Pierre-Louis: The BIA Won’t Reopen an Old Removal Case So an “Arriving Alien” Can Seek a Green Card From USCIS

A person classified as an “arriving alien” who is under a final removal order generally cannot get the Board of Immigration Appeals to reopen the case on its own motion just to wait while U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) decides a green-card application. In Matter of Pierre-Louis, 30 I&N Dec. 212 (BIA 2026), a published decision dated October 30, 2026, the Board denied a Haitian man’s third motion to reopen and terminate his case, filed after his wife became a U.S. citizen.
The ruling is about discretion, not power. The case arose in the Ninth Circuit, where the Board accepted that it has authority to reopen. It declined to use it and pointed to a stay request with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).
A removal order, an approved petition and three motions
Jonas Pierre-Louis was served with a notice to appear in February 2017 that classified him as an “arriving alien.” Under 8 C.F.R. § 1001.1(q), that classification, which covers people who sought admission at a port of entry, continues even after parole into the country. An immigration judge denied his applications and ordered him removed on September 19, 2018. While his appeal was pending, he asked the Board to let the judge decide a green-card application based on an approved petition from his wife, then a permanent resident. The Board dismissed the appeal on February 3, 2021, which made the removal order final, and denied that request, noting that USCIS alone decides arriving aliens’ adjustment applications.
The Board denied a first motion to reopen and terminate in March 2023 and a second, based on his Temporary Protected Status, in October 2024.
The third motion, filed March 24, 2025, said his wife had naturalized, making a visa immediately available to him as a citizen’s spouse. It also described her psychological disorders and the hardship his removal would cause her and their two children.
Why only USCIS could decide his green card
Under 8 C.F.R. § 1245.2(a)(1)(ii), an immigration judge has no jurisdiction over an arriving alien’s adjustment application except in a narrow situation: The person properly filed with USCIS while in the United States, traveled and returned on advance parole to pursue that application, USCIS denied it, and DHS placed the person in removal proceedings either upon return on advance parole or after the denial. Our I-130 and I-485 guide covers this rule.
The application sits with USCIS, but the removal order stays in force, and a motion to reopen does not by itself stop removal under 8 C.F.R. § 1003.2(f). In Singh v. Holder, 771 F.3d 647 (9th Cir. 2014), the Ninth Circuit described the stakes: If the person is removed, the pending application is treated as abandoned, and removal brings a bar on returning that, for the petitioner in that case, lasted 10 years.
What Singh held and what the Board added
Filed more than four years after the final order, his third motion was late and over the one-motion limit, and he did not argue that any exception applied. That left the Board’s own-motion power under 8 C.F.R. § 1003.2(a), which the Board described as limited to exceptional situations.
Singh held that the Board has the power to reopen a final order so a person can pursue a green-card application before USCIS, because the regulation says the Board “may at any time reopen or reconsider on its own motion any case in which it has rendered a decision.” Singh involved a timely motion. The court sent the case back for the Board to exercise its discretion and expressed “no opinion on how that discretion should be exercised.”
Pierre-Louis answers that discretion question. The Board ruled that it generally will not reopen a case on its own motion while a third party decides an application the Board cannot decide. Its reasons: Limited resources are best spent on matters the judges and the Board can decide, and the person can ask DHS for a stay while USCIS acts. Because the case arose in the Ninth Circuit, the Board treated Singh as binding and accepted that its lack of jurisdiction over the application “does not necessarily preclude” reopening. It then declined to reopen, concluding that it “generally will not exercise its discretion to reopen proceedings sua sponte for an arriving alien to pursue adjustment of status before USCIS.”
Why a citizen spouse was not exceptional
The Board repeated that own-motion reopening is not meant to “otherwise circumvent the regulations, where enforcing them might result in hardship,” quoting Matter of J-J-.
The Board added that the circumstances must be “sufficiently compelling,” quoting Matter of G-D-. A request to reopen so an arriving alien can wait on USCIS, the Board wrote, is “a common situation, not an exceptional one, and does not meet this high standard.”
Applying that standard to his wife’s naturalization, the Board found no exceptional situation. Our analysis of Yadav covers the related rule for people who marry a citizen after a removal order.
The Board’s alternative: a stay from DHS
The Board’s alternative, a DHS stay of removal, in practice means asking Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) with Form I-246.
Singh had noted, from counsel’s argument, a reason that route is weaker: A DHS stay denial would not be subject to court review, while a Board reopening denial would be, “at least if issued under” § 1003.2(c), which governs ordinary motions to reopen. The court said that difference may be an “important consideration” in the Board’s discretion. The Board answered that this point is “inapposite” because he sought reopening on the Board’s own motion under § 1003.2(a), not under § 1003.2(c).
What this means in California
These points are our reading of the decision and current Ninth Circuit law.
- Court review of this kind of denial is narrow. Under Bonilla v. Lynch, 840 F.3d 575 (9th Cir. 2016), the Ninth Circuit may review a refusal to reopen on the Board’s own motion only “for the limited purpose of reviewing the reasoning behind the decisions for legal or constitutional error.” A refusal resting on a legal mistake, such as the Board’s mistaken belief in Singh that it lacked power, can be sent back; a reasoned refusal like this one generally cannot be reviewed.
- Timing matters. Pierre-Louis addresses a late, number-barred request that depends on the Board’s own-motion power. A motion filed within 90 days of the final order, or one DHS agrees to file jointly under 8 C.F.R. § 1003.2(c)(3)(iii), follows different rules.
- Keep two tracks moving. A pending USCIS application does not stop removal unless a stay is granted, so pursue the stay as actively as the green-card filing.
Under a removal order with a green-card case at USCIS?
Bring your notice to appear and any I-94 or parole papers showing how you entered, the judge’s order and every Board decision, each earlier motion, your I-130 approval and I-485 receipt, and any stay request you have filed. We can review whether a timely or joint motion, a stay request or another route fits your case. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.