Salazar v. Driver Provider: One Commission Plan Can Support a Class Claim for Unpaid Pre- and Post-Trip Work

When every worker is paid under the same commission plan and all claim it does not pay for the same required work before and after each job, whether the plan covers that work is a common question that can support a class action. A worker’s personal belief about how they were paid does not defeat it. The Ninth Circuit so held for chauffeurs suing under Arizona wage law, and also held that the federal Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) does not preempt a state claim that borrows the FLSA’s overtime standard. One judge dissented on the class and civil-penalty rulings, and the reversal sends the case back for further proceedings, not a class-wide win.
The decision is Salazar v. Driver Provider Phoenix, LLC, Nos. 24-6575 & 24-6914 (9th Cir. Nov. 18, 2026), a published opinion by Judge Desai, joined by Judge Mendoza. Judge Collins concurred in the judgment in part and dissented in part.
Chauffeurs paid by the ride for work before and after it
The Driver Provider runs a luxury car service in Arizona, Utah and Wyoming and paid chauffeurs a percentage of each ride’s base rate under a commission plan; a top-level sedan driver, for example, received $23.94 of a $70.40 flat-rate ride. The company also required work outside the rides: arriving an hour before the first ride, inspecting and checking out vehicles, arriving at pick-ups 15 minutes early, fueling, cleaning and post-trip inspections. Its software tracked ride time but not that work.
What the chauffeurs appealed
The chauffeurs sued in 2019 under the FLSA, the Arizona Minimum Wage Act and the Arizona Wage Act (AWA). The district court ruled against them three times: It held the FLSA preempted their Arizona overtime claims, on a defense the company first raised in September 2022, well after the deadline to amend pleadings; denied class certification of their unpaid straight-time claims; and barred private recovery of Arizona’s civil penalties for record-keeping violations. The parties settled most remaining claims but preserved these issues for appeal, and three putative class members who had not settled their straight-time claims intervened to appeal the class ruling.
The FLSA sets a floor, not a ceiling
The majority first held the late preemption defense was allowed under Rule 12(h)(2) because it appeared on the face of the complaint, though this is not a broad license for other unpleaded defenses.
The company argued obstacle preemption: Arizona’s claim offers treble damages and opt-out class actions, while the FLSA provides double damages, opt-in collective actions and a bar on private suits when the Secretary of Labor brings a qualifying action to stop further delay in paying those wages. The court explained the relationship this way: “the FLSA dictates what an employer owes its employee, and the AWA dictates when those wages must be paid.” The FLSA lacks the special features that would show Congress meant its remedies to be exclusive. It expressly lets states set more protective standards, so “it would be illogical to conclude the FLSA impliedly forbids states from adopting identical standards and enforcing those standards through state causes of action.” The FLSA’s purpose of protecting workers is advanced, not thwarted, by added state remedies.
One pay plan, one common question
On the class ruling, the court first held it had jurisdiction. The court-approved settlement and dismissal was a final judgment, and the three intervenors kept a personal stake in their unsettled claims. The court rejected the dissent’s reliance on Microsoft Corp. v. Baker, 582 U.S. 23 (2017), because the intervenors did not voluntarily dismiss their claims; the case ended in a court-approved settlement both sides reached.
Under the Arizona Wage Act, wages are compensation for which the employee “has a reasonable expectation to be paid whether determined by a time, task, piece, commission or other method of calculation.” The district court found no commonality because chauffeurs had different expectations: Some knew they were on commission, and others thought they were hourly.
The parties agreed on two facts: All chauffeurs were paid under the same commission plan, and their pre- and post-trip work was compensable. Commonality held, the court said, whether the claim rested on an express or an implied contract. The common question was whether the plan in fact paid for that work, and its answer would resolve a central issue for every class member in one stroke. “[I]ndividual chauffeurs’ subjective understandings of their pay do not change the undisputed fact that all chauffeurs were paid under the same commission plan,” the court wrote. Reasonable expectation is measured objectively. Because the district court used a subjective standard, it abused its discretion.
Civil penalties and the cross-appeal
The court also held that private plaintiffs may recover the Minimum Wage Act’s civil penalties for record-keeping violations, because the statute lets both the state agency and private parties sue “to enforce this article.” It dismissed the company’s cross-appeal of the settled FLSA rulings as moot.
Judge Collins’s separate opinion
Judge Collins agreed the FLSA does not wholly preempt the Arizona overtime claim but would have left open whether it bars specific state additions, such as an opt-out class action. He would have found no jurisdiction over the class ruling because the intervenors agreed to dismissal of claims that were never litigated. On the merits, he would have affirmed: The written plan says nothing about pre- and post-trip duties and has no integration clause, so whether each driver had an implied promise of extra pay was an individual question. He read the majority as not requiring certification on remand, because the other Rule 23 requirements remain unresolved.
What this means for unpaid off-the-clock work
These points are our reading of the opinion.
- The pay plan is the evidence. If one written plan governs everyone and omits required tasks such as inspections, fueling or early arrival, the case can turn on what that plan covers rather than on each worker’s story. The court applied Arizona’s definition of wages; a California claim would be measured by California’s own pay rules (see our analysis of Troester v. Starbucks), but a single company-wide plan can still supply the common question in a federal class action.
- Ask which law supplies the overtime right. The Arizona claim used the federal overtime standard and state remedies. The Ninth Circuit allowed that combination for this Arizona claim, a distinction that matters in California when a state claim uses a federal wage standard.
- The case is not over. The other class requirements remain open, and the company may press its overtime-exemption defenses against the reinstated claims.
Not paid for work before or after your shifts?
Bring your pay plan or offer letter, pay stubs, schedules and any rules about arriving early, inspecting equipment or waiting for assignments. We can review whether that time should have been paid and whether coworkers share the same claim. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.