Laurenzano: The Tax Court Can Consider Tolling a Late Petition

An IRS notice of deficiency generally starts a 90-day window to petition the Tax Court before the IRS assesses the disputed tax. On November 18, 2026, in Laurenzano v. Commissioner, the Fourth Circuit held that missing the deadline under 26 U.S.C. § 6213(a) does not strip the Tax Court of jurisdiction. The court held that equitable tolling is available in appropriate cases and returned the case to the Tax Court to decide whether the taxpayer qualifies. The case matters to a late filer in the Fourth Circuit because the reason for the delay can now be considered.
The petition arrived after both possible filing periods
The IRS mailed Peter Laurenzano a $14,151.87 deficiency notice at his Maryland home on September 9, 2024. He said he was on a fishing trip in Florida and the Bahamas when the notice arrived. He assumed he had the 150 days applicable to certain notices addressed to people outside the United States. The Tax Court received his petition on February 19, 2025, 163 days after the IRS mailed the notice. The petition was late even under the longer period. The Tax Court granted the Commissioner’s motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction and did not consider equitable grounds for the delay. Slip opinion at 4.
Why the court treated the deadline as a rule for taxpayers
The Commissioner relied in part on two earlier Fourth Circuit decisions that had treated the deadline as jurisdictional. The government also argued that the design of the deficiency and assessment process depends on a fixed filing deadline. The panel applied the Supreme Court’s later clear-statement standard. It examined what the statute actually says about the Tax Court’s authority. Slip opinion at 5–7, 10–12.
The first sentence of § 6213(a) tells the taxpayer when to file a deficiency petition. A later sentence in the same subsection expressly ties timeliness to the court’s jurisdiction to order particular injunctive or refund relief. Congress used a direct link to jurisdiction for those remedies. The panel found no comparable language linking the redetermination filing deadline to the Tax Court’s power to hear the petition. The earlier cases had used a jurisdictional label without giving the reasoned analysis the Supreme Court’s later decisions require. Slip opinion at 6–11.
The court also drew on the Supreme Court’s decision in Boechler, P.C. v. Commissioner. That case concerned a filing deadline for review of a collection due process determination under § 6330(d)(1). The Supreme Court found no clear link between timeliness and jurisdiction even though that statute referred to jurisdiction in the same sentence. The Fourth Circuit reasoned that § 6213(a) had still less textual support for treating the redetermination deadline as jurisdictional. Slip opinion at 8–9.
Why the court allowed tolling in appropriate cases
Finding a rule nonjurisdictional leaves a separate question about equitable tolling. The Fourth Circuit applied the ordinary presumption that a nonjurisdictional time limit allows tolling. A taxpayer must generally show diligent pursuit of their rights and an extraordinary circumstance that prevented timely filing. The panel found that § 6213(a)’s permissive language, relatively short filing period and structure supported applying that presumption. Slip opinion at 12–14.
The First Circuit had reached a different result on tolling in Kyick Holdings, LLC v. Commissioner, treating nine statutory provisions as evidence that Congress had specified the available exceptions. The Fourth Circuit accepted only four as directly relevant to this analysis. For example, a deadline stated on the notice can make a petition timely, and the Chapter 11 stay provision can suspend the filing period. It treated the 150-day period as its own deadline. Other provisions outside § 6213 address situations like combat-zone and disaster relief. The Supreme Court had already found similar provisions compatible with equitable tolling in Boechler. Those points explain why the two circuits disagreed even though both viewed the filing period as nonjurisdictional. Slip opinion at 14–17.
What matters for a late filer
The Fourth Circuit vacated the dismissal and remanded. The Tax Court must decide whether Laurenzano’s facts justify tolling. The opinion establishes the availability of that review in the Fourth Circuit. Outside the Fourth Circuit, the controlling authority can lead to a different result. Tolling is an exceptional remedy. It requires evidence of diligence and an extraordinary circumstance that prevented timely filing. Slip opinion at 12, 15–18.
Check the last day to petition printed on the notice, and confirm the applicable deadline promptly if the date is uncertain or has passed. Keep the notice, envelope, proof of attempted filing and records showing what kept a petition from being filed on time. In a tolling dispute, the chronology of what the taxpayer did and what prevented filing can matter as much as the final date the court received the petition.
Questions about a Tax Court filing deadline?
Bring the deficiency notice, the envelope and any available record of your filing or attempted filing so we can review the timeline with you. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.