Fahey: Why California Could Not Collect an LLC’s Tax From Its Owner

A worker boxes a wrapped potted plant on a greenhouse workbench.

California’s Franchise Tax Board tried to collect Red Branch Ranch, LLC’s unpaid 2017 taxes from its sole owner, P. Fahey. The Office of Tax Appeals reversed the assessment against him. The company had paid him $200,000 in consulting fees, and the record supported that it had received reasonably equivalent value in services. Appeal of Fahey, Transferee of Red Branch Ranch, LLC, 2026-OTA-510, at 2, 5–6 (Aug. 11, 2026).

The company’s tax bill and the proposed assessment against its owner

Red Branch Ranch elected to be taxed as a corporation effective January 1, 2017. Tax election at 1–2. It filed its 2017 California corporate return late and reported $62,246 in tax and a $15,562 late-filing penalty, plus interest. The company’s Schedule V reported $200,000 in consulting fees paid to Fahey. Return and payment at 2.

The proposed assessment against Fahey as transferee listed $62,246 in tax, a $15,361.50 late-filing penalty, a $1,583.32 estimated tax penalty, a $322 collection cost recovery fee, and interest. The notice sustaining that assessment gave his membership as the reason he was liable. He appealed, and the panel decided the appeal on the written record. Assessment and written-record posture at 1 and notice at 2.

What FTB had to prove about the payment

The LLC’s election made it a taxpayer separate from Fahey. The panel explained that holding an ownership or management role alone does not make someone responsible for the LLC’s debts. FTB sought to enforce the company’s existing liability against Fahey as a transferee and did not argue that he had agreed to take on the debts. The panel therefore applied California’s rules for transferee liability in equity. Opinion at 3.

The panel treated the consulting payment itself as a transfer. It was FTB’s burden, by a preponderance of the evidence, to establish each required element, including that the company received less than reasonably equivalent value in exchange. Burden and transfer at 4.

The payment was only the starting point. The panel’s test also asked when the LLC became liable for the tax, whether the payment came after that liability accrued, whether the company was or became insolvent, and whether FTB had exhausted reasonable remedies against it. The value finding decided the appeal. In a footnote, the panel also pointed to the timing of the tax, balance sheets showing assets above current liabilities, and the absence of evidence of collection attempts. Those were separate questions about the company and the agency’s collection record. Equitable transferee test at 4 and panel’s observations at 6 n.7.

The relevant value is measured at the time of the transfer from the creditor’s perspective. FTB argued that Fahey’s tax reporting stood alone and that he had supplied too little documentation to substantiate the amount paid for his services. Value and FTB’s argument at 5.

Why the records supported the value of Fahey’s work

Fahey submitted a declaration describing what he did for the cannabis business. His work included cultivation, processing, packaging, and arranging wholesale sales. The panel found his account credible and compared it with the rest of the record. The company reported about $5.56 million in gross receipts or sales and $704,137 in net income. Fahey was its sole shareholder and officer, and the record identified no other workers who ran the business that year. His personal returns reported the $200,000 as his only income, and he paid self-employment tax on it. Opinion at 5.

That evidence supported the panel’s finding that the company received reasonably equivalent value for the payment. FTB offered no evidence establishing the contrary. Finding on value at 5. The panel reversed the assessment against Fahey on that basis. The opinion is nonprecedential. Disposition at 6.

What to keep if FTB questions a payment to an owner

Start with the notice of proposed assessment. Identify the company’s tax bill, the payment FTB identifies as a transfer, and the basis it gives for collecting from you. Gather agreements, contemporaneous descriptions of the work, invoices, and payment records. Compare those records with how the company and the recipient reported the payment. The evidence in Fahey mattered because it showed both what work the company received and why the company paid for it.

If the dispute is instead about the company’s own deduction, the records serve a different purpose. Our guide to documenting owner compensation for federal deductions explains what to keep for that issue.

Questions about a California tax assessment against an owner?

Bring the assessment, the company’s return and the documents showing what the company received for the disputed payment. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.

Mishra X Trial Lawyers helps individuals and businesses with California tax assessments and appeals from its Irvine office, serving Southern California.