Newell: A Body Part the First Workers’ Comp Award Deferred Could Be Added on Reopening

An open burgundy clothbound book with unfolding cream paper, sage and ochre paper layers, a copper thread and white blossoms on linen.

A judge’s remark that a worker had not proved a body part was work-related does not block a later reopening when the award itself made no finding on that body part and deferred it. In Phillip Newell v. Miracle Plumbing, Inc., No. ADJ14478546 (Cal. WCAB Nov. 5, 2026), the Appeals Board denied the employer’s petition for reconsideration and left in place findings that a plumber’s timely petition to reopen added his low back and right leg to his ankle injury. The petition still had to be timely and supported by medical reporting. Newell is a WCAB panel decision (Commissioner Katherine Williams Dodd, Deputy Commissioner Lisa A. Sussman and Commissioner Joseph V. Capurro) applying settled reopening and preclusion rules to this record.

An ankle award and a back left open

On September 25, 2019, Phillip Newell fell from the step of his work van while removing a ladder; his left foot struck a curb and he landed hard on his buttocks. Miracle Plumbing admitted injury to his left lower extremity, leg and ankle (pages 2 and 3).

After a January 2023 trial, the judge’s February 2, 2023 opinion on decision said that “applicant has not met his burden of proof on this issue of causation of industrial injury to the low back.” But the Findings and Award itself was silent on the low back, and its award section stated: “All other issues are deferred at this time.” The evaluator’s earlier reporting had addressed low back injury and impairment, but not what caused it.

On February 21, 2024, Newell petitioned to reopen for new and further disability, claiming his low back and right lower extremity. The petition was tried on November 12, 2025; after a petition for reconsideration and an order granting it, the case was tried again on July 14, 2026, with good cause to reopen added as an issue (page 2). The judge then found injury to both body parts, along with the admitted left leg and ankle, and good cause to reopen the 2023 award (page 1). The employer sought reconsideration, invoking the 2023 opinion and Labor Code sections 5502(d)(3) and 5815.

How the evaluator tied the back and right leg to the fall

In a February 3, 2025 re-evaluation, the qualified medical evaluator, Dr. Michael Fujinaka, diagnosed lumbar radiculopathy and an ankle fracture with ongoing complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS), a chronic nerve-pain condition (page 2). For the low back, he identified two causes: the impact of the fall and the strain of favoring the injured ankle. In his words, “The combination of the direct impact to the lumbar spine during the fall and subsequent biomechanical strain from favoring the injured ankle provides a clear mechanism for ongoing lower back dysfunction” (page 3). For the right leg, he explained “mirroring,” in which CRPS that began in one limb spreads to the other through sensitization of the nervous system (pages 3 and 4).

His November 2025 deposition cut both ways. He testified that most of Newell’s lumbar spine impairment existed before the 2023 award, and that a low back rating “should not have been given back in 2022 without the full physical evaluation of the spine.” He also called the right leg a compensable consequence of the left, and part of the low back complaints a compensable consequence of the altered gait (page 5). The judge found his low back causation reporting “unequivocal and unrebutted.”

A comment in an opinion is not a finding

The trial judge answered the employer’s preclusion and section 5815 arguments with the statutes themselves: sections 5313 and 5815 require a judge to “file finding upon all facts involved in the controversy” and to state the reasons for the decision, and the 2023 Findings and Award, which deferred “[a]ll other issues,” “included no finding regarding the additional body part of lumbar spine . . . .” The low back issue thus “was not actually ‘decided on the merits’” (page 7).

The Board agreed. Under Pacific Lumber, Co. v. State Water Resources Control Bd. (2006) 37 Cal.4th 921, 943, an earlier decision bars relitigation of an issue only if it is final and on the merits. Here, “[o]n its face, the F&A deferred a finding of causation for the lumbar spine and the issue remained open to development.” The Board added that, because the 2023 judge commented on the burden of proof without making a finding, the record “was effectively treated as an inconclusive opinion on causation.”

Why this was new and further disability, not a second try

Labor Code section 5410 lets a worker seek more compensation within five years after the date of injury “upon the ground that the original injury has caused new and further disability.” Newell’s February 2024 petition fell inside five years from the September 2019 injury, and the judge found the claim timely raised. The judge applied Applied Materials v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (2021) 64 Cal.App.5th 1042, 1080, which defines new and further disability as “disability resulting from some demonstrable change in the employee’s condition,” such as a new need for medical treatment. The petition alleged that kind of change, including new treatment needs and worsening CRPS (pages 8 and 9).

The judge then found that the low back qualified as new and further disability, and explained how she weighed the pre-award symptoms: Newell “unquestionably had low back symptoms” before the 2023 award, but Dr. Fujinaka did not address causation until 2025, did not relate the earlier symptoms to the injury, and found that the low back complaints had progressed to the point that part of them were compensable consequences of the altered gait (page 10). The Board held the reports were well reasoned and substantial evidence: “The WCJ found the reports to be substantial and we agree.”

The decision also quotes the limit from Nicky Blair’s Restaurant v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (1980) 109 Cal.App.3d 941, 956: good cause to reopen “does not consist of medical evidence obtained subsequent to the original decision which merely disagrees with the medical opinion relied upon” at the time. In our reading, that limit had little to work on here, because the 2023 record contained no causation opinion on the low back for the 2025 reporting to disagree with.

The later reports came in without objection

The employer also argued that, under section 5502, medical evidence obtained after the mandatory settlement conference that preceded the 2023 trial should be excluded. The Board disagreed that section 5502 would preclude the later reports, because the causation question had remained open, and in any event the reports were admitted at the November 2025 trial without objection, so “any objection to those reports was waived . . . .” The Board denied reconsideration, leaving the July 29, 2026 Findings in place (page 11).

Our reading: Check what the first award actually decided. If the findings and award deferred a body part, later medical reporting on that body part can support reopening if it shows new and further disability and the petition is filed within five years of the injury. Our guide to reopening a workers’ comp award or settlement explains how the five-year clock runs.

Has your back or other leg become part of your injury?

Bring the findings and award, the opinion on decision, your injury date and the evaluator’s reports so we can check what the first award decided, what it deferred and whether a petition to reopen is still timely. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.