Merida Ortiz v. Commissioner: An ITIN Did Not Qualify for the 2021 $1,400 Recovery Rebate Credit

Lime and deep blue fields of pigment on rough flax paper.

The Tax Court held that a taxpayer who filed his 2021 return with an individual taxpayer identification number (ITIN) was not entitled to the $1,400 2021 recovery rebate credit, because the statute requires a Social Security number issued by the Social Security Administration, and an ITIN is not one. The court also said it could not order the 2020 stimulus payment he asked for, because the IRS’s notice covered only 2021.

Judge Guider decided Merida Ortiz v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-81 (Sept. 3, 2026), Docket No. 13093-25, a memorandum opinion granting the IRS’s motion for judgment on the pleadings. Ivan Merida Ortiz represented himself. Because the motion was decided on the pleadings, the facts come from those papers and are not findings after a trial.

A $1,400 credit claimed with an ITIN

Before 2021, Mr. Merida Ortiz obtained an ITIN from the IRS and used it on his 2021 income tax return, where he claimed the $1,400 recovery rebate credit under section 6428B. The IRS disallowed the credit for lack of a valid identification number and, on July 24, 2025, issued a notice of deficiency for $1,400. He timely petitioned the Tax Court. He argued that he had included a “taxpayer identification number” on his return, and he also asked for a 2020 credit he said he never received.

A motion for judgment on the pleadings can be granted only if the pleadings raise no genuine issue of material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. In granting it, the court decided the case on what the statute requires.

What the 2021 credit required

The American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 created section 6428B, a credit for 2021 of $1,400, or $2,800 on a joint return, plus $1,400 for each dependent, subject to income limits and other conditions.

The decisive condition is in section 6428B(e)(2)(A): On a return other than a joint return, the $1,400 amount “shall be treated as being zero unless the taxpayer includes the valid identification number of the taxpayer on the return of tax for the taxable year.” Section 6428B(e)(2)(D)(i) defines a valid identification number as “a social security number issued to an individual by the Social Security Administration on or before the due date for filing the return for the taxable year.”

Why an ITIN was not enough

Credits are a matter of legislative grace, so he had to show he met every condition. The court explained that Mr. Merida Ortiz confused a taxpayer identification number with the valid identification number the statute requires. Under the Treasury regulation the court quoted, an ITIN is a number the IRS issues to an alien individual, on application, for filing requirements, and the term does not refer to a Social Security number. The regulation also says a person who has, or is entitled to, a Social Security number will not be issued an ITIN.

From there the reasoning was short. The statute treats the credit as zero without a valid identification number; a valid identification number is a Social Security number; an ITIN is not a Social Security number. The court added that his use of an ITIN showed he did not have a valid identification number. He was not entitled to the credit.

The 2020 payment was a different year

Mr. Merida Ortiz also asked the court to “release [the] economic impact payment for [the] year 2020” that he said he did not receive, a claim tied to the 2020 credits under sections 6428 and 6428A. The court held it had no jurisdiction over that request. In a deficiency case, the Tax Court can decide only the years in the notice of deficiency, and its power to find an overpayment is limited to those same years. The notice covered 2021 only.

That holding concerns the court’s power to hear the 2020 request in this case, not whether he qualified for a 2020 payment. The court entered its decision for the IRS on September 4, 2026. The Tax Court docket showed no notice of appeal when we checked it on November 19, 2026.

Who the statute still covers

The court applied the rule for a return other than a joint return to a $1,400 claim. Section 6428B(e)(2) treats other households differently. Under the statute’s text:

For an otherwise eligible filer, the separate dependent amount can still count a child whose qualifying identification number appears on the return, even if the filer uses an ITIN. Section 6428B excludes nonresident aliens from its definition of an eligible individual. These rules come from the statute.

What the case means for ITIN filers

The ruling applies a plain statutory definition, and it confirms that writing any IRS-issued number on the return does not satisfy a credit that requires a Social Security number. It also shows the limits of the Tax Court: A deficiency case for one year is not a forum to recover a payment for another year. To raise a different year, you need a notice or other procedure covering that year. Our guide to the notice of deficiency and the 90-day Tax Court deadline explains how that notice defines what the court can hear.

If you received an ITIN and later become a U.S. citizen or are lawfully admitted for permanent residence or under authority permitting U.S. employment, the Treasury regulation requires you to obtain a Social Security number. Once you receive the new number, notify the IRS and use it on future federal tax filings.

An IRS notice about a credit claimed with an ITIN?

Mishra X Trial Lawyers handles both tax and immigration matters. We can review the notice, the years it covers, your return and the identification numbers used for you and each family member, and explain which credits the law allows and what to do about another year’s claim. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.