U-Visa Travel Requests: Processing Stage, Agency Response, and Your Record

Diagram illustrating U-visa processing stages and advance-parole request outcomes under Ninth Circuit review

Your U-visa processing stage, the relief you have received, and USCIS’s response to an individual travel request shape the available arguments for judicial review. In U Visa Appellants v. Director, USCIS, No. 24-6824, the Ninth Circuit examined those facts separately for petitioners on the waiting list and petitioners with bona fide determinations. Its September 14, 2026 opinion explains why a careful review begins with the notices, requests, and responses in each person’s file.

The first group had received waiting-list determinations; the second had received bona fide determinations, or BFDs. Both are interim processing stages, before final approval of U-visa status. The groups relied on different asserted legal duties and injuries, which led the court to analyze their claims separately.

Waiting-List Status and Interim Relief

Waiting-list placement reflects an eligibility determination subject to visa availability. Under 8 C.F.R. § 214.14(d)(2), USCIS “will grant deferred action or parole” while eligible petitioners remain on the waiting list. The court treated those forms of relief as alternatives. The domestic waiting-list plaintiffs had already received deferred action, so an additional parole grant remained discretionary. Their APA section 706(1) claim failed because that provision allows a court to compel only a discrete agency action the law requires.

Individual Travel Requests and Final Agency Action

The waiting-list plaintiffs’ section 706(2) claim required final agency action. They had neither alleged nor produced evidence that they individually requested advance parole and received denials. That missing record defeated this claim. For a person considering a challenge, the practical starting point is the exact request submitted and USCIS’s response, including whether the agency has reached a final decision.

Agency Inaction and the Duty to Act

A claim under section 706(1) asks a different question: Which discrete action does the law require USCIS to take? For the domestic waiting-list plaintiffs who had received deferred action, the court found parole discretionary. The BFD plaintiffs instead sought adjudication of waiting-list eligibility. Their claim returned to the district court for review of additional standing theories before any necessary merits analysis.

The BFD Plaintiffs’ Remaining Standing Theories

The panel agreed that the BFD plaintiffs’ lost-parole-opportunity theory failed because the undisputed record placed them in the same position as domestic waitlisted petitioners with deferred action. It remanded for consideration of other alleged injuries: The risk of losing evidence while full eligibility adjudication was delayed, accrual of unlawful presence (an argument first raised in the reply brief, leaving a possible forfeiture problem), and the difference between a regulatory waiting-list process and a changeable BFD policy. The district court must evaluate those theories, including the forfeiture question surrounding the unlawful-presence argument, and address the merits if necessary. Judge Bea would have dismissed the BFD claim for lack of statutory jurisdiction because he found no discrete legally required act.

Evidence and Record Implications for Your Own Case

Keep the notice identifying your processing stage, any deferred-action documentation, the specific travel request, proof of submission, and the agency’s response together. Those records help counsel distinguish a challenge to a final decision under section 706(2) from an attempt to compel required action under section 706(1). Identify the particular injury and legal duty supporting the proposed claim as well. For the separate custody issues involving BFD notices, see our analysis of U-visa bona-fide determination and detention.

Assess Departure and Reentry Risks Individually

Before planning international travel, review your individual immigration history and any travel authorization with counsel. Advance parole is discretionary and does not guarantee admission. A pending U-visa petition, BFD, or waiting-list notice alone is not travel authorization. Our case analysis explains the opinion’s APA reasoning in greater depth. If removal proceedings are pending, include that record in the assessment; our deportation-defense page provides related information.

Practical Takeaways for Petitioners Evaluating Next Steps

Start with your processing stage and the action you want USCIS to take. Then identify the legal duty, individual request, agency response, and claimed injury. This sequence helps separate the two APA routes addressed in the opinion. For related custody litigation, see our discussion of Vaca-Flores and pending U-visa status.

Questions About Your U-Visa Stage, Travel Request, and Agency Record

Does being on the U-visa waiting list give me the right to advance parole so I can travel?

Waiting-list status alone is not advance-parole authorization. The regulation says USCIS “will grant deferred action or parole,” and the court held that an additional parole grant remained discretionary for domestic waitlisted petitioners who already had deferred action.

What does my record need to show before I can challenge USCIS’s failure to act on a travel request in federal court?

For a section 706(2) challenge, identify the individual request and final agency response. The waiting-list plaintiffs’ claim failed because they had neither alleged nor produced evidence of individual requests and denials. A section 706(1) claim instead requires identifying a discrete agency action that the law requires.

What did the Ninth Circuit actually decide for bona-fide-determination petitioners, and what remains unresolved?

It remanded for the district court to evaluate additional alleged injuries, including evidence-loss risks, unlawful-presence accrual, and differences in regulatory stability. The district court must consider those standing theories and, if necessary, the merits. Judge Bea would have dismissed the claim for lack of statutory jurisdiction.

Talk to a U-Visa Attorney

Mishra X Trial Lawyers can assess your U-visa processing stage, travel request and USCIS response. Bring the petition receipt, waiting-list or bona-fide-determination notice, any travel request, proof of submission and USCIS response. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.