Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions: A Hiring-Packet Arbitration Agreement Too One-Sided to Fix

Interlaced teal ribbons curve around a rust-colored band on an ivory surface.

A call-center worker’s wage class action stays in court. In Bennett v. VXI Global Solutions, LLC, No. B346763, the California Court of Appeal held that the arbitration agreement she signed at hiring was so one-sided, and its defects so central, that the trial court properly refused to enforce it at all. The limit is in the wording: The court could not cure the agreement by deleting words, because the words left behind would still have reached claims having nothing to do with her job.

The Second District, Division Eight, filed the published opinion on November 13, 2026, by Justice Viramontes with Presiding Justice Stratton. Justice Wiley dissented.

A call-center job and a 100-page packet

VXI Global Solutions hired Tracie Bennett as an account associate in February 2023; she worked there until April. Her roughly 100-page new hire packet included an arbitration agreement and a confidentiality agreement she understood she had to sign. In October 2023 she filed a wage-and-hour class action. The trial court held the agreement’s scope and duration unconscionable and impossible to sever.

Signing was only mildly unfair

Unconscionability requires unfairness both in how a contract was made and in its terms, on a sliding scale. The signing involved only the low unfairness built into a take-it-or-leave-it hiring form: Nothing showed she was rushed, and the language was “not particularly complex or difficult to understand.”

What made the terms one-sided

Only a high degree of one-sidedness could defeat the agreement, and the court found it in three features. First, the agreement covered individual claims or controversies even if they had nothing to do with her employment. Second, it said it would survive her employment, and it could be revoked only by a writing signed by her and all of the company’s partners. Together, those terms required her to arbitrate nearly any claim against the company for the rest of her life, unless she and the company agreed to end the agreement.

Third, “the Company” included past and present partners, officers, employees, affiliates and benefit plans. They could force Bennett to arbitrate her claims against them, but she could not force them to arbitrate theirs against her without first showing they had accepted a benefit under the agreement. The court called that a one-sided benefit VXI never justified.

Because both agreements were signed the same day at hiring, the court read them together. The confidentiality agreement let VXI obtain an injunction without proving irreparable harm, and barred Bennett, while employed and for a year after she left, from soliciting coworkers to leave, even by lawful means. The court held the first unconscionable and the second invalid under Business and Professions Code section 16600.

Why the court would not cut and enforce

Under Civil Code section 1670.5 and Ramirez v. Charter Communications, Inc. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 478, a court should refuse to enforce a contract whose central purpose is tainted with illegality. If it cannot cure the unfairness without adding to or rewriting terms, it likewise “should refuse to enforce the contract.”

Both reasons applied. Counting the two confidentiality terms, the court found “at least five substantively unconscionable provisions, a considerable number,” and a central mechanism, arbitration of every claim against a broad group of beneficiaries with no reciprocal duty, that swept too broadly and favored the company. The confidentiality terms could have been cut; the scope could not. Deleting the “may or may not be related” and “whether or not” phrases, as VXI proposed, would leave “all individual claims or controversies” with the company, still reaching claims unrelated to her job. Limiting that would require adding language. The court affirmed the order denying arbitration.

Why Salazar came out the other way

A day earlier, the same division certified for publication Salazar v. CN Motor Co. LLC, which struck similar overbroad, one-sided terms from a car dealership’s agreement and sent the worker’s individual wage claims to arbitration. Bennett does not cite it; in our reading, the opinions differ in two ways.

First, what survived the deletions. Salazar’s agreement explicitly covered disputes related to his job application or employment. Once the court struck phrases such as “of any nature” and “or any other relationship/interaction with”, that job tie remained, and the agreement was enforced for employment-related claims. Bennett’s agreement had no such fallback, and its at least five defects included the confidentiality terms; Salazar said the few unconscionable provisions left “appear entirely severable.”

Second, duration. Salazar rejected the trial court’s finding that the agreement lasted forever: The “not revocable” sentence the trial court relied on sat in a paragraph listing exceptions for agency claims, and a contract with no stated term “terminates after a reasonable time.” Bennett held its agreement’s express survival and signed-writing terms unconscionable. Justice Wiley, who dissented in Bennett, joined only in the result in Salazar.

The dissent: Federal law forbids this method

Justice Wiley agreed the procedural unfairness was low and the anti-raiding clause was unenforceable. He would have severed that clause and remanded with directions to send the case to arbitration. He argued that faulting scope, duration and a mutuality concern he called “strictly hypothetical” is an “arbitration special,” a rule used nowhere else in contract law, which the Federal Arbitration Act preempts under AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion (2011) 563 U.S. 333 and Kindred Nursing Centers L.P. v. Clark (2017) 581 U.S. 246. Of 100 California decisions from 2021 to 2025 that used unconscionability against a contract, he found 79 percent involved arbitration, or 90 percent after excluding specialty statutes.

The majority answered that the California Supreme Court still applies unconscionability to arbitration agreements under the Act, and that Concepcion saw a similar pattern but called the statistics “not definitive.” Because unconscionability is a defense to adhesion contracts, where arbitration clauses often appear, courts “are not singling out arbitration for disfavored treatment under the unconscionability doctrine.” As for “hypothetical” concerns, unconscionability is judged when the contract is created, before anyone performs. Justice Wiley replied that his numbers are not definitive either, but “suggestive.”

What to check in your own agreement

These points are our reading of Bennett and Salazar together.

Your employer wants to arbitrate your wage claims?

Bring the arbitration agreement, every document you signed with it, your hire date and the employer’s motion. Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review whether the agreement reaches beyond your job, what a court could cut, and what would be left. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.