Butler: A 10% Apportionment Cut Failed on Conflicting Alcohol History

Two medical histories beside an impairment worksheet

An employer that wants to cut a workers’ compensation award for nonindustrial causes has to prove the facts its doctors relied on. In Butler v. State of California, Department of Toxic Substances Control, Nos. ADJ6958667 & ADJ6960238 (Cal. WCAB Sept. 11, 2026), two evaluators assigned 10% of the disability to alcohol use or personal stressors. But the worker had given the doctors conflicting accounts of her drinking, and nothing in the record resolved the conflict. A three-commissioner panel denied reconsideration for the reasons in the trial judge’s report, and the 73% permanent-disability award stood with no apportionment.

The doctors relied on conflicting histories

Dara Butler was an office technician for the Department of Toxic Substances Control. She claimed a specific injury on May 14, 2009, and a cumulative psychiatric injury from April 13, 2008, to April 13, 2009. The judge found injury to her lumbar spine, psyche, vascular system (headaches), cognition (memory) and sleep, treated the two claims as inextricably intertwined, and on June 2, 2026, issued a joint award of 73%. The case was submitted on March 11, 2026, without testimony.

Dr. Roger Bertoldi, a sleep-medicine specialist, apportioned 10% of the cognitive impairment to “non-industrial alcohol usage” and 10% of the sleep impairment to “non-industrial factors.” He relied on a reported history of more than 20 years of alcohol abuse. Dr. David Sones assigned 10% of the psychiatric disability to stressors outside work that Butler had described, including a 2010 foreclosure, illnesses and deaths in her family, and a separation from her husband.

Dr. Silverman then reviewed Dr. Bertoldi’s work and wrote that he had not known of the alcohol history. In his October 14, 2025, report he said it “raises the possibility that there should be an apportionment to the nonindustrial alcohol use of at least 20%, if confirmed,” and that it “would be important to confirm her past history in terms of amount and duration of alcohol abuse.” He kept fatigue and pain 100% industrial. The judge’s report noted, as Dr. Silverman had, “material inconsistencies” in the alcohol history Butler gave each doctor. Because she did not testify and no supplemental report reconciled the accounts, the judge could not decide “which factual history, if any, was accurate.”

The employer had to prove the facts behind the 10%

Under Labor Code section 4663, apportionment is based on causation of the permanent disability, and the reporting physician must estimate what share the work injury caused and what share other factors caused. The party seeking apportionment carries the burden. Under Escobedo v. Marshalls (2005) 70 Cal.Comp.Cases 604, that burden is met only by substantial medical evidence explaining how and why the nonindustrial factor caused a percentage of the disability.

The judge’s report added the point that decided Butler: “A medical opinion based on materially inaccurate or unresolved historical facts is not substantial evidence.” It compared Pan Pacific Printing Press, Inc. v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (Whitt) (2016) 81 Cal.Comp.Cases 744 (writ denied), where a QME’s conclusion failed because it rested on an incorrect history of no prior back injury.

Applied here, the two 10% opinions were only as good as the history beneath them, and Butler’s conflicting accounts of her past alcohol use were never reconciled. The judge called the opinions “speculative and unsupported.” Dr. Silverman’s “if confirmed” showed the gap: A possible allocation that depends on an unproved fact is a possibility, and under Kopping v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (2006) 142 Cal.App.4th 1099, 1101, the employer must prove apportionment within reasonable medical probability. The report concluded that the employer had not met that burden.

The rest of the medical reports still counted

Rejecting the apportionment did not throw out the reports. The judge still relied on Dr. Bertoldi’s and Dr. Sones’s findings on causation and impairment, citing Republic Indemnity Co. of America v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (Winner) (2007) 72 Cal.Comp.Cases 1175, where a judge properly used the valid parts of reports whose apportionment analysis was not entirely convincing. A report can fail on one question and remain substantial evidence on others.

The employer also attacked the 51% permanent disability for the sleep disorder, arguing that Dr. Bertoldi needed an Almaraz/Guzman analysis. That challenge failed for a different reason: Dr. Bertoldi traced the sleep disorder to a hypothalamic-pituitary (endocrine) dysfunction and gave a straight rating under the AMA Guides chapter for that system, so, as our companion analysis of his rating method details, Almaraz/Guzman was not triggered.

The 73% award stood

The employer did not challenge the joint rating itself, only its result. With the apportionment and sleep-rating arguments rejected, the rating did not change, so the employer’s request to recalculate the attorney’s fee had nothing to work with. Commissioner José H. Razo signed the order, with Commissioners Craig L. Snellings and Katherine Williams Dodd concurring; the panel adopted and incorporated the judge’s report as its reasons.

If a doctor cuts your award for personal history

Find the fact the doctor used to apportion: years of drinking, a prior injury, a list of life stressors. Then find where it came from and whether another report tells it differently. In Butler, the conflict between the doctors’ accounts was in the record, but no one took the step that might have resolved it: testimony or a supplemental report reconciling the histories.

The same logic works in both directions. A worker who wants to defeat apportionment should look for the unsupported premise. A party relying on apportionment should resolve a disputed history before trial, not after.

Questions the medical record should answer

If an evaluator has apportioned part of your disability to your history, our California workers’ compensation practice can review the reports and the records they rely on and identify which factual links are missing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the proposed reduction fail?

The 10% opinions rested on Butler’s reported history, and her accounts of past alcohol use conflicted from doctor to doctor. With no testimony and no supplemental report to resolve them, the judge found the opinions speculative, and the employer did not prove apportionment.

Why did the conditional medical opinion matter?

Dr. Silverman said the alcohol history raised the possibility of at least 20% apportionment “if confirmed.” It was never confirmed, and apportionment must rest on reasonable medical probability, not possibility.

Could the judge use other parts of the same reports?

Yes. The judge rejected the apportionment opinions but still relied on the same reports for causation and impairment, which Winner permits.

Facing an apportionment reduction?

We can review the QME or AME reports, the histories they rely on and the trial record, and prepare the request for clarification, deposition or supplemental report the case needs. Bring the medical-legal reports, the records they cite, any deposition transcripts and the Findings and Award. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.