Fine v. Commissioner: Form 872-T Cannot End a Fixed-Date IRS Extension You Signed on Form 872

When a taxpayer and the IRS properly sign Form 872 to extend the tax assessment deadline to a fixed date, the taxpayer cannot cut the extension short by sending Form 872-T. The U.S. Tax Court held that only the passage of time ends a Form 872, so notices of deficiency issued before the agreed date were timely even though the taxpayers had tried to terminate the extensions months earlier.
Judge Ashford decided Fine v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 13 (Sept. 30, 2026), Docket No. 24390-21 on the IRS’s motion for partial summary judgment. The Tax Court had reached the same result in a 1993 memorandum opinion, Coggin, but the Eleventh Circuit affirmed that case on other grounds and left the question open; Fine now decides it in a reported opinion.
Two extensions, a failed appeal and a fax
For this motion, the court took the facts from the pleadings and motion papers. Barry Holmes Fine and Monica Dias filed their 2015 and 2016 returns in October 2016 and October 2017, and both were audited. They signed Form 872 consents extending the 2015 assessment period to December 31, 2020, and then, by a second consent, to December 31, 2021. For 2016 they signed a Form 872 extending the period to June 30, 2021. The IRS countersigned each form.
When talks at the IRS Independent Office of Appeals failed, their lawyer on September 11, 2020 faxed a Form 872-T for each year, one to the Appeals officer and one to the Examination group manager, asking the IRS to end the extensions and issue a notice of deficiency quickly. Form 872-T has no box for ending a Form 872, so the box for ending Form 872-A was checked, and copies of the Forms 872 were attached.
The IRS issued notices of deficiency dated April 15, 2021: $405,943 for 2015 and $210,003 for 2016, with accuracy-related penalties of $81,189 and $42,001. The taxpayers argued in Tax Court that the IRS had only 90 days after receiving the Forms 872-T to issue the notices, so the April 2021 notices came too late.
Two IRS forms that work differently
The IRS generally has three years after a return is filed to assess tax. Section 6501(c)(4)(A) lets the taxpayer and the IRS agree in writing, before that period runs out, to a later deadline, and to extend it again by later written agreements. The notices came more than three years after the returns, so they were timely only if the extensions held.
The IRS uses two forms for these agreements:
- Form 872 sets a specific end date that the parties agree on.
- Form 872-A is open-ended. When the taxpayer uses Form 872-T, the 90 days start when the IRS office handling the case receives the form. If the IRS sends Form 872-T, the 90 days start when the IRS mails it to the taxpayer’s last known address.
Once the IRS produced the signed consents, the taxpayers had to prove them invalid; as the court put it, quoting the Eleventh Circuit, “The ultimate burden of proof on the limitations defense always rests on the taxpayer.”
Why the court held the taxpayers to the date
The court treated the consent as a waiver rather than a contract, but used contract principles to read what the parties agreed to, looking within the four corners of the form. An agreement of indefinite length, like Form 872-A, can generally be ended by either side; an agreement with a specified end date is enforced as written.
Three points decided the motion:
- The forms themselves. Form 872-A says it can be ended with Form 872-T, and Form 872-T asks the taxpayer to check that it is ending a Form 872-A. Form 872-T lists no option for ending a Form 872, and Form 872 never mentions Form 872-T. The court read that omission as showing Form 872-T is meant for Form 872-A only.
- The fairness argument. The taxpayers said they should be able to end the extension because the IRS has the “unilateral ability to terminate the Form 872 by issuing a [Notice of Deficiency] or ceasing Appeals consideration.” The court answered that a notice issued before the agreed date is simply timely action; the taxpayer’s protection is the right to refuse the next extension, which forces the IRS to issue a notice of deficiency or be barred from assessing. “Today,” the court wrote, “we determine that only the passage of time can terminate Form 872.”
- The bargain they made. The taxpayers, through counsel, could have negotiated a shorter period, limited the extension to certain issues, or declined to sign later extensions. By their own account they wanted out because Appeals did not produce a favorable result, and the court held that unhappiness with settlement talks is no reason to undo a valid agreement.
The taxpayers also relied on a Ninth Circuit footnote in Kelley v. Commissioner saying Form 872-T may end a Form 872. The Tax Court read that footnote as a recital of facts, not a ruling, and said that, even if it were a ruling, it would only be persuasive in this case, which, because the taxpayers lived in Florida when they filed, is appealable to the Eleventh Circuit. Our reading: For Californians, whose Tax Court appeals in individual deficiency cases generally go to the Ninth Circuit, the Tax Court has now said the Kelley footnote does not decide the question.
What was decided, and what remains
The court held that faxing the Forms 872-T did not end the Forms 872. The 2015 consent ran to December 31, 2021, and the 2016 consent to June 30, 2021, so notices dated April 15, 2021 were timely, the court had jurisdiction over both years, and it granted the IRS partial summary judgment on the limitations issue. The order was entered October 5, 2026.
The ruling decides only timeliness. The remaining deficiency and penalty issues were tried remotely on March 1–3, 2023, and the public docket showed no decision on them as of November 19, 2026. The case is consolidated with Docket No. 33340-21, where this motion was not at issue.
Before you sign an extension
Our reading: Fine moves the real decision to the moment the IRS asks for more time. Section 6501(c)(4)(B) requires the IRS, each time it asks, to tell you that you may refuse or may limit the extension to particular issues or a particular period. If an audit is open, collect every consent you signed and note whether each is a Form 872 or a Form 872-A, its end date and any written limits. For how the separate fraud exception can keep a year open with no consent at all, see our guide on whether the IRS can assess tax after three years for fraud.
Asked to extend an IRS audit deadline?
Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review the IRS’s request, every Form 872 or 872-A you have signed and the audit file to help you decide whether to agree, narrow the extension or decline, and can review whether a notice of deficiency was issued in time. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.