Levesque: The Employer Never Sent Its Own Vocational Report, So Discovery Stayed Closed and Total Disability Stood

Teal paper ribbons connect an open report to two readers beside a closed coral report and an hourglass.

When an employer holds its own vocational report for nearly two years and never sends it to the medical evaluators, it cannot use their failure to see it to reopen discovery after the mandatory settlement conference (MSC). In Joseph Levesque v. Barrett Business Services, Inc., No. ADJ11836498 (Cal. WCAB Nov. 9, 2026), the Appeals Board held that discovery properly closed at the MSC and affirmed a bartender’s 100 percent permanent total disability and life pension. It amended one finding so the award rests on proof that he could not be retrained. The panel (Commissioners Joseph V. Capurro, Paul F. Kelly and Craig L. Snellings) adopted much of the trial judge’s report.

A bartender’s head injury and two vocational reports

Joseph Levesque, a bartender, was injured on December 10, 2017; the parties stipulated to injury to his head, brain, neck, low back, right shoulder, left elbow, right hip, psyche and sleep. The evaluators were Dr. Alexander Latteri (orthopedic panel QME), Dr. Mark Levine (neuropsychiatric agreed medical evaluator, or AME) and Dr. Howard Greils (psychiatric panel QME). Dr. Latteri found no basis for apportionment, and Dr. Levine found no reason to apportion the cognitive disability to nonindustrial factors (page 2).

The worker’s vocational expert, Steve Ramirez, found Levesque 100 percent vocationally disabled and not amenable to rehabilitation; the employer received that report on December 13, 2023. The employer’s expert, Nick Corso, concluded on April 5, 2024 that Levesque could work within his limitations. After giving notice and waiting out the objection period, the worker sent the Ramirez report to Dr. Greils and Dr. Levine, who agreed with it in 2025 supplemental reports. The employer did not object and never sent Corso’s report to either evaluator (page 3).

How discovery closed

After the employer asked for a status conference on discovery, the parties agreed on October 29, 2025 to go to an MSC “to finalize discovery.” At the February 2, 2026 MSC, noting no formal discovery since October, the judge set trial over the employer’s objection. The sole trial issue was 75 percent versus 100 percent; the July 8, 2026 award found 100 percent. On reconsideration the employer argued that Dr. Greils’s reporting was defective because he never saw the Corso report, that closing discovery denied it due process, and that the worker’s out-of-state move hampered its investigation (page 1).

The report the employer kept to itself

Labor Code section 5502(d)(3) provides that “[d]iscovery shall close on the date of the mandatory settlement conference.” Later evidence comes in only if it was unavailable, or could not have been discovered with due diligence, before the conference. The employer could not make that showing: The Corso report was in its hands for nearly two years before the MSC and was admitted at trial. As the judge put it, the only thing that did not happen before the MSC “was a step Defendant chose not to take.”

The employer’s fallback, the Board’s general power to develop the record under sections 5701 and 5906, ran into San Bernardino Community Hospital v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. (McKernan) (1999) 74 Cal.App.4th 928. There the Court of Appeal held that “[t]he Board’s power to develop the record cannot be used to circumvent the clear intent and language of section 5502, subdivision (d)(3).” Due process was satisfied too: The employer had notice of every step, agreed to finish discovery before the MSC and stipulated to every exhibit, and its January 2026 efforts to schedule a deposition did not include sending the Corso report to Dr. Greils (pages 5 to 7).

An unfavorable record is not a deficient one

The duty to develop the record arises only when the record is inadequate. This one held eight medical-legal reports, two vocational reports and the worker’s testimony, and every medical opinion on employability supported the finding. In the judge’s words, “The distinction is between a record that is deficient and a record that is merely unfavorable.”

Dr. Greils’s reporting, based on three examinations over nearly six years, remained substantial evidence; the employer identified no error in it. An opinion does not lose that status because the other side chose not to show the evaluator its own expert’s report. Otherwise, the judge wrote, “any litigant could manufacture a reversible defect in the opposing side’s medical evidence simply by withholding its own.”

The out-of-state move was not dispositive either. Levesque’s mailing address of record never changed, he testified that he was homeless with no permanent Connecticut address, and the employer had not raised the point at trial (page 8).

How the worker proved he could not be retrained

A scheduled rating is prima facie evidence of permanent disability, but it can be rebutted. Under LeBoeuf, Ogilvie and Dahl, the worker shows that the industrial injury prevents retraining and competition in the open labor market, so lost earning capacity exceeds the schedule. Ramirez analyzed each impairment and restriction, found that the psychiatric and cognitive deficits ruled out competitive work, and addressed apportionment as the en banc Nunes decisions require. Both evaluators concurred, and no medical report disputed the 100 percent result (pages 8 and 9).

The judge found Corso less persuasive. His opinion rested on remote, home-based work drawn from Dr. Levine’s provisional 2022 and 2023 reporting, a premise both evaluators rejected in 2025; Levesque testified credibly that he cannot type; Corso’s apportionment depended on an unadmitted treating report; and much of his analysis turned on motivation, yet “[t]he LeBoeuf inquiry is not whether an injured worker is willing to be retrained; it is whether the industrial injury precludes him from being retrained.”

Why the Board rewrote one finding

The award said Levesque was totally disabled “based on the range of evidence.” The Board explained that this approach fits a choice between competing reports that are each substantial medical evidence, which is not what happened here. The worker rebutted the rating schedule, so the Board granted reconsideration only to amend Finding 7 to state that he “has successfully rebutted the PDRS to establish that he is 100% Permanently and Totally Disabled as a result of the December 10, 2017 injury and entitled to a life pension,” and otherwise affirmed (pages 10 to 12).

Our reading: The MSC is, in general, the deadline for putting your own evidence before the evaluators. For a worker, the record this panel credited—notice before sending the vocational report, supplemental reports engaging with it, and vocational analysis tied to the medical restrictions—shows what supports a total disability claim. Our guide to the pretrial conference statement explains how the MSC fixes the trial record.

Building or defending a total disability claim?

Bring the evaluators’ reports, both sides’ vocational reports, the pretrial conference statement and any discovery orders so we can check what was disclosed before the MSC and whether the vocational evidence connects to the medical restrictions. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.