Cleveland Board of Education v. Loudermill: Notice and a Chance to Respond Before a Public Employee Is Fired

Case records and a notebook arranged for legal review.
The notice, the supporting evidence and the opportunity to respond are separate parts of a dismissal record.

If you hold a public job that can be taken away only for cause, your employer must tell you the charges, explain its evidence and give you a chance to answer before the firing takes effect. That pre-firing step, often called a Loudermill hearing, need not be a trial. It is an initial check on whether there are reasonable grounds for the firing, and it works together with the full hearing that comes afterward.

The Supreme Court set that rule in Cleveland Board of Education v. Loudermill, 470 U.S. 532 (1985), decided March 19, 1985, in an opinion by Justice White. It is a ruling under the Fourteenth Amendment’s Due Process Clause, so it applies to state and local public employers, including school districts, cities and counties in California.

A security guard and a bus mechanic, fired without a chance to answer

The Cleveland Board of Education hired James Loudermill as a security guard in 1979. His application said he had never been convicted of a felony. Eleven months later the Board found a 1968 grand-larceny conviction, and a letter dated November 3, 1980, told him he was dismissed for dishonesty on the application. He had no chance to respond first. Before a Civil Service Commission referee, he said he had believed the conviction was a misdemeanor; the Court later called that plausible, since his sentence was a suspended six months and a fine. The referee recommended reinstatement, but the full Commission upheld the dismissal.

Richard Donnelly, a bus mechanic for the Parma Board of Education, was fired in 1977 after failing an eye examination. He had been offered a retest and did not take it. The Commission later ordered him reinstated, but without backpay.

Both men sued in federal court, alleging that Ohio’s procedure gave them no chance to respond before removal. The District Court dismissed both complaints at the pleading stage. The Sixth Circuit reinstated the pretermination claims, and the Supreme Court affirmed and remanded: Because the employees alleged “that they had no chance to respond,” their complaints stated a claim.

The job protection comes from state law; the process comes from the Constitution

Ohio law made the two men classified civil servants who held their jobs “during good behavior and efficient service” and could be removed only for listed causes. That gave each a property interest in continued employment.

The Parma Board argued that the same statute that created the job protection also set the procedure for ending it, so following that procedure was all the process due. That was the “bitter with the sweet” idea from the plurality in Arnett v. Kennedy (1974). The Court rejected it: “‘Property’ cannot be defined by the procedures provided for its deprivation any more than can life or liberty.” A State may choose whether to give a job protection, but once it does, the Constitution sets the minimum process for taking it away.

Justice Rehnquist dissented. He would have read the job protection and its procedures as one package, so that a person who takes a government job “accepts the grant of tenure along with its inherent limitations.”

Why the answer has to come before the firing

Due process requires “some kind of a hearing” before an employee with a protected job interest is discharged. The Court weighed the employee’s livelihood, the employer’s interest in removing unsatisfactory employees quickly, and the risk of a mistaken firing. Even when the facts are clear, whether firing is the right response may not be, and the only meaningful chance to influence that choice is likely before it takes effect.

Both cases showed why. Donnelly’s reinstatement suggested an error might have been avoided. Loudermill’s referee had recommended reinstatement, so the Court could not rule out that a fully informed decision-maker would have kept him. And “the right to a hearing does not depend on a demonstration of certain success,” the Court wrote. If an employer thinks keeping someone at work is a significant hazard, it can suspend the employee with pay; here, Donnelly’s failed test concerned driving buses, not repairing them, and Loudermill’s job performance was conceded to be fully satisfactory.

What a Loudermill hearing must include

The pre-firing hearing “need not be elaborate.” The Court said what it must contain: “The tenured public employee is entitled to oral or written notice of the charges against him, an explanation of the employer’s evidence, and an opportunity to present his side of the story.” The answer can be given in person or in writing. The hearing need not finally decide whether the firing is proper; it is a check on whether there are reasonable grounds to believe the charges are true and support the proposed action. The Court’s holding rested in part on Ohio’s full post-termination hearing and judicial review.

Justice Marshall agreed the employees were entitled to respond and joined the part of the opinion rejecting “bitter with the sweet.” He would have required more before wages stop when there are substantial disputes in testimonial evidence: a chance to confront and cross-examine adverse witnesses and to present witnesses of his own. Justice Brennan joined Parts I–IV but read them as leaving that question open for cases with real factual disputes.

Compare what you were actually given with those three parts. A notice that sets a meeting without stating the charge, or reasons first explained after the firing, may fall short.

The nine-month appeal: when delay becomes a claim

Loudermill also claimed his administrative appeal took too long. The referee’s hearing came two and a half months after he appealed, and the written decision six and a half months after that. The Court recognized that due process requires a hearing “at a meaningful time” and that “[a]t some point, a delay in the post-termination hearing would become a constitutional violation.” But his complaint only recited the chronology and called nine months too long. The Court held that did not state a claim, noting the delay stemmed in part from the thoroughness of the procedures.

Justice Brennan dissented from that part. He read the holding as limited to Loudermill’s pleading—“not that nine months can never exceed constitutional limits”—and would have sent the delay question back for evidence, since the Commission had explained none of the gaps. A delay claim therefore needs more than a total: hearing and decision dates, who asked for each continuance, the reasons the agency gave, and what the wait cost you.

What to bring if you face dismissal

If you were also ordered to answer questions in an investigation, see our guide to compelled interviews and criminal exposure. Our employment litigation practice can check these papers against the three things a pre-firing hearing must give you.

Facing a notice of intent to dismiss from a public employer?

Our employment litigation team can review the notice and the evidence you were given, help prepare your response before the decision, and assess the administrative appeal. Bring the notice, your classification and the rules protecting your job, and any response you have already sent. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.