When a Tribal Employer Is Immune From a California Workers’ Comp Claim: United Indian Health Services
Deborah Hemstead was hurt in 2014 while working as a medical assistant for United Indian Health Services, a nonprofit that provides health care to Native people in and around Humboldt and Del Norte Counties. She first received benefits and treatment through the employer’s tribal workers’ compensation system. After a dispute, she filed a claim with California’s workers’ compensation system. The question was whether the state system could hear it at all.
It could not. In United Indian Health Services, Inc./Tribal First v. Workers’ Compensation Appeals Bd. (2025) 111 Cal.App.5th 1064, the First District Court of Appeal held that United Indian was an “arm of the tribe” entitled to tribal sovereign immunity, and it reversed the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board. In our reading, an employer that passes this test is outside the WCAB’s reach, and any remedy has to come from somewhere else, such as the tribal program. Whether a different tribal employer passes depends on its own records: how it was created, who controls it and whose money a judgment would take.
A clinic job, a tribal comp system and a state claim
United Indian argued that tribal sovereign immunity kept the state system from deciding the claim. In March 2024, the workers’ compensation judge rejected that defense. She found that four of the five factors California courts use weighed against immunity: United Indian was a California nonprofit, no evidence showed the tribes meant to share their immunity, its board “consisted of tribal members and others who may or may not be tribal members,” and a judgment would not reach tribal money. Only its health care purpose favored immunity.
On reconsideration, the judge conceded that United Indian’s funding argument was “well made,” but her overall conclusion did not change. The Board adopted her report and denied reconsideration. United Indian petitioned the Court of Appeal for a writ of review.
The five-factor “arm of the tribe” test
Indian tribes are immune from suit in state and federal courts unless Congress abrogates that immunity or the tribe waives it. The immunity can extend to an affiliated entity that is not itself a tribe. Under People v. Miami Nation Enterprises (2016) 2 Cal.5th 222, courts weigh five factors: how the entity was created, whether the tribe intended to share its immunity, the entity’s purpose, the tribe’s control over it and the financial connection between them.
No single factor decides the case. The entity claiming immunity must prove it by a preponderance of the evidence. The ultimate question is whether extending immunity would, as a practical matter, promote tribal self-governance and self-sufficiency. In Miami Nation itself, tribe-affiliated payday lenders lost because the tribes “relied heavily on outsiders” to create and run the businesses and drew little benefit from them. The Court of Appeal reviewed the immunity question de novo, without deferring to the Board.
How United Indian was created
Eighteen tribes formed the California Rural Indian Health Board, a tribal organization that contracts with the federal government under the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act to provide health services. United Indian is one of its subcontractors. At least nine federally recognized tribes passed resolutions authorizing the Health Board to contract with United Indian for their members’ care. Only the Yurok Tribe’s resolution described United Indian itself as a “legally established organization of Indians.”
United Indian was created by several tribes but incorporated under California law, which ordinarily weighs against immunity. The court held that this was not dispositive. This was not a tribe absorbing an outside commercial business. The tribes formed United Indian so that tribal organizations, not the federal government, would run their health care. On balance, the creation factor “tip[s] toward immunity.”
Health care purpose and tribal control favored immunity
Providing health care, the court agreed with the judge, “serves a purpose central to tribal self-sufficiency and self-governance.”
Control also favored immunity, in three ways. Each federally recognized participating tribe appoints a member to the board of directors, which runs the corporation, and a tribal director testified that the board in practice votes on resolutions, approves insurance contracts, receives reports and discusses litigation. The tribes keep approval power over United Indian’s contracts with the Health Board. And the Health Board must manage and monitor the work under the federal agreement, although the record did not show how closely it does so.
The judge had counted the board’s mixed membership against immunity. That was legal error. As Hemstead herself explained, the tribes appoint a majority of the board—nine members. The five members they do not appoint, who must themselves be American Indians registered for United Indian’s services, did not undercut that majority control.
A judgment would come out of tribal health funds
United Indian is funded by the Health Board, which receives federal money under its self-determination agreement. Under Miami Nation, immunity can be appropriate when a judgment would significantly reduce tribal resources, even if it would not be paid from a tribal treasury. Here, a judgment would reduce the money available for tribal members’ medical care. The court relied on a parallel Alaska Supreme Court decision, where such a judgment “would be effectively paid from the member tribes’ federal healthcare funding.”
No written intent to share immunity
The record contained no tribal document saying the tribes intended to extend their immunity to United Indian. Because the entity carries the burden, a silent record generally weighs against immunity. But intent can also be inferred from what tribes do, and here the tribes created and authorized United Indian to deliver their members’ health care under a federal system meant to advance self-governance. The factor therefore weighed “only somewhat against immunity.”
What the court decided
Weighing all five factors, the court held that “United Indian is entitled to sovereign immunity.” It reversed the Board’s order denying reconsideration and remanded for further proceedings consistent with the opinion. Filed May 20, 2025, the opinion was modified and certified for publication on June 10, 2025; the modifications did not change the judgment. United Indian did not claim to be a “tribal organization” under the federal Act, so the decision rests on the arm-of-the-tribe test alone.
The result depends on this entity’s record: tribal creation under the federal self-determination system, a tribe-appointed board majority that actually oversees the work, and federal health funds at risk. An affiliate run and funded by outsiders, with little tribal benefit, can come out the other way, as the lenders did in Miami Nation.
What workers and tribal employers should gather
- The employer’s legal identity. Find the exact entity on the pay stubs and benefit letters. A claims administrator’s name on a letter does not tell you who the employer is or how it was formed.
- Creation and control records. Articles, bylaws, tribal resolutions and board rosters show who formed the entity, who appoints the board and whether the board actually oversees the work.
- Funding. Self-determination contracts and grant records show whether a judgment would come out of tribal or federal health funds.
- The tribal program’s own rules. If immunity applies, the WCAB is not available even for an otherwise compensable injury. Read the tribal compensation program’s documents and deadlines early. Our workers’ compensation team can review those records to see which forum applies.
Later developments. On September 17, 2025, the California Supreme Court denied review (No. S291542).
- United Indian Health Services, Inc./Tribal First v. Workers’ Compensation Appeals Bd. (2025) 111 Cal.App.5th 1064, No. A170950 (Cal. Ct. App., 1st Dist., Div. 5, filed May 20, 2025, modified and certified for publication June 10, 2025) (opinion and publication order)
- Supreme Court of California, results from the petition conference of Sept. 17, 2025 (No. S291542, petition for review denied)
Evaluating a Claim Involving a Tribal Employer?
If a tribal employer or its claims administrator says the WCAB has no jurisdiction over your claim, bring the denial or objection, your pay stubs and benefit notices, any tribal program decision and its appeal deadlines, and any records you have on how the employer was formed. We can review whether the immunity factors fit your employer and which forum can hear the claim. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.