Ontiveros-Diaz: Missing the Voluntary Departure Deadline Barred Cancellation, Even on Reopening

An ochre ribbon curls on pale stone beside a narrow gap, with a dark blue stone on the other side.

A person who voluntarily stays in the United States after a voluntary departure deadline is barred for 10 years from cancellation of removal, and a motion to reopen filed after that deadline does not lift the bar, even when the motion only adds new evidence for the same cancellation application. The Board of Immigration Appeals so held in Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz, 30 I&N Dec. 222 (BIA 2026), Interim Decision #4272, decided November 5, 2026. The timing is the key limit: A motion filed during the departure period automatically ends the voluntary departure grant and its penalties. In the alternative, the three-member panel held that the new evidence would not likely have changed the hardship result.

Fourteen days past the deadline

Daniel Ontiveros-Diaz applied for cancellation of removal for nonpermanent residents. The immigration judge found he had not shown that his United States citizen children would suffer “exceptional and extremely unusual hardship” if he were removed. On April 4, 2025, the Board dismissed his appeal and reinstated voluntary departure for 60 days, through June 3, 2025. He did not leave. On June 17, 2025, he moved to reopen with new evidence about the same children: a new Individualized Education Plan for the eldest, an autism diagnosis and accommodation plan for the second, a post-traumatic stress diagnosis for the youngest after a dog attack, and more records on the second child’s heart condition.

By our count he filed 74 days after the April 4 decision, inside the general 90-day window the Board cited; the issue was the separate departure deadline. The Board asked for supplemental briefs on whether reopening relieves a person of the consequences of breaking a voluntary departure agreement.

Before the deadline or after it

Under 8 U.S.C. § 1229c(d)(1)(B), a person who “voluntarily fails to depart” within the time allowed is ineligible for 10 years “to receive any further relief” under the provisions it lists: voluntary departure, cancellation of removal, adjustment of status, change of nonimmigrant status and registry. A motion to reopen properly filed before the departure period expires automatically terminates the grant and its penalties for not leaving. A motion filed afterward does not. The Board quoted 8 C.F.R. § 1240.26(e)(2): “The filing of a motion to reopen . . . after the time allowed for voluntary departure has already expired does not in any way impact the period of time allowed for voluntary departure . . . .” Ontiveros-Diaz filed 14 days late, so the penalties had already attached.

Why the same application was still “further relief”

Ontiveros-Diaz argued that the bar is “simply irrelevant” when a person seeks only to add evidence to an application already filed, because once proceedings are reopened there is no longer a concluded case or a removal order. The Board disagreed for four reasons.

The alternative ruling on the children

Even without the bar, the motion failed. Someone reopening for relief already denied carries a “heavy burden” to show the new evidence would likely change the result. The Board found the new evidence supplemental to what had already been presented: An earlier motion to remand had included the youngest child’s PTSD and the second child’s autism screening, a diagnosis of “Other Specified Neurodevelopmental Disorder” and a need for further therapy and psychological testing. He had also already provided records of the second child’s heart treatment, and the eldest child’s special education services were in the record.

The decisive fact was the judge’s finding that the children’s educational, medical and financial resources would not change, because the children would stay in the United States with their mother. The Board relied on Matter of Buri Mora, 29 I&N Dec. 186 (BIA 2025), for that point, then found the new records “of a similar nature to the evidence previously presented” and unlikely to change the outcome.

Exceptions the decision mentions

A footnote noted that Ontiveros-Diaz never claimed his failure to leave was involuntary. Under Matter of Zmijewska, 24 I&N Dec. 87 (BIA 2007), a person has not voluntarily failed to depart when, “through no fault of his or her own,” he is unaware of the voluntary departure order or is physically unable to depart. He invoked neither.

What this means in California

As a published Board precedent, Ontiveros-Diaz binds immigration judges in California as everywhere else, and the Ninth Circuit reached the same practical result years ago. In Granados-Oseguera v. Mukasey, 546 F.3d 1011 (9th Cir. 2008), a motion to pursue adjustment based on an employer petition, filed 62 days after the departure period ended, had to be denied, and an ineffective-assistance excuse did not change that: “the BIA was not simply correct to deny the motion; it was compelled to do so . . . .” Ontiveros-Diaz applies the same bar where the motion seeks the very relief already denied.

The Ninth Circuit has also recognized the involuntariness exception. Singh v. Holder, 658 F.3d 879 (9th Cir. 2011), an ineffective-assistance case, involved a petitioner who never received the Board’s order and said his lawyer did not tell him about the departure deadline. Saying he had “a strong argument” under Zmijewska, the court sent the case back for the Board to apply it; Granados-Oseguera, where the petitioner knew of the order, did not control. And under Monsalvo Velázquez v. Bondi, 604 U.S. 712 (2025), a voluntary departure deadline that falls on a weekend or legal holiday runs to the next business day.

In our reading, count the departure deadline now, from the order itself. A motion filed during the departure period, on or before the last day, ends the grant without the penalties, though the alternate removal order takes effect. For that rule the Board cited the regulation and Dada v. Mukasey. After the date, the first question is whether the failure to leave was truly voluntary or the VAWA exception fits; new hardship evidence comes second. Our voluntary departure guide covers bonds and penalties.

A question readers ask

I missed my voluntary departure deadline and then filed a motion to reopen. Can I still get cancellation?

Under this decision, no: The 10-year bar applies, and reopening does not erase it, unless an exception applies, such as a failure to leave that was not voluntary under Zmijewska or a qualifying VAWA claim.

Granted voluntary departure, or already past the date?

Bring the immigration judge’s order, the Board’s decision with the reinstated departure date, your bond receipt, and anything showing when you learned of the order or why you could not leave. We can check the deadline, whether a motion can still be filed in time, and whether an exception applies. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.