Zemanek: A Late Form 1040 Filled With Zeros Did Not Stop Three IRS Additions to Tax

An unmarked indigo caliper frames a brass machined piece beside blank folded and layered paper on cream linen.

A Form 1040 filed nearly six years late that claimed the standard deduction and left the other entries blank or zero did not count as a tax return, and the court sustained separate additions for late payment and underpaid estimated tax; the late-filing addition applied both because the form was not a valid return and because it came after the April 15, 2019 due date. In Zemanek v. Commissioner, No. 8984-25 (T.C. Nov. 4, 2026), Judge Kathleen Kerrigan of the U.S. Tax Court sustained a $15,170 deficiency for 2018 against a self-employed machinist whose PayPal income was reported on a Form 1099-K, along with additions for filing late, paying late and failing to pay estimated tax.

Judge Kerrigan delivered the decision as an oral bench opinion on November 4, 2026; the court served the transcript by order on November 16. It shows how the court applies settled rules to a familiar set of facts.

A machinist paid through PayPal

Mark Barry Zemanek, who lived in Washington when he petitioned the Tax Court, worked in 2018 as a self-employed machinist. His clients paid him, and he used PayPal to process their card payments and send invoices. For 2018, PayPal issued him a Form 1099-K reporting $63,229, and his credit union issued a Form 1099-INT reporting $50 of interest. The IRS account transcript showed no payments for 2018 (transcript pages 4 and 5).

On December 9, 2024, the IRS sent a CP2566 notice saying it had not received his 2018 return and had issued a section 6020(b) certification for a substitute return. Zemanek’s own 2018 Form 1040, signed and dated August 8, 2024 and January 27, 2025, was not filed until February 19, 2025. It claimed the $12,000 standard deduction and left the other entries blank or filled with zeros. The IRS’s March 3, 2025 notice of deficiency determined $15,170 of tax plus additions of $3,413 for filing late, $3,793 for paying late and $492 for the estimated-tax shortfall (transcript pages 3 and 4). He represented himself at trial in Seattle.

The 1099-K shifted the burden to him

A notice of deficiency is generally presumed correct, and the taxpayer must prove it wrong. In an unreported-income case, though, the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Weimerskirch v. Commissioner requires the IRS first to lay “some evidentiary foundation” linking the taxpayer to the income. That foundation is minimal. Once it is laid, the taxpayer must show by a preponderance of the evidence that the deficiency is arbitrary or erroneous (transcript pages 5 and 6).

The two information returns were enough. Zemanek did not dispute receiving the income, and he offered no valid argument that any of it was excludable. The court declined to answer his remaining arguments one by one, calling them “frivolous and groundless” (transcript pages 6 and 7).

Why a return of zeros was not a return

For each addition to tax, the IRS bears the burden of producing evidence that the addition applies; the taxpayer must then show it is wrong or prove a defense such as reasonable cause. Frivolous arguments are not reasonable cause (transcript pages 7 and 8).

Section 6651(a)(1) adds tax for failing to file a return on time. Whether a document counts as a return turns on the four-part test in Beard v. Commissioner, 82 T.C. 766 (1984): The document must contain enough data to calculate the tax, purport to be a return, reflect an honest and reasonable attempt to comply with the tax law, and be signed under penalties of perjury. Zemanek’s 1040 failed the first part. As the court put it, his “delinquent return was not a valid return because it did not contain sufficient data to calculate his tax liability.” It was also filed long after the April 15, 2019 due date. The addition applied (transcript page 8).

Late payment rested on the IRS’s substitute return

Section 6651(a)(2) adds tax for failing to pay the tax shown on a return. When the taxpayer has filed no valid return, the court explained, that addition can apply only if the IRS has prepared a substitute return. The IRS established that its 2018 substitute met section 6020(b), and Zemanek had paid nothing toward his 2018 tax. With no reasonable cause shown, this addition applied too (transcript page 9).

The estimated-tax addition

Section 6654 adds tax when an individual does not pay enough estimated tax during the year. It is measured against four required installments, each 25 percent of the “required annual payment,” and the IRS must produce evidence of what that required payment was. The court explained that the IRS must establish the tax shown on the preceding year’s return or show that no such return was filed. If no prior-year return was filed, the prior-year comparison is unavailable; the current-year benchmark is 90 percent of that year’s tax. The oral opinion then concluded that the addition applied, noting that Zemanek filed no valid 2018 return and paid no estimated tax for 2018, and that the IRS had prepared a substitute return (transcript pages 9 and 10). The court then announced that a decision would be entered for the IRS (transcript page 10).

What Zemanek means for a self-employed taxpayer

Our reading: A Form 1099-K is often all the IRS needs to start an unreported-income case, and after that the taxpayer carries the burden. A self-employed person who believes the tax is overstated needs evidence, such as the business records our Newton analysis discusses, not a document reporting zero. Zemanek’s form did not count as a return because it lacked enough data to calculate his tax; a return filed after the due date draws the late-filing addition unless the taxpayer shows reasonable cause. Once the IRS prepares a substitute return, the late-payment addition can follow as well. Check both the amounts paid and when they were paid, including any withholding; our guide to estimated-tax safe harbors explains the applicable calculations.

If an information-return mismatch is just starting, our guide to the CP2000 notice and the 90-day Tax Court deadline explains the steps that come before a case like this one.

Received a deficiency notice after a 1099-K?

Bring the notice of deficiency, any CP2566 or other IRS letters, the Forms 1099-K and 1099-INT, whatever return you filed, and your invoices, bank statements and expense records, so we can assess what the IRS must prove, what you can, and whether a Tax Court petition makes sense. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.