Intermountain Electronics: Custom Mining Equipment Did Not Earn the R&D Credit Without Reliable Time Records

Flowing copper-colored strands interweave with broad sea-green bands in a richly textured abstract field.

The Tax Court denied a Utah maker of custom mining electrical equipment the research credit for ten of the twelve sample projects it tried, because the company could not prove genuine design uncertainty, or reliable hours spent resolving it. It allowed the credit for two in-house ground-monitor products: Their supply costs and the wages of its own employees qualified, but the unsubstantiated cost of outside contractors did not. The rulings decide only those twelve projects; the court expects the parties to use them to settle the thousands of others.

Judge Buch issued the memorandum opinion in Intermountain Electronics, Inc. v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2026-118, Docket No. 11019-19, on November 17, 2026. Intermountain claimed credits of about $1.1 million to $1.56 million a year for 2012 through 2015; the IRS disallowed the credits and determined deficiencies of $498,847 to $1,051,499 a year.

A custom shop and a credit study built after the fact

Intermountain, based in Price, Utah, designs and builds transformers, control buildings called e-houses and other electrical equipment for mines and oil and gas sites. Most jobs are custom, fixed-fee orders that follow a seven-phase process of design, review, fabrication and testing.

Time records were the weak point. Engineers typically did not log their time in the company’s accounting system, and salaried employees had no time-tracking requirement. A consulting firm later estimated qualifying costs from sampled projects and interviews, and the company amended its returns.

What the credit requires

Section 41 gives a credit for qualified research expenses above a base amount. For the 2012 through 2015 tax years at issue, the court applied four tests to each product: (1) the costs are research expenses under section 174; (2) the research seeks technological information; (3) it is meant to develop a new or improved product; and (4) substantially all of it is part of a process of experimentation. “Substantially all” means at least 80% of the research activities, measured by cost or another consistent basis. Funded research is excluded, and the taxpayer must prove every element, including the amount.

The court’s section 174 test required the taxpayer to show that the information available to it did not establish the right design, and that it actually investigated to resolve that uncertainty. Running basic calculations on data already in hand does not count.

A design that might change is not enough

Intermountain argued that every project stayed uncertain until built, because workers kept finding flaws, and that its seven-phase process mirrored the scientific method. The court rejected both blanket arguments. “The mere possibility of altering the design in later stages does not itself establish that uncertainty remained.” And, quoting its 2024 Phoenix Design Group decision, the court said that “[m]erely connecting an activity to a larger plan that may resemble the scientific method does not satisfy the process of experimentation test.”

Real design problems, but no reliable hours

Two custom projects did involve genuine uncertainty. Hillsboro was the company’s first longwall system, with a self-propelled monorail and a custom transformer; Tallgrass was its longest e-house.

Both still failed. For Hillsboro, the engineers “did not track their hours but estimated them after the fact,” and two exhibits disagreed: One showed 374 engineering hours on seven subprojects, the other 222.15. For Tallgrass, an engineer testified that he had applied his time to a different e-house. Without reliable hours, Intermountain could not show which wages went to resolving the uncertainty or that 80% of the activity was experimentation.

Nor could the court credit only part of a project. Crediting only early-phase wages or splitting costs by department failed because engineers were not paid only to resolve uncertainty, and the hour spreadsheets were “broken down by discipline,” but “not consistently broken down by subset or issue confronted by Intermountain engineers.”

Supply costs required separate proof. Under the rules the court applied, even a fully functional product could be a pilot model if made to evaluate and resolve uncertainty. The court found no showing that the custom products were made for that purpose; the record showed final products built for customers.

A contract that gave the results away

The Kearl Oil Sands job, seven e-houses for an Alberta project, was funded research. The purchase terms assigned any inventions to the buyer, barred Intermountain from using the information furnished for the order on any other project, and gave the buyer a perpetual, royalty-free license under Intermountain’s own rights. “It is challenging to imagine what, if any, rights Intermountain retains in the work product at all,” the court wrote. With no substantial rights retained, the research was excluded even if Intermountain bore the cost risk. It also failed section 174, because Intermountain had built e-houses many times.

Repeat jobs, repair hours and paint

The remaining custom projects failed on their own records. One LACT unit was marked a “repeat job,” used the customer’s complete electrical drawings and logged 0.02 engineering hours. A Whiting saltwater disposal skid failed because Intermountain’s “internal documents show that it ordered a pump that it had used in other locations.” A Whiting e-house followed a standard design; “The consequence of repetition is expertise.” A drive controller rested on the claim that the product was complex, which “does not suffice.” A controller repair job logged only repair hours, an arc-flash door only cutting and painting, and a mine transformer no engineering at all. Small projects got no easier test: “The burden of proof does not change with the size of the project.”

What the company won: two ground monitors

The IRS agreed that two proprietary projects, the GLT 500 and GMS 504-DZ ground monitors, were qualified research; they were designed from a clean sheet, tested, redesigned and patented. The court credited the time estimates of the research department’s head, whose principal work was research, and of the two interns he supervised. The IRS conceded wage and supply expenses for these projects totaling $287,162 and $243,944, which the opinion says “could be allocated over 2011 through 2014.” The record held no 2015 study, but the court accepted 2015 wage and supply amounts because the consultant’s representative testified that one was done and “the record contains the information necessary to support” them. Only the wage claim was cut back: Intermountain claimed pay to its employees and third-party contractors, but contractor costs were not substantiated, so qualified wages are limited to “the amount paid in wages to its own employees involved in the proprietary research projects.” In its November 18 order, the court directed the parties to file either an agreed computation for entry of decision under Rule 155 or a joint status report on the remaining projects by February 12, 2027.

What this means for a manufacturer claiming the credit

These points are our reading of the opinion.

Claiming the research credit for custom work?

Bring the credit study, the project list, any time records, the customer contracts and the IRS examination letters. Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review which projects your records can support and how to present them in an audit or Tax Court case. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.