Zenith v. WCAB: California Court Rejects 20-Month Grant-for-Study Delay

Professional reviewing a workers compensation case file at a library table
The later Supreme Court decision in Mayor limits the WCAB’s authority to extend its own deadline.

Zenith Insurance Co. v. WCAB, 118 Cal. App. 5th 510 (2026), reversed a WCAB decision after a late grant of reconsideration and approximately 20 months of further delay. The Sixth District’s January 14, 2026 opinion, certified for publication February 10, rejected equitable tolling on that record. A later Supreme Court decision in Mayor now supplies an important limit: The Board cannot extend its own statutory deadline through equitable tolling.

Keep three questions separate: Was reconsideration granted within the applicable statutory period; was the grant order adequately explained; and what did the final ruling decide? The workplace fight explains the underlying claim, but the appellate disposition turned on procedure rather than a new finding about who started the fight.

Read the filed opinion and publication order.

Important case-status update: The Supreme Court’s April 29, 2026 order granted review in Zenith Insurance Co. v. WCAB, No. S295357, and deferred action pending Mayor, No. S287261, or further order. Mayor was decided August 24, 2026. That later decision must be considered; the April order does not establish the outcome of any subsequent order in Zenith. Check the current case record before relying on Zenith as binding authority.

A Workplace Altercation Led to a Dispute About WCAB Deadlines

Kin Chan worked as a prep cook at New Sam Kee Restaurant. In September 2020, an argument with a coworker escalated in the kitchen. The coworker struck Chan in the eye, causing a broken eye socket and other injuries. Chan sought workers’ compensation benefits.

The employer and Zenith Insurance Company invoked the initial-physical-aggressor defense under Cal. Lab. Code § 3600, subdivision (a)(7).

The Workers’ Compensation Judge Denied Benefits

Witnesses gave conflicting accounts. The judge found two witnesses generally credible and determined that Chan approached his coworker angrily while holding a knife. The judge concluded that Chan was the initial physical aggressor and ordered that he take nothing.

Chan timely petitioned for reconsideration on November 18, 2022. The judge transmitted the file through EAMS on November 30, but the Board stated that it did not receive notice and review the petition until January 17, 2023.

The Board Issued a Grant-for-Study Order

On March 3, 2023, the Board issued a generic order granting reconsideration for further study. Approximately 20 months later, it rescinded the judge’s decision and found the defense unproved. Zenith and the restaurant sought review, arguing that the petition had been deemed denied under former section 5909.

The Court Enforced the 60-Day Deadline

The Sixth District held that the deadline was mandatory. Assuming equitable tolling was legally available, the facts did not justify it. The record showed no inquiry by Chan or assurances that the Board would act, and the Board did not demonstrate diligence after receiving notice. A boilerplate grant-for-study order followed by nearly 20 months of inactivity was not a narrow, unusual circumstance supporting tolling.

The court also agreed with decisions criticizing generic grant-for-study orders that omit the evidence and reasons for granting reconsideration. Its reasoning did not require every final merits decision within 60 days; the timely grant-or-denial question and the later merits decision were distinct. Zenith, slip opinion, pages 19–21 and footnote 12.

Procedural Grounds of the Decision

The court reversed the Board’s November 2024 decision on procedural grounds. It did not decide whether Chan was legally the initial physical aggressor or whether the Board properly evaluated the evidence.

Practical Lessons

Parties should preserve filing proof, monitor the docket, document communications with the WCAB, and obtain prompt advice about judicial-review deadlines. Silence does not necessarily mean a petition remains pending indefinitely. Diligent follow-up can document what happened, but it does not by itself authorize the Board to extend the statutory period. Get advice on the actual order and available judicial remedy before a review deadline expires.

Read Zenith with the later Mayor decision

In Mayor v. WCAB, No. S287261 (Aug. 24, 2026), the Supreme Court held that former section 5909 imposed a mandatory deadline even though the Board retained fundamental jurisdiction over compensation matters. The Board could not equitably toll its own time to act. Mayor, slip opinion, pages 11–24.

The Court separately left open a narrow, party-asserted due-process issue; it did not find such a violation there. It also expressly declined to decide the merits of the grant-for-study procedure. Those reservations should not become either an automatic extension for every timely filer or a claim that Mayor decided every kind of interim grant order. Mayor, slip opinion, pages 12, footnote 4, 24–29.

Zenith applied the former filing-based clock to a 2022 petition. Current section 5909 measures the period from the trial judge’s transmission and requires notice; July 2026 legislation retained that framework. Match the governing statute to the actual petition, transmission and notice history before calculating a current deadline. Mayor, slip opinion, pages 5, footnote 3, 33.

Have Our Firm Review Your WCAB Reconsideration File

Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review your workers’ compensation record to evaluate section 5909 jurisdictional deadlines, grant-for-study orders, or pending petitions for reconsideration. Please have your WCAB case number, EAMS filing proofs, and any Board orders available when you contact us. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.