Pal v. Commissioner: Moving Money and Stock From Your IRA to Your Own Accounts Was a Taxable Early Distribution

The Tax Court treated $229,857 a California engineer moved from his E*Trade IRA into his own brokerage and bank accounts in 2021 as taxable distributions, including stock transferred in kind. It sustained the 10% early-distribution tax and a 20% penalty on the portion of his underpayment attributable to the substantial understatement. The records traced every transfer to the IRA, whose account number had changed in 2023.
Judge Lauber decided Pal v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-93 (Sept. 24, 2026), Docket No. 16983-24, a memorandum opinion issued after a remote trial on June 9, 2026, at which Aloke Pal represented himself.
An IRA, a brokerage account and a checking account
After working for Boeing and Modine Manufacturing, Mr. Pal rolled his retirement plan money into an E*Trade IRA, then numbered ending 1601. He also had a regular E*Trade brokerage account ending 1455 and a Wells Fargo checking account. During 2021 he made hundreds of trades inside the IRA and frequent transfers out of it.
Morgan Stanley issued a Form 1099-R reporting $229,856.80 of 2021 distributions from account 1601, with distribution code 1, “[e]arly distribution, no known exception.” Mr. Pal and his wife reported no retirement distributions on their joint 2021 return. In August 2024 the IRS issued a notice of deficiency determining an $80,292 deficiency, including a $22,986 early-distribution tax, plus a $16,058 penalty.
His petition said E*Trade had “used all my 401k and pension” and “reported false distribution[s] to IRS,” that he had not received a Form 1099-R, and that he “did not recognize ACCT number on the 1099–R.”
Who had to prove what
An IRA distribution generally counts as taxable income. Basis from nondeductible contributions can reduce the taxable portion. The taxpayer generally bears the burden of proving the notice of deficiency wrong. For unreported income, the IRS must first link the taxpayer to the income, and the court said a third-party Form 1099 is enough to do that. The burden then returns to the taxpayer.
Under section 6201(d), the IRS must produce additional evidence if the taxpayer reasonably disputes an item on the form in court and has fully cooperated with the IRS. The court found Mr. Pal had not raised a reasonable dispute, because he offered no evidence for his assertions that E*Trade took his money, and the records confirmed the Form 1099-R.
How the records traced every transfer
The IRS subpoenaed Morgan Stanley and obtained statements from Wells Fargo. When Mr. Pal answered the IRS’s motion to deem its proposed stipulation established only by calling the IRS’s evidence “patently incredible,” without identifying specific disputed paragraphs as the court’s rules require, the court granted the motion and admitted the bank and brokerage records.
Those records broke the $229,857 into three parts:
- $37,460 in cash to Wells Fargo. The IRA statements showed each transfer as an “ACH withdrawal,” and the Wells Fargo statements showed the deposits as coming from “E*Trade ACH . . . 1601,” the IRA’s number.
- $120,013 in cash to his brokerage account, mostly $55,000 and $65,000 on January 26, 2021, each shown on the IRA statements as going to the account ending 1455.
- $72,384 in stock to his brokerage account, in May, November and December 2021, valued from the IRA statements. He sold most of the shares shortly afterward, and the share counts matched his brokerage Form 1099.
At trial Mr. Pal acknowledged that he “moved money back and forth” between the two E*Trade accounts but said he could not confirm which account the transfers came from. When the court asked where the shares could have come from, if not the IRA, he had no comprehensible answer. The court concluded he had simply forgotten that the IRA’s number changed from 1601 to 2205 in 2023, and sustained the unreported income.
The 10% additional tax and the 20% penalty
Section 72(t) adds a 10% tax to the taxable part of a distribution from a qualified retirement plan, unless an exception applies, such as disability or certain medical or education expenses, or the owner has reached 59½. Mr. Pal confirmed he was under 59½ in 2021 and claimed no exception, so the $22,986 additional tax stood.
For the 20% accuracy-related penalty, he had reported $20,528 of tax against a correct tax of $100,420, a substantial understatement. The IRS also showed written supervisory approval under section 6751(b): The revenue agent’s manager approved the penalty on May 20, 2024, before the notice of deficiency, the first time the penalty was communicated to him. The court found that timely under its own precedent and under the rule of the Ninth Circuit, where an appeal would generally go, in Laidlaw’s Harley Davidson Sales, Inc. v. Commissioner, 29 F.4th 1066, 1074 (9th Cir. 2022), that approval is timely if obtained while the supervisor still has discretion to approve the penalty, as the manager did before the examination ended.
His reasonable-cause defense failed. The court did not believe his testimony that he did not know where the money came from, observing: “One may enjoy a large bank error in one’s favor when playing Monopoly, but this rarely if ever happens in the real world.” Forgetting a changed account number was not reasonable cause; an engineer with his experience could not reasonably have misunderstood that IRA distributions are taxable.
Result, status and what the case means
The Tax Court entered its order and decision for the deficiency, additional tax and penalty on September 25, 2026. Mr. Pal filed a notice of appeal on October 3. The Tax Court’s docket records transmission of the record to the Ninth Circuit on October 15, 2026, its last entry when checked on November 19.
Our reading: An IRA does not stop being an IRA because you also have a regular account at the same firm. Money or shares moved from the IRA to your own taxable account are a distribution, whether or not you spend them. An eligible distribution can avoid current tax through a rollover to an IRA within 60 days. Section 408(d)(3) generally limits IRA-to-IRA rollovers to one per 12-month period. If a Form 1099-R lists an account you do not recognize, ask the custodian for a letter showing any number changes and the statements for the year before you dispute the form. Our analysis of Braun shows how the same Form 1099-R burden rules worked for a lapsed life insurance policy.
Got a notice for IRA distributions you do not recognize?
Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review the Form 1099-R, your custodian’s statements and any account-number changes, and the notice of deficiency to see what the IRS can prove, whether an exception or rollover applies, and whether the penalty was properly approved. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.