Pantoja: Reconsideration Granted for a Limited Correction

A petition marked “granted” does not tell you which part of a decision changed. In its September 14, 2026 Pantoja decision, the WCAB corrected a finding to match two stipulated claim periods. It otherwise affirmed the result the employer had challenged: The earlier settlement did not bar the omitted neck claim. The correction and the settlement ruling must be read separately.
Pantoja v. United Parcel Service, Nos. ADJ13684015 and ADJ12299056 (WCAB Sept. 14, 2026), pages 1, 5–7. This analysis focuses on the limited correction. Our companion analysis of the omitted neck claim explains the settlement language and adequacy ruling.
The employer sought a bar to the neck claim
The employer was United Parcel Service; Liberty Mutual Insurance was also a defendant. The employer challenged the Board’s June 19, 2026 decision, arguing that an August 2020 compromise and release settled the potential neck injury along with the earlier cumulative-trauma claims. The June decision had found that the neck claim was not barred and had deferred all other issues. Pantoja, pages 1, 3.
Two claim numbers had different stipulated periods
The employer also argued that the neck claim had to proceed in the earlier back-injury case, partly because the Board had used the same injury dates for both. The September panel checked the April 1, 2021 trial minutes. The parties had stipulated to different claimed periods. Pantoja, pages 5–6.
| Case number | Period stated in the corrected finding | Claim described in that finding |
|---|---|---|
| ADJ12299056 | April 4, 2018–January 28, 2019 | Low back and bilateral lower extremities |
| ADJ13684015 | April 4, 2018–January 15, 2019 | Neck |
The table follows the operative finding on page 7. The discussion on pages 5–6 describes the underlying trial stipulations; the final order states the finding the Board actually substituted.
The correction left the settlement result intact
The panel identified a clerical error in Finding of Fact No. 1. It granted reconsideration solely to make the claimed dates match the trial stipulations, then affirmed the June decision in every other respect. The employer obtained that correction, but not a ruling that the neck claim had already been settled. Pantoja, pages 1, 5–7.
Claimed periods were not findings that an injury was compensable
The amended finding says the worker claims an injury arising out of and in the course of employment. It does not award neck benefits or decide the deferred issues. Nor does the listed exposure period establish a separate legal date-of-injury rule for every cumulative-trauma claim. Read the words of the finding and the issues left open before using its dates in another calculation. Pantoja, pages 1, 7.
Read the operative order before calling the petition a win
Here the order both granted a petition and affirmed the challenged decision with one amendment. Reading only “granted” would miss the result. Reading only the earlier decision would miss the corrected claim periods. The useful comparison is between the relief requested, the finding replaced and the rest of the order that remained in force.
Which documents show what actually changed?
- The earlier decision and the later decision after reconsideration.
- The petition identifying the relief requested.
- The trial minutes containing the stipulations.
- The amended findings, matched to each case number and claimed body part.
Keep unresolved issues separate from findings the Board actually made. If another case has different pleadings, stipulations or procedural history, this panel’s limited correction does not supply an automatic remedy.
Keep this panel decision within its limits
This three-commissioner WCAB panel corrected the settlement and pleading record for ADJ13684015 and ADJ12299056 while leaving the remaining issues deferred. The complete seven-page September 14 decision supplies the controlling text for this analysis.
What did the reconsideration order actually change?
Mishra X Trial Lawyers can compare your decisions, petition, trial stipulations and amended findings to identify which issues were resolved and which remain open in your California workers’ compensation case. Bring the complete orders and proofs of service so we can assess the available next step. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.