Hoffman: A Union ADR Program Took the Comp Claims, but Section 132a Stayed With the WCAB

Violet and ocher currents sweep apart across a textured ultramarine field.

A city electrician whose union contract sends comp disputes to an alternative dispute-resolution program could not bring his medical treatment and temporary disability disputes to the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board, even though he said the program was stalling him. In Hoffman v. City of Los Angeles, Nos. ADJ18998863, ADJ20148054, ADJ19129371, ADJ18808115, ADJ18807342 & ADJ18805265 (Cal. W.C.A.B. Nov. 16, 2026), the Appeals Board held that it must honor a program approved under Labor Code section 3201.7 and that complaints about the program’s fairness belong to the Administrative Director. But the Board kept jurisdiction over the claims the contract leaves out, including his pending section 132a discrimination petition, and it removed the order dismissing his cases.

The panel consisted of Commissioners Kelly and Dodd and Chair Zalewski.

Six claims and a contract that replaced the usual process

Thomas Joseph Hoffman, a communications electrician for the City of Los Angeles, represented himself. He had six claims with injury dates from August 21, 2018, through November 7, 2024, including a cumulative period from March 4, 2023, through March 5, 2024.

The City’s memoranda of understanding with the building trades council contain an ADR Program Agreement. Under it, the program “shall be used in place of the filing of an application with the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board” and is “the sole means of dispute resolution.” A separate article lists the claims the program does not cover: Labor Code section 132a, serious and willful misconduct, death claims, and claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act and California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act.

In February 2026, Hoffman filed a declaration of readiness seeking medical treatment and temporary disability. The City objected that the ADR program controlled. In May he filed a petition for removal saying he was being “starved out” by the City’s delays in the program, and he filed a section 132a petition. A June 23 trial addressed one issue: whether the WCAB had jurisdiction. On August 14 the judge found no WCAB jurisdiction over the underlying issues and dismissed his cases without prejudice.

Why the Board had to honor the program

Section 3201.7 says the Department of Industrial Relations and the courts “shall recognize as valid and binding” a qualifying labor-management agreement. The panel treated that language as requiring recognition of this duly approved agreement and exhaustion of its procedures for the benefit disputes it covered. Section 3201.7(a)(3)(A) preserves review in the same manner as reconsideration of a final order. Hoffman described the Board’s review as limited to final arbitrator rulings. In Dunne v. City and County of San Francisco, No. ADJ22209281 (Cal. WCAB July 10, 2026), another panel addressed removal review of a nonfinal medical-examiner ruling under a different ADR agreement. The agreement and the order at issue therefore matter when choosing the review route.

The Board found the City proved its agreement. It was approved by the State on or about October 2, 2018, and remained in effect through periods covering every injury date Hoffman claimed. Hoffman offered no evidence that it was not properly executed or authorized, that he was outside the union it bound, or that it otherwise did not apply to him. On that record, the Board wrote, “we must recognize defendant’s ADR Program Agreement,” and the WCAB lacked jurisdiction over the workers’ compensation issues it covers.

Complaints about the program belong to the Administrative Director

Hoffman’s main argument was that the program was invalid because it was not a “functioning, fair, and neutral forum.” The WCAB can decide whether it has jurisdiction, but “that authority does not extend to reviewing the fairness, neutrality, validity, or otherwise of an ADR program properly approved pursuant to section 3201.7.” Those questions fall within the Administrative Director’s authority, which a workers’ compensation judge may not override.

The Board relied on its earlier decision in Jimenez, Perez v. Samuel Hale, LLC (2020) 85 Cal.Comp.Cases 717, which explained that “[t]he legislature conferred jurisdiction in the AD [Administrative Director] to recognize labor-management agreements pursuant to section 3201.7—not the WCAB . . . .” The judge’s report, which the Board quoted, noted that Hoffman complained that the arbitrator had dismissed his claim, but “had applicant filed a petition for reconsideration of the arbitrator’s alleged self-dismissal, then jurisdiction on that issue would have been with the Appeals Board.” The judge noted he had not filed one.

Why the section 132a claim stayed, but did not bring the rest

The Board keeps jurisdiction over disputes that cannot be decided through an ADR program but remain within its authority. Section 132a vests only the WCAB “with full power, authority and jurisdiction to try and determine finally all [employee discrimination claims],” and nothing in the section expressly permits exceptions. Because the agreement itself excludes section 132a, death and serious and willful misconduct claims, the WCAB retains jurisdiction over them.

Hoffman also argued that because the WCAB must hear his section 132a claim, it must hear his benefit claims too. The Board disagreed; he cited no authority for that. Although the contract also excludes federal disability and California fair employment claims, the Board explained that “our jurisdiction does not extend to claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and the California Fair Employment and Housing Act.”

The Board agreed with the judge that the trial concerned jurisdiction over the underlying cases. Hoffman’s pending section 132a claim remained for the Board to decide.

What the amended order does

The Board granted reconsideration and affirmed the judge’s decision as amended. The amended finding says the WCAB lacks jurisdiction over the underlying workers’ compensation issues in the six cases but “does have jurisdiction to decide the issue of applicant’s claims that are excluded by the ADR Program Agreement.” The amended order places all six cases in the City’s ADR program, keeps WCAB jurisdiction over the excluded claims, including section 132a, death and serious and willful misconduct claims, and defers any issues arising from them. The dismissal is gone, because a section 132a claim the WCAB must hear was pending.

What this means if your contract has a carve-out

These points are our reading of the decision.

Is your comp claim stuck in a union ADR program?

Bring the ADR article from your union contract, including its list of excluded claims, any arbitrator orders, your declarations of readiness and any section 132a petition. We can sort out which claims belong in the program, which can still go to the Appeals Board, and which arbitrator rulings can be reviewed. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.