Pablo Pablo: An Asylum Applicant Must Get a Chance to Explain an Inconsistency Before It Is Used

A tabletop microphone, hearing papers and a hand raised to explain.

If an immigration judge called your asylum testimony inconsistent, the Ninth Circuit requires that you first had a chance to explain the conflict. In Pablo Pablo v. Blanche, No. 25-7609 (9th Cir. Nov. 17, 2026), the court granted a mother’s petition because one conflict was never put to her and the agency never explained why her husband’s inconsistent account undermined hers. A third conflict still stood, so the court sent the case back for the agency to reassess credibility.

The decision is an unpublished memorandum, not precedent under Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3. Judge Tung concurred, urging the court to abandon the opportunity-to-explain rule.

A police stop described three ways

Elidia Florinda Pablo Pablo sought asylum, withholding of removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture. Her minor son appealed only as a derivative on her asylum application, so the withholding and torture claims are hers alone.

On September 15, 2021, Guatemalan police stopped the car carrying Pablo, her husband and her son. The immigration judge found her not credible, and the Board of Immigration Appeals affirmed based on three inconsistencies:

Two findings failed the Ninth Circuit’s rule

Credibility findings get deferential, substantial-evidence review, subject to a procedural rule. In Soto-Olarte v. Holder, 555 F.3d 1089, 1092 (9th Cir. 2009), the court held that a judge could not base an adverse credibility finding on discrepancies the applicant was never asked about or given a chance to reconcile. The court restated the rule in Barseghyan v. Garland, 39 F.4th 1138, 1145 (9th Cir. 2022): “Before relying upon a purported inconsistency to make an adverse credibility determination, the fact finder must provide the applicant with an opportunity to explain each inconsistency.” If the explanation is “reasonable and plausible,” the fact finder “must state a ‘specific and cogent’ reason for rejecting it.”

The first conflict failed that test: The judge never asked Pablo why her testimony left out the physical harm her declaration described. Because she never had that chance, the panel held that “the agency cannot rely on this inconsistency.”

The second failed because the inconsistency was in her husband’s account, and the agency never explained why it bore on her truthfulness. Under Bandari v. INS, 227 F.3d 1160, 1166 (9th Cir. 2000), the court will not uphold a credibility finding “unless the IJ or BIA specifically explains the significance of the discrepancy . . . .”

The slaps: A chance to explain that was enough

The third conflict survived. When the judge asked Pablo to clarify, she said the officer “slap[ped] [E.E.P.P.] on his head” and “hit [him] about three times.” The panel held that “[a] reasonable factfinder could conclude that a relentless beating would entail a degree of harm greater than three slaps.”

In the panel’s words, “the opportunity to explain requirement was fully satisfied” when the judge asked her to explain the conflict, and the judge did not have to ask further whether her background affected how she perceived the degree of harm to her son. The judge need not ask every question personally: Under Barseghyan, 39 F.4th at 1143, the opportunity “can occur through direct or cross-examination.” Our analysis of Matter of Y-I-M- covers the Board’s version.

Why the case went back to the agency

One inconsistency remained: a difference in how much harm she described, not a clear falsehood or fabrication. In Alam v. Garland, 11 F.4th 1133, 1134, 1137 (9th Cir. 2021) (en banc), the court overruled the circuit’s “single factor rule” and held that review must assess the “totality of the circumstances.” Barseghyan, 39 F.4th at 1146, applied that standard by remanding for the Board to decide whether a single remaining inconsistency was enough.

The panel relied on Kumar v. Garland, 18 F.4th 1148, 1155–56 (9th Cir. 2021), which, in the panel’s description, remanded when the remaining inconsistency was not a “clear falsehood[] [or] fabrication[].” Kumar left the Board “to determine in the first instance whether the remaining factors—considered on their own—suffice to support an adverse credibility determination” (18 F.4th at 1156). Because the Board never judged eligibility apart from credibility, the panel, following Soto-Olarte, 555 F.3d at 1096, also left asylum, withholding and torture protection for the agency to decide in the first instance.

Our reading: The agency now decides whether the slaps conflict, weighed with the whole record, still supports an adverse credibility finding; if not, it reaches each claim’s merits. The court also granted stays of removal.

A due process claim left out of the appeal brief

The court would not consider Pablo’s claim that she was denied a full and fair hearing, a correctable procedural error she listed in her notice of appeal but left out of her Board brief. Under Abebe v. Mukasey, 554 F.3d 1203, 1208 (9th Cir. 2009) (en banc) (per curiam), a petitioner who files a brief is “deemed to have exhausted only those issues he raised and argued in his brief before the BIA.” The inconsistencies were different: The Board decided them on the merits, so the court could review them.

Judge Tung’s concurrence

Judge Tung voted to grant because “[o]ur circuit’s precedent (good or bad) binds me,” but wrote that the precedent is “clearly erroneous.” In his view, deferential review should have meant denial: A reasonable adjudicator could have found Pablo not credible from her changing descriptions of the stop and her husband’s similar inconsistency.

He likened it to the Ninth Circuit’s rule treating testimony as credible absent an explicit adverse finding, which the Supreme Court rejected in Garland v. Ming Dai, 593 U.S. 357 (2021), and wrote that no other circuit imposes the opportunity-to-explain rule categorically. He hopes the court will “soon correct” it. For now the rule binds.

What to check in your hearing record

These points are our reading of the decision.

Status as of November 20, 2026: The time for either side to seek rehearing had not yet run, and we found no later order in the court’s public records.

Was your asylum case denied on credibility?

Bring your declaration, Form I-589, hearing transcript, both decisions, and your Board notice of appeal and brief. We can compare each inconsistency relied on with what you were actually asked and answered. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.