QME Apportionment to Personal History: Check the Facts Behind the Percentage

Medical history folders and a QME percentage chart

If a QME report says part of your permanent disability comes from something outside work—a prior condition, alcohol use, a divorce, a death in the family—that percentage can reduce your California workers’ compensation award. It does so only if the employer proves it with medical reasoning built on accurate facts. A percentage resting on conflicting history that no one has resolved is not enough, as a September 2026 decision shows.

List every fact the percentage rests on

Find the paragraph that assigns a share of disability to nonindustrial causes. List each condition, event or habit it relies on, with the dates, duration and treatment the doctor describes. Then find where each fact came from: your interview, an intake form, a treating record, an earlier evaluation or testimony. Mark anything you cannot trace rather than filling the gap with a guess.

That tracing decided Butler v. State of California, Department of Toxic Substances Control, Nos. ADJ6958667 & ADJ6960238 (Cal. WCAB Sept. 11, 2026). Two evaluators each assigned 10% of an office technician’s disability to nonindustrial factors, including long-term alcohol use and personal stressors. But the histories she had given the doctors about her alcohol use were materially inconsistent. She did not testify at trial, and no supplemental report was obtained to reconcile the accounts, so the judge could not tell which history, if any, was accurate. The judge rejected the 10% reduction, and a WCAB panel denied the employer’s petition for reconsideration, adopting the judge’s report. The 73% permanent-disability award stood.

Who must prove apportionment, and how

Under Labor Code section 4663, apportionment is based on causation. The doctor must estimate what approximate percentage of the permanent disability the work injury caused and what percentage other factors caused. The employer bears the burden of proving apportionment with substantial medical evidence: an explanation of how and why the nonindustrial factor caused part of the disability. As the Butler judge put it, “Apportionment cannot be based on possibilities – it must be based on reasonable medical probability.”

So look for the sentences that connect the factor to your present disability. A diagnosis or a reference to your past does not, by itself, explain a number. If a report documents a prior condition but never says why it accounts for 10% rather than some other share, that is the gap to ask the doctor to address.

A weak apportionment does not sink the whole report

Separate the doctor’s impairment rating from the explanation of what caused the disability. In Butler, the judge found the same reports unreliable on apportionment but still substantial on causation and impairment, and relied on them for those findings. The ratings stood, and the award issued without the reduction. Aim any challenge at the specific conclusion you dispute.

Line up the conflicting accounts

For each disputed fact, write down what the evaluator said, the source relied on, the conflicting document or testimony and the question that needs an answer. If two reports give different durations for the same condition, note both passages and their interview dates. Ask which account the evaluator accepts, why, and whether the difference changes the causal opinion. A request that only asks the doctor to “confirm the percentage” may return the same number without resolving its premise.

A conflict can cut both ways. In Butler, a third evaluator, Dr. Silverman, learned of the alcohol history only from Dr. Bertoldi’s new report. He wrote that it raised the possibility of apportioning at least 20% of the cognitive problems to alcohol use, “if confirmed.” Unconfirmed, it supported no reduction; confirmed, it might have supported a larger one. Know which version of your history the records support before you press the point. Our Butler case analysis covers the rest of the decision, including the sleep-impairment rating.

Prepare a focused review with counsel

Give counsel the complete report and the passages you dispute. Depending on the stage of the case, the next step may be a request for a supplemental report, a deposition of the evaluator or evidence at trial. Contact with a QME is governed by procedural rules, so get advice before sending the doctor a request or new records yourself. Bring a short list:

Check what each evaluator received

When several specialists evaluate related conditions, compare their lists of records reviewed. One may have a history another has not yet seen. Keep a list of what each evaluator received and any later clarification. If an account changed, keep the original, the correction and the explanation.

Protect sensitive records and track deadlines

Substance-use and personal histories can involve sensitive records. Ask counsel which authorization and disclosure rules apply before circulating them, and do not send unrelated personal information. Keep the report’s service date, benefit notices, hearing dates and orders together; asking a doctor for clarification does not extend any other deadline.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can personal history support apportionment?

Yes, when reasoned medical evidence based on accurate facts explains how a nonindustrial factor caused part of the permanent disability. The employer must prove it.

What if the history in my QME report is wrong?

Note the statement, the record that contradicts it and any explanation for the difference. Then ask counsel whether to raise it through a supplemental report, a deposition or evidence at trial.

Does an unsupported apportionment throw out the whole report?

Not necessarily. A judge can rely on a report for causation and impairment while rejecting its apportionment.

What to bring for a QME apportionment review

We review QME and AME reports to test whether a nonindustrial apportionment rests on accurate history and explained medical reasoning, and we can pursue clarification, a deposition or trial evidence through our California workers’ compensation practice. Bring the QME reports, treating records, intake questionnaires and any deposition transcripts. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.