Ewing: With No Earlier Psychiatric Award, There Was Nothing to Subtract on Reopening

A worker whose first award found a psychiatric injury but rated no psychiatric disability can receive a psychiatric rating on reopening once permanent disability is established, without a deduction for disability that was never awarded. Any apportionment to other causes still needs substantial medical evidence. In Christiana Ewing v. Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transit Authority, No. ADJ9666592 (Cal. WCAB Nov. 13, 2026), the Appeals Board replaced a 48 percent award with 67 percent permanent disability. It also rejected the evaluator’s 30 percent apportionment to childhood trauma and an earlier car accident, because she never explained how those factors caused the worker’s current symptoms.
The panel (Commissioner Kelly, Chair Zalewski and Deputy Commissioner Sussman) granted the worker’s petition for reconsideration.
A work car accident and a 2017 award that rated no psychiatric disability
Christiana Ewing was a bus driver for the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transit Authority. She was injured on September 14, 2014, in a crash that left her with facial lacerations and scarring as well as orthopedic injuries. Her treating psychologists diagnosed depression and, later, posttraumatic stress disorder (pages 2 and 3).
A November 9, 2017 Findings and Award found injury to her psyche along with her lumbar spine, right ankle, face, right knee and right shoulder (page 3). It awarded no psychiatric permanent disability, and the record held no report finding her psychiatrically permanent and stationary (at maximum medical improvement, or MMI) before that award (page 8). On February 1, 2019, she petitioned to reopen for new and further disability, including to her psyche (page 4).
The psychiatric panel qualified medical evaluator, Alexis Link, M.D., found her at MMI on December 10, 2019. She diagnosed posttraumatic stress disorder and moderate major depressive disorder and assigned a Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF) score of 51, a 29 percent whole person impairment. In 2024 she found her opinions unchanged (pages 4 and 5).
Dr. Link apportioned 20 percent of the psychiatric disability to nonindustrial factors, including childhood trauma and adult relationships, and 10 percent to a nonindustrial 2009 car accident. In a separate Benson summary she called 30 percent “solely nonindustrial,” assigned 55 percent to the 2014 work accident itself, including its emotional impact and her permanent facial changes, and left another 15 percent, for chronic pain, to be split among her injuries as the orthopedic evaluators had divided them, including the 2009 accident (pages 4 and 5).
How the judge reached 48 percent
After trial, the judge’s August 13, 2026 Supplemental Findings and Award found that Ewing could not claim psychiatric disability not claimed at the time of the 2017 award. After deducting what the Board called a “prior, non-existent Award of psyche permanent disability,” he found 7 percent new psychiatric disability (pages 7 and 8) and 48 percent permanent disability overall (page 1). Ewing argued that treating 26 percent psychiatric disability as previously awarded was invalid apportionment, and that the judge had cited the wrong section for his violent-act finding (page 1).
No earlier psychiatric award meant nothing to subtract
Under Labor Code section 4664 and the Court of Appeal’s decision in Kopping, an employer seeking credit for earlier disability must prove a prior award and then the extent of overlap. Here the first step failed. As the Board put it, “the applicant had no prior Award for her accepted psyche permanent disability,” and with no psychiatric MMI report before the 2017 award, she had no permanent psychiatric disability when it issued (pages 10 and 11). Our Strong analysis explains how overlap works when a prior award does exist.
The Board then applied the reopening rule. “New and further disability” under section 5410 means a demonstrable change, including a change to permanent disability. Quoting Sierra Vista Hospital v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (Shedelbower), it explained that when increased disability is awarded, “it is the total [permanent disability] award which is due, not the subtraction of the percent of permanent disability . . . On a reopening, it is as if a new award had issued.” Because her psychiatric condition was declared MMI for the first time on December 10, 2019, the Board held that she “is entitled to an unapportioned Award of psyche permanent disability” (page 11).
Why the childhood and 2009 crash apportionment failed
Under section 4663 and the en banc decision in Escobedo, the employer must prove apportionment with substantial medical evidence addressing what caused the disability, not the injury. A medical opinion “must set forth reasoning in support of its conclusions” (page 9).
The rated disability was Ewing’s GAF of 51, which the rating schedule describes as moderate symptoms or moderate difficulty in social or occupational functioning. Dr. Link’s opinions failed “because she did not address the causation of applicant’s moderate symptoms and disability.” She listed childhood stress and the 2009 accident but “failed to explain how and why the moderate symptoms were caused by” them (pages 9 and 10). Our guide to QME apportionment to personal history explains how to test a percentage of this kind.
The Benson analysis failed for a different reason. Benson divides disability between two industrial injuries. Ewing was a 17-year-old rear-seat passenger in the 2009 accident, Dr. Link herself called it nonindustrial, and nothing in the record showed it was work-related (page 10).
The substituted 67 percent award
Using the judge’s rating strings, the Board combined 41 percent for the psyche with the ratings for both scars, the right ankle and the lumbar spine: 41 c 18 c 15 c 15 c 6 equals 67 percent. The substituted findings award 407.25 weeks at $290 a week, $118,102.50, less credit for permanent disability previously paid, with an attorney fee of 15 percent of the additional disability (pages 11 and 12; the award section on page 13 says 407.26 weeks with the same total).
The Board also corrected the violent-act finding to cite section 4660.1(c)(2)(A). As our Baigmoradi analysis explains, that exception allows psychiatric impairment to increase a rating despite section 4660.1(c)’s limit. Ewing had challenged only the citation, not the finding (page 1).
What Ewing means for a reopened psychiatric claim
Our reading: When a first award found a psychiatric injury that no one had yet rated, check the award’s terms and the dates of the psychiatric reports. A section 4664 deduction needs a prior award of permanent disability, not just a finding of injury. And a nonindustrial percentage must connect the earlier history to the symptoms rated now; naming childhood trauma or an old accident is not enough. A prior award that did rate psychiatric disability, or a report explaining how earlier trauma produces specific current symptoms, could change the result.
Reopening a claim with an unrated psychiatric injury?
Bring your first Findings and Award, the petition to reopen, every psychiatric evaluator’s report and deposition, and the rating strings, so we can check whether a deduction or nonindustrial percentage has real support. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.