M-R-I-: A Trip Home on Advance Parole Abandoned an Entire Asylum, Withholding and CAT Application

A person with a pending asylum case who travels on advance parole back to the country they say they fear is presumed to have abandoned the whole application, including withholding of removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT), unless they prove compelling reasons for the trip. The Board of Immigration Appeals so held in Matter of M-R-I-, 30 I&N Dec. 137 (BIA 2026), a published decision issued October 7, 2026.
The burden is on the applicant. The Board also held that the question turns on the evidence, not the government’s argument: An applicant who made the trip must explain it even if the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) says nothing.
Two trips while the case was pending
The respondent, a citizen of Nepal, applied for asylum, withholding and CAT protection in immigration court. While the case was pending, DHS twice granted him advance parole, permission to travel abroad and return. In 2016 he went back to Nepal for about two months. He testified that he missed his family and worried about his mother’s health and his family after the 2015 earthquake. In 2018 he traveled to India for about two months and met his Nepalese family there.
On June 17, 2020, the immigration judge denied his applications, finding that the Nepal trip abandoned them. The judge noted that his mother’s last health incident and hospitalization were about four years before the trip and the earthquake about a year before.
The rule: A return is presumed to abandon the claim
Under 8 C.F.R. § 1208.8(b), an applicant who leaves on advance parole “and returns to the country of claimed persecution shall be presumed to have abandoned his or her application, unless the applicant is able to establish compelling reasons for such return.” The Board tied that rule to the definition of a refugee, a person who is “unable or unwilling to return” to their country because of a well-founded fear of persecution.
Why the reasons for his trip were not compelling
The Board agreed with the judge that the respondent did not carry his burden. Two facts decided it. Significant time had passed between the events that prompted the trip, the earthquake and his mother’s health issues, and the trip itself. And by later meeting his family in neighboring India, he showed there was an “alternative option to traveling to Nepal,” the country he said he could not return to.
The applicant’s burden, not the government’s argument
His only abandonment argument on appeal was procedural. DHS filed its closing argument on the judge’s schedule but served it on him several days after filing, and, he said, without some signatures, so he argued DHS had waived the issue. The Board rejected that on two grounds.
First, there was no due process violation. He did not show prejudice from the delay, and because he objected in writing and again at a later hearing, and the judge considered those objections, he had notice and a chance to respond.
Second, the argument would fail even if DHS had waived its closing. The applicant bears the burden of proof for asylum, withholding and CAT. Under 8 C.F.R. § 1240.8(d), when the evidence indicates that a ground for mandatory denial may apply, the applicant must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that it does not. The Board held that the application of a mandatory bar to relief “is not triggered by the argument of counsel but is governed by the evidentiary record.” Because the trip was undisputed, it was “incumbent on him” to present compelling reasons; the judge had also put him on notice and asked both sides to brief the issue.
One application, including CAT
The judge had treated only CAT withholding as abandoned and went on to decide CAT deferral, a narrower protection that remains available to some people barred from withholding. The Board said that step was unnecessary. Section 1208.8 sits in a subpart that, under 8 C.F.R. § 1208.1(a)(1), applies to asylum, withholding and CAT applications alike. The regulation speaks of a single “application,” and “abandon” means to give up entirely, so the applicant forsakes the whole application. The phrase “country of claimed persecution” describes the place, the Board reasoned, not the kind of harm feared.
Deferral was unavailable for a second reason. Under 8 C.F.R. § 1208.17(a), deferral is for people entitled to CAT protection who are subject to mandatory denial of withholding. Someone who abandoned the application is not in that group, and it would be, in the Board’s word, “anomalous” to deny, on mandatory grounds or the merits, an application already abandoned.
The CAT claim and the new evidence
Alternatively, the Board affirmed the judge’s denial of CAT deferral on the merits. The respondent’s last encounter with the Maoists he feared was in 2010, and he stayed in Nepal about eight months unharmed before leaving. The judge also found it speculative that the Maoists were still looking for him or could find him. In that 2010 incident he fled into a police station; officers sheltered him for a day, took a report and escorted him to a relative’s home. His “minimal argument” on appeal did not establish “a clear probability of future torture within the meaning of CAT.”
He also submitted updated country-conditions evidence, which the Board treated as a motion to remand and denied. Updated conditions were not relevant to whether his trip years earlier abandoned the application, and he did not show a reasonable likelihood of winning relief with the new evidence. The appeal was dismissed.
Before you travel with an asylum case pending
As a published precedent, M-R-I- binds immigration judges and DHS nationwide under 8 C.F.R. § 1003.1(g), including in California, though some of its due-process and remand standards came from Fourth Circuit cases. These points are our reading of the decision.
- Advance parole is permission to travel, not protection for the claim. A trip to the feared country puts the whole application at risk, including withholding and CAT.
- If family needs you, consider meeting elsewhere. The presumption applies to a return to the feared country, but here a later family meeting in India still counted against him as evidence of an alternative to the trip home.
- Timing and proof matter. A sudden emergency documented with hospital records, a death certificate or similar proof, and a short stay, presents a different record.
- Do not count on the government to raise it. Be ready to explain any return yourself; here, later country-conditions evidence did not change the abandonment finding.
For a different abandonment question, a defective declaration, see our analysis of C-A-R-R-.
Thinking about traveling while your asylum case is pending?
Before you leave, bring your I-589, your advance parole document and the reason for the trip, with any medical or other records that show the urgency. If you already traveled, bring your passport stamps and the dates of each trip. We can review the risk to your case before you go or prepare the explanation the judge will expect. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.