not shown on this record and sent the case back to choose a supported way to get spine evidence.

Can a QME from my other claim cover the spine in this claim?

Not by default. The Board refused to let the second claim’s QME become a de facto additional QME without the agreement of all parties.

What options did the Board point to?

A replacement QME or panel under rule 31.5, an agreed medical evaluator, a physician appointed under Labor Code section 5701 or, with good cause, an additional panel in a different specialty. It chose none of them.

Review your QME panel history

If a QME has deferred your spine or another body part, or the other side wants a new panel, we can review your claim forms, panel requests, QME reports and objection history and explain which route fits your record. Learn more about our California workers’ compensation practice. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.