Love: A 2017 Psych Report Was Too Stale to Rate a 2004 Injury in 2026

A workers’ compensation judge cannot rate permanent disability from a psychological report written almost a decade earlier when the record suggests the worker’s condition may have changed since. In Love v. Starbucks Coffee Co., No. ADJ357552 (Cal. W.C.A.B. Nov. 10, 2026), the Appeals Board set aside a 48 percent permanent disability finding for that reason and sent the case back to update the medical record. It did so even though the worker may have been able to do more to develop her own evidence.
The decision is a WCAB panel decision (Chair Zalewski and Commissioners Razo and Snellings), persuasive rather than binding. The Board left two other rulings in place: The 2005 rating schedule applies, and a late-offered exhibit was properly excluded.
A 2004 injury and a psych claim that outlasted its reports
Honey Love, a Starbucks shift supervisor, injured her neck and back on September 27, 2004. Psychological injury, urological injury and headaches were later found to be compensable consequences. After the claim was amended in 2006 to include psychiatric injury, each side obtained its own qualified medical evaluator in psychology: Dr. Elena Konstat for the worker and Dr. Dennis Nehamen for the employer.
Trial began on September 27, 2017, then was continued several times because the worker was unavailable, and was not submitted until June 2021. The July 2021 findings confirmed injury to the back and psyche, rejected a claimed sleep disorder, and ordered more reporting on the spine, headaches and urological injury, but not on the psychological injury. The judge then issued a Findings and Award on July 23, 2026, finding 48 percent permanent disability and no permanent psychiatric disability.
Why the judge chose the defense psychologist
Dr. Nehamen changed his opinion after reviewing video footage and social media posts the employer supplied, and he explained why. In the judge’s words, the material “provided a very different view of the Applicant than that described by the Applicant herself.” The orthopedic evaluator reviewed the same material; it did not change his view of her physical limits.
Dr. Konstat never reviewed that material. Because she tied the worker’s depression and anxiety to chronic pain and physical limits, the judge reasoned that it was “essential” for her to address it, and relied on Dr. Nehamen’s more current reports instead. The judge added that the worker had time before the 2017 trial to get a supplemental psychological report and did not.
Why a reasoned report still could not be rated
The worker argued that Dr. Nehamen’s reports were inadmissible and not substantial evidence, and that the record should be further developed. The Board upheld their admission but agreed they could not support a rating. It accepted that the judge “may be correct” that the worker “could have exercised greater diligence” by getting a supplemental report from Dr. Konstat. But Dr. Nehamen’s most recent report, dated March 21, 2017, on which the judge relied, was “approximately 10 years old,” and there was “evidence in the record that applicant’s condition may have materially changed” since he last reported. The Board stated the governing rule: “Where the medical evidence or opinion on an issue is incomplete, stale, and no longer germane, or is based on an inaccurate history, or speculation, it does not constitute substantial evidence.” It relied on the California Supreme Court’s decision in Place and the Appeals Board’s en banc decision in Escobedo.
The Board’s concern was the report’s age, not its reasoning, which the Board did not criticize. And because the judge and the Board must develop the record when the evidence is insufficient, any lack of diligence by the worker did not end the inquiry.
How the record gets developed now
The Board granted reconsideration, deferred permanent disability and attorney fees, found that the record requires further development and returned the case to the trial judge. It otherwise affirmed the Findings and Award, including the award of future medical treatment.
The Board left the next steps to the trial judge, returning the case “for further proceedings as the WCJ determines necessary for development of the record.” Citing the Appeals Board’s en banc decision in McDuffie, it described the preferred sequence in its own words: “Where it is determined that the medical record requires further development, the preferred procedure is to allow supplementation by the physician who has already reported in the case.” If supplemental reporting cannot cure the problem, the parties should consider a different agreed medical evaluator. If neither is possible, the judge may appoint a regular physician under Labor Code section 5701.
The 2005 schedule and the late exhibit
For the first time on reconsideration, the worker argued that her disability should be rated under the 1997 schedule rather than the 2005 schedule. The Board agreed with the judge’s reasons for rejecting that argument and for excluding Exhibit 54, a four-page document she had offered on April 15, 2026, and now relied on to support it. As the judge noted, she had not asserted that purpose when she offered it.
The judge found that Exhibit 54 did not appear to have been listed on a pretrial conference statement or served before trial. One page was an undated form letter predicting that the worker would be left with permanent impairment once her condition stabilized. The judge called it “completely speculative and premature” because she was still early in treatment, still temporarily disabled, and would not reach permanent and stationary status for years. As the judge described it, the 1997 schedule applied to injuries “determined to be permanent and stationary prior to 2005.” Under the regulation the judge cited, that means maximal medical improvement, and “[n]o doctor had found the Applicant to have actual permanent disability, or found the Applicant’s condition to be well stabilized in December of 2004.” Citing Echeverria, a Court of Appeal decision rejecting a similar unreasoned form statement, the judge found the letter insufficient to support the earlier schedule. The worker’s own proposed rating also used the 2005 schedule.
What this means for a claim that has run for years
These points are our reading of the decision.
- Check the date of every report behind a rating. An admissible report can still be too old to rate a current condition.
- Answer the surveillance. If the other side’s evaluator changes an opinion after reviewing video or social media, have your own evaluator respond to it.
- Expect development, not a new rating, as the remedy. Our Rivera analysis covers a similar remand; our Carrasco analysis shows the contrast: There, the Board rerated from newer reports.
- List exhibits on time. Our pretrial conference statement guide explains how exhibits are listed.
Is your rating built on an old medical report?
Bring the findings and award, each evaluator’s reports with their dates, any surveillance or social media material the evaluators reviewed, and your exhibit lists. We can identify which opinions are out of date and what updated reporting the record needs. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.