Illinois Midwest v. WCAB: Is Ongoing Care Exempt From Utilization Review?

Home health care request undergoing California workers’ compensation utilization review
The CA Supreme Court is reviewing whether previously authorized ongoing care must remain within the UR and IMR system.

Illinois Midwest Insurance Agency LLC v. WCAB, 115 Cal. App. 5th 1168 (2025), addresses renewed requests for previously approved home health care. For a worker facing a gap in care, the first practical question is what the existing approval covered: Which services, hours and end date? Put that approval beside the new request and the denial before assuming the same treatment means the same authorization.

The Court of Appeal said yes on these facts, but the CA Supreme Court has granted review.

Read the published opinion on CourtListener.

Important case-status update: The CA Supreme Court granted review in Illinois Midwest Insurance Agency LLC v. WCAB, No. S294463, on January 21, 2026. The opinion is not binding while review is pending. It may be cited for persuasive value and for the limited conflict-of-authority purpose specified in the Supreme Court’s order.

Read what the last authorization actually covered

Orlando Rodriguez suffered significant head and brain injuries while working as a mechanic in November 2016. The employer’s insurer accepted the injuries. Beginning in September 2018, his physician repeatedly requested home health care in six-week increments. Illinois Midwest, the insurer’s administrator, approved at least eight requests, some after utilization review. Each requested period was finite. A history of receiving care and the written duration of the approval are different facts; keep both. Illinois Midwest, slip opinion, pages 2–3.

Match the new request to the period of care being denied

In September 2019, the physician submitted another six-week request. A utilization-review physician denied it on medical-necessity grounds. Rodriguez sought an expedited WCJ hearing rather than obtaining relief through independent medical review. In another file, compare the denial’s service record, the care period requested and the treating physician’s supporting report. A letter declining the next period is not necessarily a cancellation of an unexpired approval. That distinction needs the actual papers, not the shorthand statement that care stopped. Illinois Midwest, slip opinion, pages 3–4, 25, footnote 6.

The WCJ and Board Applied Patterson

The judge found an ongoing and constant need for care. Relying on the significant-panel decision in Patterson v. The Oaks Farm, the judge held that the administrator could not stop care without substantive medical evidence of changed circumstances and treated the UR decision as moot. The Appeals Board affirmed in January 2025.

The Court Rejected an Ongoing-Treatment Exception

The Second District held that the post-2013 statutes contain no general exception for ongoing treatment. Each request sought only six weeks of care, so the September 2019 submission was a new request. Once a timely UR decision denied treatment on medical-necessity grounds, the statutory challenge was IMR, not adjudication of medical necessity by the WCAB.

Why Patterson Was Different

Patterson involved pre-2013 law, apparently open-ended nurse case-management services, and termination for a nonmedical reason without a UR medical-necessity decision. The court held that it could not be expanded to remove later, finite requests from the modern UR/IMR framework.

What the Court Left Open

The court did not decide whether a different analysis applies when an employer terminates authorized treatment without using UR or when parties stipulate to treatment and agree to forgo UR and IMR.

Prepare the next-period care review without waiting on the appeal

For an immediate care review, identify the last authorized date, the next requested period, the services actually being supplied and the reason stated for stopping or declining them. For example, a request for another six weeks of assistance presents a different document question from a provider being told to stop before an existing approval expires. Neither example establishes the result by itself.

Give the treating physician an accurate account of the current assistance needed and any imminent gap. Preserve the actual request, approval, denial and delivery records for counsel’s review of the appropriate process and deadline. The DWC’s current IMR instructions address medical-necessity review and the instructions on the received form; waiting for a Supreme Court decision is not a substitute for preserving a present response deadline.

Supreme Court Review Is Pending

The Supreme Court’s January 21, 2026 review order permits persuasive citation and the specified conflict-of-authority use while review is pending. Its official October 2, 2026 pending-issues summary still lists S294463 and the two ongoing-care questions. Those dated records do not decide the merits or guarantee the outcome of a current request. Check later case entries before relying on the opinion’s present status.

Have your utilization review denial evaluated

Mishra X Trial Lawyers can compare the existing approval, renewed request and denial to identify the care period and dispute that need attention. Bring the complete letters, delivery records and treating physician’s report, including any current gap in home assistance. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com to discuss your situation.