O’Dell: Two Coworkers’ Arbitration Wins Could Not Cancel 255 Other Workers’ Agreements

If coworkers who signed the same arbitration agreement as you have already convinced an arbitrator that the agreement is unfair, can you use their win to take your own claims to court? Under the Federal Arbitration Act, the Ninth Circuit answered no. A court may not use other workers’ arbitration awards, through non-mutual issue preclusion, to declare your agreement unenforceable; the Act requires your agreement to be enforced according to its own terms.
The decision is O’Dell v. Aya Healthcare Services, Inc., No. 25-1528 (9th Cir. Apr. 1, 2026), a published opinion by Judge Tung, joined by Judges Tallman and VanDyke. It reversed a San Diego federal judge who had refused to send 255 other Aya employees to individual arbitration because two arbitrators in earlier cases had found materially identical agreements unconscionable.
A mid-contract pay cut and four split arbitrations
Aya employs traveling nurses and other clinicians and places them with hospitals. As a condition of employment, each signed an agreement to arbitrate employment-related disputes. A “delegation clause” in each agreement gave an arbitrator, not a court, the job of deciding whether the arbitration agreement itself was valid.
Four former employees sued Aya in a putative class action, alleging that it cut their pay mid-contract. They asserted contract, fraud, state wage-and-hour and federal Fair Labor Standards Act claims. The district court granted Aya’s motion to compel arbitration, and each of the four went to a separate arbitration.
Because the workers challenged the agreements, each arbitrator, under the delegation clause, decided whether the agreement was valid. Two arbitrators found the agreements unconscionable, reasoning that the fee and venue provisions were unduly one-sided. The other two found the agreements valid because a savings clause rescued them. The district court confirmed three awards but not the fourth, which upheld the agreement, because Aya apparently failed to pay arbitration fees.
How the district court used two awards for everyone
By then, 255 more workers had opted in to the case through the Fair Labor Standards Act’s collective-action procedure. Aya moved to compel each of them to arbitrate under the delegation clause in that worker’s own agreement. A newly assigned district judge raised on her own whether collateral estoppel barred Aya from enforcing those agreements, and then denied Aya’s motion.
Collateral estoppel, also called issue preclusion, stops a party from relitigating an issue already decided against it. The version used here was “non-mutual” and “offensive”: New parties used earlier awards as a sword against Aya. The district court gave that effect only to the two awards invalidating the agreements, and declined to rely on the awards upholding them because it considered those awards less “reasoned” or “thorough.” As a result, all 255 agreements were rendered entirely unenforceable.
Preclusion is not a contract defense
Section 2 of the Act makes an arbitration agreement enforceable except on grounds for revoking any contract—generally applicable defenses such as fraud, duress and unconscionability. The court held that an “equitable issue-preclusion doctrine (of the offensive non-mutual variety)” is not a “generally applicable contract defense.” It concerns whether earlier judgments bind later litigants, not contract formation, so it is not a “revocation” of the agreement. Even under a broader reading of “revocation,” the court added, preclusion used this way would conflict with the rest of the Act.
The surrounding provisions pointed the same way. Sections 3 and 4 require arbitration “in accordance with the terms” of the agreement, and section 10 allows a court to vacate an award only for defects in the arbitral process, such as corruption or fraud. In the court’s words, “nowhere in this scheme—from the beginning of arbitration to its end—did Congress contemplate that a non-mutual preclusion doctrine could be deployed to frustrate an arbitration that the parties had agreed to undertake in resolving their disputes.”
Consent and the bellwether problem
Arbitration rests on consent. Blocking an agreed arbitration because a different arbitrator, in a different case, found a different worker’s agreement unconscionable “would render the parties’ consent meaningless.”
The ruling also turned individual arbitrations into a binding bellwether class action nobody agreed to. Ordinary class actions require named plaintiffs who adequately represent the class; here, whoever happened to arbitrate first would have decided the question for everyone. “That is a class action stripped of all its important protective features,” the court wrote; bellwether trials generally do not bind unless the parties agree in advance. The workers argued that section 13, which gives a confirmed award a judgment’s force, required preclusion. The panel read it as letting confirmed awards be enforced and collected like other judgments, not as overriding sections 2, 3, 4 and 10.
What the reversal means for the 255 workers
The Ninth Circuit reversed and remanded “for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.” It did not itself order the 255 into arbitration. Our reading: The district court must take up Aya’s motion without giving preclusive effect to the two earlier awards, and each worker’s agreement, including its delegation clause, will be applied on its own terms. A worker who still says the agreement is unfair will ordinarily raise that challenge in the forum the agreement provides.
If your coworkers already won in arbitration
These points are our reading of the opinion. As a published Ninth Circuit opinion, O’Dell binds federal courts throughout the Ninth Circuit, including in California. California state courts also apply the Federal Arbitration Act but are not bound by Ninth Circuit decisions.
- Use the reasoning, not the result. A coworker’s award will not void your agreement automatically. The one-sided fee and venue terms that persuaded two arbitrators here can still be raised in your own challenge, with your own agreement and evidence.
- Read your own agreement. Check whether it has a delegation clause, a savings clause, and the same version and date as your coworkers’ agreements, because each agreement is judged on its own.
- Watch the fees. In the district court’s view, unpaid fees cost Aya confirmation of one favorable award. California has its own rules on late employer payments; see our guide to late employment-arbitration fees under section 1281.97.
- Different situations use different rules. When California arbitration procedure governs and coworkers’ related claims are pending in court, the state’s conflicting-rulings provision may matter; it applied in Donis, where the federal Act did not cover the worker’s contract. When the earlier award is in your own case, it can bind you, as Sorokunov v. NetApp shows.
As of November 20, 2026, the Ninth Circuit’s docket shows that the court’s mandate issued on April 23, 2026, with no rehearing petition or amended opinion entered.
Coworkers won their arbitration, but you were sent to yours?
Bring your arbitration agreement and its date, any onboarding documents, the motion or order sending you to arbitration, and whatever you know about your coworkers’ awards and the terms they challenged. We can review whether your own agreement can be challenged, who decides that challenge, and what deadlines apply. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.