Trump v. J.G.G.: Every Justice Agreed on Notice. They Split Over Where to Sue.

As Justice Sotomayor’s dissent recounts, the government began sending Venezuelan detainees to a prison in El Salvador in March 2025 under the Alien Enemies Act (AEA), a 1798 law. Lawyers who anticipated their clients’ deportation sued in Washington, D.C., and a judge blocked the removals. On April 7, 2025, a divided Supreme Court set aside the judge’s orders in Trump v. J.G.G., 604 U.S. 670 (2025). This was an emergency ruling, not a decision on whether the removals were lawful. The Court decided where such challenges belong, and it said detainees must get notice in time to bring one.
The orders that were set aside
President Trump’s Proclamation No. 10903 invoked the Alien Enemies Act to detain and remove Venezuelan nationals “who are members of” Tren de Aragua, which the State Department has designated a foreign terrorist organization. Five detainees and a proposed class sued. They had first sought habeas relief, a petition asking a court to review whether someone is lawfully held, among other claims, but they dismissed the habeas claims. A federal judge in the District of Columbia issued temporary restraining orders, short emergency court orders, blocking any removal of the named plaintiffs and blocking removal under the Act of a provisionally certified class, a group the judge temporarily allowed to sue together, of noncitizens in U.S. custody subject to the Proclamation. The D.C. Circuit declined to stay the orders, meaning put them on hold, and the government applied to the Supreme Court.
Why the case was in the wrong court
The Court said it did not reach the detainees’ arguments about the meaning of the Act or whether they fall within it. Instead, it held that challenges to removal under the Act “must be brought in habeas.” It reasoned that the claims “necessarily imply the invalidity” of confinement and removal, quoting earlier decisions, and so fall within the core of habeas, the kind of claim that must be brought as a habeas petition, even if the detainees did not formally request release.
That determined the location. For core habeas petitions, the Court said, quoting Rumsfeld v. Padilla, 542 U.S. 426 (2004), “jurisdiction lies in only one district: the district of confinement.” The detainees were held in Texas, so venue, the place where a case must be filed, was improper in the District of Columbia, and the Court concluded the government was likely to succeed in this action. The Court treated the temporary restraining orders as appealable injunctions, a step Justice Sotomayor’s dissent disputed as beyond the Court’s jurisdiction. It then vacated the orders, which cancelled them.
What the Court said about notice
In our view, the opinion’s second half matters most to a detained person. Although review under the Act is limited, the Court said a person subject to it is entitled to judicial review of “questions of interpretation and constitutionality” of the Act and of whether the person “is in fact an alien enemy fourteen years of age or older,” quoting Ludecke v. Watkins, 335 U.S. 160 (1948). The government, the Court noted, expressly agreed that “TdA members subject to removal under the Alien Enemies Act get judicial review.” TdA is Tren de Aragua. The Court said the Fifth Amendment entitles noncitizens to due process in removal proceedings, quoting Reno v. Flores, 507 U.S. 292 (1993), so these detainees are entitled to notice and an opportunity to be heard “appropriate to the nature of the case,” quoting Mullane v. Central Hanover Bank & Trust Co., 339 U.S. 306 (1950).
The Court then set the rule: detainees “must receive notice after the date of this order that they are subject to removal under the Act,” and the notice must come “within a reasonable time and in such a manner as will allow them to actually seek habeas relief in the proper venue before such removal occurs.”
Its answer to the dissents was short. The order and opinion, it said, “confirm that the detainees subject to removal orders under the AEA are entitled to notice and an opportunity to challenge their removal. The only question is which court will resolve that challenge.”
The separate opinions
Justice Kavanaugh agreed, and he stressed that all nine justices accept that judicial review is available. The only question, he wrote, was where. Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson, and by Justice Barrett as to Parts II and III-B, dissented. She wrote that “we all agree” with the per curiam’s command on notice, that this agreement on notice and review “should have been the end of the matter,” and that the Court’s conclusion about habeas was “suspect.” Her dissent also objected that the Court lacked jurisdiction over the orders and that equitable relief was unwarranted given the government’s conduct. She also described the government’s moves in detail, including detainees being put on planes during the litigation. Justice Jackson also dissented.
What this means if someone is detained
These points are our practical reading of J.G.G.
- Location comes first. In our view, the first fact to establish is where the person is physically held, because a petition filed elsewhere may be dismissed.
- Do not drop habeas. The plaintiffs here had dismissed their habeas claims. The Court held that these challenges must be brought in habeas, in the district of confinement. In our view, a lawyer should not plead around that requirement.
- Use the notice requirement. In our view, a person who receives a notice should contact a lawyer immediately, so that a habeas petition can be filed in the district of confinement before removal occurs.
- Keep the limits in mind. The ruling addressed the Alien Enemies Act. It did not decide whether the Proclamation is valid.
For help with detention, see our deportation defense practice.
Is someone you know being moved or removed?
Find out where the person is held, and bring any notice. We can review what can be filed and in which court. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.