Removed From a Hospital Schedule? Who Owes a Doctor a Hearing

A hospital tells the staffing company to take you off the emergency-department schedule, and the company does. Who owes you a hearing? In Stallion Springs Medical Services v. Superior Court, No. F090834 (Cal. Ct. App. Sept. 2, 2026), a published Fifth District decision, the court held that the common-law right of fair procedure does not apply to a physician staffing company because it is not a quasi-public institution. The hearing rights that can matter belong to the body that controls your medical-staff membership: the hospital and its medical staff.
What happened to Dr. Hundal
Kuljit Hundal, an emergency physician, worked at Adventist Health Tehachapi Valley as an independent contractor of Stallion Springs, the medical corporation that staffed and scheduled the hospital’s emergency department. He was also a member of the hospital’s medical staff. On March 26, 2019, a patient posted a social-media complaint that he had yelled at her. The chief of the medical staff opened an investigation, and the hospital told Stallion Springs to remove him from the schedule pending that investigation. The company did, ran its own investigation and ended his contract for cause.
Hundal sued the hospital, the medical staff and the company, alleging that he was removed without “any sort of notice or hearing.” He settled with the hospital and medical staff, leaving only a fair-procedure claim and an emotional-distress claim against the company. The trial court granted summary adjudication on the emotional-distress claim but denied it on the fair-procedure claim, which was headed for trial. The Court of Appeal granted the company’s writ petition and directed the trial court to grant summary judgment for the company in its entirety.
Why the staffing company owed no hearing
The fair-procedure doctrine protects against arbitrary decisions by private organizations that courts treat as quasi-public, such as a labor union, hospital, medical or dental licensing organization, or health insurer. The court held that a staffing company is not like them. Stallion Springs was not open to all qualified physicians, a contract with it was not necessary to practice medicine, and taking Hundal off one schedule did not affect his right to work in his field. His own contract made him responsible for obtaining and keeping medical-staff membership; if the hospital said he could no longer work there, the company had to tell him.
Hundal argued that the company was a gatekeeper because it chose who worked shifts and removed him. The court applied the test from Potvin v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. (2000) 22 Cal.4th 1060, under which an insurer’s duty “arises only when the insurer possesses power so substantial that the removal significantly impairs the ability of an ordinary, competent physician to practice medicine or a medical specialty in a particular geographic area . . . .” Hundal’s practice was not significantly impaired, the court said, “as he lost privileges at only one hospital,” and he cited no evidence that the company could impair his ability to practice in the area.
The peer-review hearing belongs to the hospital
California’s peer-review statute, Business and Professions Code sections 805–809.9, governs a hospital physician’s hearing rights in peer review. As the court described it, the statute reaches a final proposed action by a peer-review body, such as a hospital’s medical staff, that must be reported to the licensing agency in an “805 report.” The physician gets written notice and may request a hearing, with the right to call and confront witnesses, present evidence and receive a written decision. Hundal did not dispute that Stallion Springs was not a peer-review body, so the statute did not require it to give him notice and a hearing.
The company also argued that the statute replaced the common-law doctrine altogether in physician-discipline cases, relying on Asiryan v. Medical Staff of Glendale Adventist Medical Center (2024) 100 Cal.App.5th 947. The court said it “need not decide the scope of the holding in Asiryan” and decided the case on the company’s role.
A hearing has to be able to change something
The court asked what procedure the company could have offered. The hospital decided whether Hundal kept his medical-staff membership, so, the court wrote, “even if it held a hearing and determined Hundal was improperly removed from the schedule, it could not return him to the schedule unless the hospital restored Hundal’s medical staff privileges.” Before demanding a hearing, identify who can grant the result you want. If the goal is to get back on the schedule, the decision that matters is the hospital’s.
The hospital’s own duties are a separate question
Hundal relied on Economy v. Sutter East Bay Hospitals (2019) 31 Cal.App.5th 1147, which held that a hospital cannot “avoid its obligation to provide notice and a hearing before terminating a doctor’s ability to practice in the hospital for jeopardizing patient quality of care, by directing the medical group employing the doctor to refuse to assign the doctor to the hospital.” The court said Economy did not help Hundal because it addressed the hospital’s obligations, not the medical group’s. In our reading, that distinction matters to a physician: A removal carried out through a staffing company can still raise peer-review questions about the hospital.
Ending the contract is a different claim
Stallion Springs also ended Hundal’s contract after its own investigation. But his fair-procedure claim, the court noted, was “based entirely on his removal from the hospital’s emergency department schedule, not Stallion Springs’ termination of his contract.” The court also rejected the idea that carrying out the hospital’s direction created a duty: If that were enough, “any termination of a contractual or employment relationship with a physician” would implicate the doctrine. Whether a termination broke the agreement is a contract question that turns on its notice and termination terms.
Answer each notice on its own terms
A removal can bring papers from the hospital or medical staff and from the staffing company, each with its own response date and review steps. A letter to the company does not answer a medical-staff notice.
What to check first
- Which action do you want changed: the schedule removal, the contract termination or your staff privileges?
- Who has power over that action under the staffing agreement and the medical-staff bylaws?
- Did the hospital or medical staff restrict or end your privileges, and did it give you notice of a hearing right?
- What does the staffing agreement say about staff membership, notice and termination?
- Share patient-related material only through an appropriate confidential channel.
What to bring
Bring the staffing agreement, the hospital’s removal instruction, every medical-staff notice and the bylaw provisions it cites, the company’s termination letter, and any complaint or court order. Those papers show which decision is still open, who made it and what kind of review or claim fits it. Our case analysis of Stallion Springs walks through the court’s reasoning in more detail. Our employment practice reviews staffing agreements, removal notices and termination letters like these.
Pulled From a Hospital Schedule?
Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review the staffing agreement, the hospital and medical-staff notices and the termination letter, sort out which entity made each decision, and explain whether a hearing request, a contract claim or another step fits your situation. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com. This article provides general information, not legal advice.