Perry: The Employer’s Knowledge Mattered to an EEOC Retaliation Claim

A worker holds a closed envelope while standing outside an office door.

Domeneque Perry alleged that her employer fired her in retaliation after she reported a matter to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of her federal retaliation claim. The complaint lacked facts that plausibly showed her employer knew about the report before it fired her. Memorandum at 2.

The court took a fresh look at the dismissal

Perry represented herself in the appeal. The district court dismissed her employment case before the defendants were served. The Ninth Circuit reviewed the dismissal anew under 28 U.S.C. § 1915(e)(2)(B)(ii), which requires a court to dismiss a case proceeding under the federal in forma pauperis statute if the complaint fails to state a claim. The appellate court looked at whether the facts alleged, accepted as true at this stage, gave rise to a plausible claim. Memorandum at 1–3.

The two events needed a plausible connection

The panel drew on Lui v. DeJoy for the causal link between protected activity and an adverse employment action under Title VII. Perry’s allegations supplied the beginning and end of the sequence, an EEOC report and a firing. They left a gap in between. The judges needed enough facts to infer that her employer knew of the report before the firing. The dismissal rested on that gap in the complaint. It left actual employer knowledge unresolved. Memorandum at 2.

The published case shows why the later proof is different

In Lui, after the parties had developed a record, the employee challenged her demotion by the Postal Service. One of the misconduct charges involved her handling of a harassment complaint. The official who confirmed the demotion said she had excluded that charge from her penalty assessment and relied on two other charges. The panel held that Lui had produced no evidence supporting her argument that the official’s reasons concealed a retaliatory motive. Lui v. DeJoy, slip op. at 20–21.

The two decisions show where a retaliation claim can break down. At Perry’s stage, the judges looked for facts plausibly connecting the employer’s knowledge to the sequence alleged. In Lui, the court had the official’s actual explanation and considered whether the employee had evidence disputing it. Learning of a complaint and deciding to act because of it are separate questions. Perry memorandum at 2 and Lui, slip op. at 20–21.

Trace who learned about the complaint and when

Suppose a worker sends a report to the EEOC on Monday, the company’s HR office receives notice on Wednesday, and a supervisor recommends dismissal on Friday. Monday’s confirmation documents the report. Wednesday’s notice may show when someone at the company learned of it. Other records may show whether the person who made or influenced the decision learned of the report before acting. An approval sent earlier in the week could change the picture even if the worker heard about the dismissal on Friday. EEOC enforcement guidance on employer knowledge and timing.

Put the report, notice, recommendation and approval on the same timeline. Include the dismissal notice, any prior warnings and any subsequent change in the employer’s stated reason. A message forwarding the report can answer a different question from the report itself. For workers in Southern California dealing with discipline after an internal report, our guide to retaliation after an HR complaint explains how California law treats that separate situation.

The Arizona claim and the requests to continue the case

Perry also brought a retaliatory termination claim under the Arizona Employment Protection Act. The panel affirmed dismissal because her allegations did not sufficiently show that she was fired for activity protected by that Arizona statute. The statute addresses specified disclosures about violations of Arizona law. Memorandum at 2.

The panel held that the district court could dismiss this action before directing service. It also affirmed the refusal to allow another amendment, which the court deemed futile, and the refusal to reconsider because Perry had not established a basis for relief. The panel denied the pending motions and affirmed the dismissal. Memorandum at 2–3.

Decision

Perry v. Tiffany & Bosco, P.A., No. 26-3501 (9th Cir. Nov. 20, 2026). The Ninth Circuit issued an unpublished memorandum, generally nonprecedential under Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3. It affirmed the District of Arizona’s dismissal.

Questions about workplace retaliation?

Bring the communications about your complaint and any notice of the employer’s decision so we can help you identify which records matter. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.