Mellouli v. Lynch: State Drug Convictions and Federal Schedules

State case file and federal statute book separated on a law desk

Mellouli v. Lynch, 575 U.S. 798, 800–02, 811–13 (2015), rejected removal based on a Kansas drug-paraphernalia conviction where the conviction did not establish a connection to a substance controlled under federal law. The state’s broad drug definition could not be treated as though every covered substance appeared on the federal schedules.

The conviction and the federal removal ground

Police found four tablets in Mellouli’s sock. A probable-cause affidavit identified Adderall, a substance controlled under both federal and Kansas law. But the amended paraphernalia complaint and plea did not identify the substance. The legally important gap was in what the conviction established, not a claim that investigators never knew what the pills were. Mellouli, 575 U.S. at 803, 806 n.5. Kansas regulated some substances not included in the federal controlled-substance schedules. The government charged him as removable under 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(2)(B)(i), which concerns a conviction for violating a law relating to a controlled substance as defined by federal law. An immigration judge ordered removal, the Board affirmed, and the Eighth Circuit denied review. Mellouli, 575 U.S. at 800–04.

The government also proposed a substantial-overlap theory: A state schedule covering many federally controlled drugs should suffice even if it covered extra substances. The Court rejected that shortcut. A broad relationship between the state law and drug activity did not replace the required link between an element of the conviction and a federally defined drug. Mellouli, 575 U.S. at 810–813. A schedule comparison should therefore identify the actual mismatch, not merely report that the lists are mostly similar.

The required federal connection

The majority held that the Board’s approach swept too broadly. The federal statute names substances defined in 21 U.S.C. § 802; it does not make every state paraphernalia conviction removable regardless of the substance. The Court used the categorical approach to compare the elements of the state offense with the federal removal ground and concluded that Mellouli’s conviction did not establish the required tie. Mellouli, 575 U.S. at 805–13.

The Court reversed because Mellouli’s conviction did not establish the required connection to a federally controlled drug. The majority rejected the government’s substantial-overlap reading of the state and federal schedules. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissented and would have read “relating to” to encompass the Kansas law despite its additional substances. Mellouli, 575 U.S. at 810–813; 813–821 (Thomas, J., dissenting).

What to compare in a current case

Start with the exact state statute and the law in effect at the relevant time. Determine whether it states separate crimes before considering a modified categorical inquiry. The Court described that method but expressly did not apply it in Mellouli because the government had not argued that it governed this case. Mellouli, 575 U.S. at 805 n.4. Here, the probable-cause affidavit identified Adderall, but the amended complaint and plea did not identify the substance. That difference explains why the police account did not supply the missing connection in the conviction on which removal rested. Mellouli, 575 U.S. at 803, 806 n.5.

Practical record review

Source: Supreme Court-hosted U.S. Reports volume 575. Citations above use reporter pagination.

Evaluate state drug convictions against federal schedules

Mishra X Trial Lawyers can analyze your state criminal record, record of conviction, charging documents, and plea agreements against the federal controlled substance schedules. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.