Stallion Springs: A Staffing Company Owed No Common-Law Fair-Procedure Hearing

Hospital contract divided from a peer-review chamber

Losing a hospital assignment did not make the staffing company responsible for a peer-review hearing. In Stallion Springs Medical Services v. Superior Court, No. F090834 (Cal. Ct. App. Sept. 2, 2026), the court distinguished a company that supplied emergency-room physicians from the hospital and medical staff that controlled staff membership. It directed judgment for the company on the remaining fair-procedure claim.

The hospital and staffing company had different powers

After a patient complaint, the hospital told Stallion Springs to remove physician Kuljit Hundal from the emergency-department schedule. The company complied, investigated and terminated its independent-contractor agreement with him. Hundal sued the hospital, medical staff and company. After settlement with the hospital and medical staff, only the claims against the company remained. Stallion Springs, pages 2–6.

The trial court rejected the emotional-distress claim but allowed the common-law fair-procedure claim to proceed. The staffing company challenged that ruling by a writ petition, asking the Court of Appeal to prevent a trial on the remaining claim. Stallion Springs, pages 6–8.

Scheduling work was not the same as controlling a profession

The common-law doctrine can require certain private organizations to make decisions that are both rational and procedurally fair. But the opinion did not treat every private decision affecting a livelihood as subject to that duty. It examined the organization’s public role and the kind of power it exercised. Stallion Springs, pages 9–10, 16–19.

Stallion Springs contracted with physicians to staff one hospital’s emergency department. It did not license doctors or control their ability to practice in the geographic area. The court found no evidence of the broader gatekeeping power on which Hundal’s argument depended. Losing this assignment was not enough to establish that power. Stallion Springs, pages 16–19.

The company could not restore hospital staff membership

The parties did not dispute that this staffing company was not a peer-review body under the statute discussed in the opinion. Its investigation and decision to end the agreement did not change that status. The hospital decided whether Hundal retained medical staff membership; the company could not restore it on its own even if a hearing before the company favored him. Stallion Springs, pages 13–14, 19–20.

The court expressly declined to decide the broader argument about the scope of Asiryan and statutory displacement of common-law protections. It resolved this case on the company’s role. The opinion also noted that the fair-procedure claim was based on removal from the hospital schedule, rather than contract termination as a separate basis. Stallion Springs, page 16 and page 20, footnote 7.

The court directed judgment for the staffing company

The Court of Appeal granted the writ. It directed the trial court to vacate the order denying summary judgment and enter an order granting the company’s motion in full. The claims against the hospital and medical staff had already been settled; this decision did not adjudicate their liability. Stallion Springs, pages 5, 21.

Identify who made the decision and who could reverse it

A scheduling notice, a termination letter and a decision about hospital privileges may involve different entities and different rights. Review each document against the role of its sender. The fact that the staffing company carried out the removal did not give it the hospital’s power over staff membership. That distinction mattered to the claim actually before the court.

Which records separate those decisions?

The Case Library contains further decisions, the Insights archive provides practical explanations and the practice-area pages describe the firm’s work. Do not substitute a general label such as “due process” for identifying the source of the particular right claimed.

Separate the scheduling claim from contract termination

Hundal’s fair-procedure claim challenged removal from the hospital schedule, not termination of his contract as a separate basis for relief. The court decided that this staffing company owed no common-law fair-procedure duty on that claim; the hospital and medical staff had already settled. Stallion Springs, pages 5, 16–21 & page 20 footnote 7.

Which decision ended your assignment?

For a California employment or contract dispute, Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review the agreements, removal instructions and termination notices to identify the issues and responsible parties. Bring the complete documents and any pending proceeding’s orders so we can assess the available next step. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.