Murphy Hollow: Promoters Who Knew Their Appraiser Would Inflate Values Lost Two Land-Donation Deductions Entirely

Two layered paper hills beside a deep blue clothbound book, cream paper, a copper clip and a pine sprig on linen.

The Tax Court disallowed charitable deductions of $26,725,000 and $19,420,000 in full because the two donor entities’ managers knew facts that would lead a reasonable person to expect their appraiser to falsely overstate the land’s value, so neither entity had a qualified appraisal. The court then valued the two Tennessee tracts at $2,075,025 and $1,206,262 and imposed the 40% gross valuation misstatement penalty on both.

Chief Judge Urda decided the consolidated cases in Murphy Hollow, LLC v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-115 (Nov. 5, 2026), Docket Nos. 9620-21 and 13346-21, a memorandum opinion issued after trial that also resolves Hales Gap, LLC’s case. Unlike the many easement cases, these were gifts of the land itself, outright, in fee simple.

Land bought for $1,350 an acre and given away a year later

Mark Sofge and Walter Hall ran Piedmont Private Equity, which by the end of 2017 had done more than 60 similar deals. Investors bought into a fund that bought 97% of a land entity, which donated its land and passed the deduction through. Every deal ended in a donation. Tax Court opinion at pages 3–4.

On December 21, 2016, Murphy Hollow paid $1,803,789 for about 1,336 acres and Hales Gap paid $1,048,586 for about 777 acres of steep, rural land in Marion County, Tennessee, carved from a failed residential project called Sequatchie Pointe: $1,350 an acre. Investors were promised $3.80 of deductions per dollar invested. On December 26, 2017, the entities gave the land to Southern Conservation Trust, which had agreed not to sell for three years. Tax Court opinion at pages 2, 8–9, 15, 17–18.

The appraiser rule the court applied

A deduction of more than $500,000 for donated property requires a qualified appraisal by a qualified appraiser, under section 170(f)(11). Under the Treasury regulation the court applied to these 2017 gifts, section 1.170A-13(c)(5)(ii), an appraiser is not qualified if the donor “had knowledge of facts that would cause a reasonable person to expect the appraiser falsely to overstate the value of the donated property.” Tax Court opinion at pages 21 and 50.

The test looks at what the donor knew about the appraiser; careless overvaluation alone does not disqualify the appraiser. No explicit instruction is needed, because an agreement can arise “by virtue of acquiescence in a shared goal.” For an entity, the court looks to the people with ultimate authority to manage it. It treated Sofge and Hall’s knowledge as shared, finding incredible their testimony that neither knew what the other was doing. Tax Court opinion at pages 21–23.

What the managers knew about their appraiser

The court found that the managers had every reason to expect inflated numbers from their appraiser, Clayton Weibel. Tax Court opinion at pages 23–26.

From these facts the court found an unstated agreement between the managers and Weibel to raise the values enough to deliver the promised return. Weibel was not a qualified appraiser, neither entity had a qualified appraisal, and each deduction was disallowed in its entirety. Tax Court opinion at page 26.

Value still mattered because of the penalties

With both deductions at zero, the court still had to value each tract, because the penalty depends on the misstatement (Tax Court opinion at page 27). The entities’ experts proposed a 1,205-unit resort community and an 807-lot active adult community. The court instead found the then-current rural residential, agricultural or recreational use, relying on the 2016 lender appraisals, Sequatchie Pointe’s failure and the lack of engineering, demand or cost evidence for building on steep land. That the managers chose donation over development, the court said, “gives the game away.” Tax Court opinion at pages 32–41. Our Watson Lake analysis explains the same probability test for a planned development.

The IRS appraiser’s comparable sales supported $1,350 an acre. The court added 15% because the 2016 sales followed a foreclosure, which can push prices down, reaching $1,553 an acre. The arm’s-length 2016 purchases and the $1.2 million resale after the three-year hold further supported that value. Even if development were the highest and best use, the court said, its conclusion “would remain the same”: Land a developer bought for the Jasper Highlands and River Gorge Ranch projects sold for $1,243 to $1,600 an acre, so the market price already reflected development potential. Tax Court opinion at pages 43–48.

A 40% penalty on both gifts, and 20% on the rest for Murphy Hollow

A misstatement is gross at 200% or more of the correct value. The claimed values were 1,288% (Murphy Hollow) and 1,610% (Hales Gap) of the court’s values, so the 40% penalty applies to the part of each underpayment caused by claiming more than the correct value. Section 6664(c)(3) makes the reasonable-cause defense unavailable for a gross overstatement of charitable contribution property. Tax Court opinion at page 48.

The rest of the disallowance, equal to the land’s true value, was lost only for want of a qualified appraisal. For Murphy Hollow, the court applied the 20% penalty to that “lower tranche” as a substantial understatement or, alternatively, negligence, and rejected reasonable cause for the same reason it disqualified the appraiser. The IRS had conceded the 20% penalty for Hales Gap. Tax Court opinion at pages 2 n.2 and 48–50.

Result and what the case means

Decisions will be entered under Rule 155. The court’s November 6, 2026 order gives the parties until February 3, 2027 to file computations. Tax Court opinion at page 50; Tax Court docket 9620-21.

Our reading: The appraiser holding is what separates this case from valuation-only cases. In Riddle Aggregates, decided five days later, the parties had agreed the gifts were deductible, so the fight was over value. Here, what the managers knew about their appraiser cost the entities even the deduction the land’s real value would have supported, and it also defeated the reasonable-cause defense to the 20% penalty. For an investor or donor, the questions that matter are how the appraiser was chosen and paid, whether a value was previewed before the deal, what other appraisals showed, and whether the charity was asked to hold the property.

Review a land-donation appraisal or an FPAA penalty

Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review an FPAA or deficiency notice, the appraisal and how the appraiser was engaged, the offering papers and the gift documents to see whether the dispute turns on the appraisal, the value or the penalty. Bring the notice, the appraisal with its engagement letter, any lender or other appraisals, and the deed and donee agreement. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.