Krzesni: Federal Grant Whistleblowers Must Report Misconduct Before the Employer Acts

An employee of a federal grant recipient is protected from retaliation only for a disclosure that a reasonable, informed observer would see as evidence of misconduct, and the disclosure must precede the employment decision it allegedly influenced. Applying that test, the Ninth Circuit affirmed summary judgment against a project director whose contract was not renewed after he documented a grant-funded trip to Hawaii. His report described the trip as a legitimate grant activity, his question to a supervisor disclosed nothing, and the one call that might have counted came after the school district had already decided not to renew him.
The decision is Krzesni v. Wellpinit School District, No. 25-3308 (9th Cir. July 27, 2026), a published opinion by Judge Clifton, joined by Judges Hawkins and Ryan Nelson. It interprets 41 U.S.C. § 4712, the whistleblower provision that protects employees of federal contractors, subcontractors, grantees, subgrantees and personal services contractors.
A grant, a trip to Hawaii and a contract not renewed
Wellpinit School District, on the Spokane Reservation in Washington, hired David Krzesni in January 2023 to direct a federal Native Youth Community Project Grant. The district had already planned a March 2023 peer-mediation trip to Hawaii. Krzesni signed the requisition to pay for it with grant money and submitted a revised budget. The Department of Education’s grant contact, Donna Bussell, replied that the Hawaii travel “was not in the original grant application therefore it will not be approved.” On March 2, Krzesni wrote to the district’s business manager that approval would likely come after the trip.
The group, including Krzesni, went without approval. The annual performance report he prepared, submitted April 27, 2023, listed $55,011.05 in trip expenses and explained how the trip furthered the grant’s objectives.
On May 1, the superintendent contacted the district’s general counsel about Krzesni, and the next day they discussed not renewing his contract. On the morning of May 8, administrators decided not to renew it when it expired on September 30, 2023. That same day, Bussell told Krzesni in a call that drawing down grant funds for the trip without prior authorization was “fraud.” The district later reimbursed the government, and the district court granted the district and superintendent summary judgment on Krzesni’s section 4712 and Washington claims.
The four parts of a section 4712 claim
The court set out the prima facie elements: A covered employee must communicate a protected disclosure to a qualified person or body and suffer an adverse employment action as a reprisal for that disclosure. Qualified recipients include a federal employee responsible for grant oversight, an inspector general and a manager responsible for addressing misconduct. A protected disclosure contains information the employee reasonably believes is evidence of gross mismanagement, gross waste of federal funds, abuse of authority, a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety, or a violation of law, rule or regulation related to the grant or contract.
“Reasonably believes” is an objective test. Following its readings of the identically worded defense-contractor statute and the similarly worded Sarbanes-Oxley provision, the court held that the belief is reasonable “if a disinterested observer with knowledge of the operative facts would reasonably conclude that the disclosure evidences” misconduct, joining other circuits. That inquiry looks at what the disclosure actually says.
On causation, the employee must show the disclosure was a contributing factor in the decision. If he does, the employer can still prevail by showing with clear and convincing evidence that it would have taken the same action anyway.
A report that defended the trip was not a disclosure
Krzesni argued that the annual performance report was a protected disclosure. The court disagreed: The report called the trip “a unique opportunity for cultural exchange and traditional Hawaiian restorative justice training” and tied it to grant objectives on discipline, attendance and academic performance. A descriptive account with no explicit or implicit suggestion of wrongdoing, paired with statements justifying the expense, could not objectively evidence misconduct. As the court put it, “The APR did not blow a whistle.”
A rhetorical question disclosed nothing
Krzesni also said that, on learning the funds had been drawn down without approval, he asked a supervisor, “So this is how we do things?” He had not raised this theory in the district court. Even on the merits, the question conveyed no information about misconduct, so it was not a protected disclosure.
The call came after the decision
The May 8 call with Bussell was the strongest candidate, and the district court thought a protected disclosure might have occurred there. It did not matter. Krzesni’s opening brief conceded that the superintendent began the nonrenewal process on May 1, and nothing in the record showed the district knew of any protected activity when it decided. “An adverse action that preceded a purported disclosure could not have been taken in retaliation for that disclosure,” the court wrote. Even assuming the call was protected, there was no reprisal.
Nonrenewal was not a discharge under Washington law
Krzesni’s Washington claim for wrongful discharge in violation of public policy failed separately. Washington’s Supreme Court limits that tort to discharged employees, and Washington courts treat a nonrenewal differently; his contract was not renewed; he was not discharged, so he could not show the discharge element.
What this means for employees paid with federal money
Section 4712’s federal contractor and grant protections also apply in California. The Ninth Circuit interpreted the federal statute, and its separate ruling on nonrenewal addressed Washington tort law.
- Say what is wrong. A report that only describes spending, or that defends it, is unlikely to qualify. A disclosure should state the facts that make the spending improper, such as missing approval, and go to a person or office the statute lists.
- Timing is evidence. A disclosure cannot have caused an employment decision the employer had already made. Keep the dates of your reports and the employer’s decisions.
- Follow the statute’s path. File with the agency’s inspector general within three years of the alleged reprisal. Under § 4712(c)(2), an agency denial or inaction for 210 days after filing ordinarily opens a two-year window to sue in federal district court. With an agreed investigation extension, the inaction trigger is 30 days after the extension expires. A delay caused by the complainant’s bad faith can prevent deemed exhaustion. Either side may request a jury.
- Check state law too. A California employee may also have a claim under Labor Code section 1102.5, which has its own burden framework; see our analysis of Lawson v. PPG.
Lost your job after reporting misuse of federal funds?
Bring what you reported and to whom, with dates, the grant or contract documents, your nonrenewal or termination notice and any record of when the decision was made. We can assess whether your report qualifies and which deadlines apply, federal and state. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.