Manente: Why Private-Sector Wages Counted as Taxable Income

The Third Circuit affirmed a $21,758.70 federal income-tax deficiency for 2021 after Vito Manente reported no taxable wages or other income. His principal argument rested on a word in the withholding statute. The statute says that “employee” includes federal employees. He read that language to limit wages to federal employment. The court read it as an inclusion and held that his roughly $114,347 in wages were taxable income. The decision was nonprecedential.
What the Tax Court had decided
Manente’s 2021 return reported no taxable wages and no other income. The record showed that he had earned approximately $114,347 in wages and had also received litigation settlements and taxable withdrawals from retirement funds. The IRS sent a notice asserting a $21,758.70 deficiency. The deficiency was the amount of tax at issue. The wage figure was one component of the income that gave rise to it. Manente petitioned the Tax Court, which upheld the notice on the parties’ cross-motions for summary judgment. The Third Circuit reviewed that judgment de novo. Slip opinion at 1–2 & n.1.
How the court read “includes”
Section 3401(a) defines wages for withholding purposes in terms of remuneration for services performed by an employee. Section 3401(c) specifies that employee “includes” federal employees. Manente argued that because he was outside that group, his compensation fell outside the definition. The court held that naming federal employees brought them within the definition and left other employees within its reach. The panel applied the same reasoning it had used in Manente’s appeal over 2018, where it had relied in part on the Seventh Circuit’s reading of the term in United States v. Latham. Slip opinion at 2–3 & n.2.
Manente also argued that the Supreme Court’s decision in Moore v. United States undermined the tax on his wages. The panel said it had not expressly addressed Moore in his appeal over 2018. It now explained that Moore upheld a tax involving certain unrealized corporate gains. The question here was whether wages Manente had earned counted as income. The panel relied on its own circuit’s prior decision on that question, United States v. Connor. The different kinds of income explain why Moore did not change the result. Slip opinion at 3 n.2.
Which income issues remained in the appeal
The Commissioner argued that Manente had forfeited any challenge to the deficiency attributable to his settlements and retirement withdrawals by leaving those items out of his appeal. The court agreed and added that it saw no basis to question the Tax Court’s treatment of those items. With the wage arguments rejected, the court affirmed the 2021 judgment. The panel carried forward its reasoning from the earlier appeal, which concerned a separate return and deficiency for 2018. Slip opinion at 2–4.
Manente also challenged certain penalties and argued that he had been denied a chance to present his case. The panel explained that the penalties he challenged were either outside this proceeding or had been conceded by the Commissioner. It rejected the due-process claim because the Tax Court had considered his arguments and decided them on the merits. Slip opinion at 3–4.
What to check when an IRS notice lists several income items
Match each disputed item to the notice and the records that explain it. For a wage amount, compare the notice with the W-2, pay statements and any employer correction. For a withdrawal or settlement, use the payer’s statement and the documents that establish what was paid. Identify the amount and reason separately for each item you dispute. In Manente, the court could dispose of the wage argument on the statutory language and treat the other income items as forfeited because they were left out of the appeal. That difference matters when a single deficiency combines more than one income item.
Questions about an IRS notice of deficiency?
Bring the complete notice and the records linked to each item, including any corrected forms, so we can help you identify what is disputed. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.