Edgar G.C.: His Father Abused Him Here. That Was Not “Past Torture” in Mexico.

G.C. came to the United States as an infant and became a lawful permanent resident through a Special Immigrant Juvenile petition, a route for certain young people. His father, a member of the Los Zetas cartel, abused him for years before being deported. In 2018, after a man on a parking garage roof called him the word his father used to call him, G.C. “snapped” and beat the man. That assault and a February 2018 petty theft conviction, charged as two crimes involving moral turpitude, put him in removal proceedings, and the immigration judge held the assault a particularly serious crime that barred asylum and withholding of removal. The Ninth Circuit denied his petition in Edgar G.C. v. Bondi, 136 F.4th 832 (9th Cir. 2025), and, in our view, it decided a question that matters to many people who grew up here: abuse that occurred entirely in the United States, with no involvement by an official of the country of removal, was not “past torture” under the Convention Against Torture.
A hard history and a single assault
The opinion describes physical, emotional and sexual abuse by G.C.’s father during childhood. A licensed clinical social worker diagnosed PTSD, major depressive disorder, a psychotic disorder and other conditions. G.C. experiences auditory hallucinations of his father’s insults. He pleaded guilty in 2018 to felony assault with force likely to produce great bodily injury under California Penal Code section 245(a)(4), and he was sentenced to 270 days in county jail and three years of probation. He testified that he punched the man and continued to kick him after he fell. He had been drinking and using drugs.
G.C. sought asylum, withholding of removal and protection under the Convention Against Torture, or CAT. The immigration judge and the Board of Immigration Appeals denied relief.
The conviction and his mental illness
A “particularly serious crime” bars withholding of removal, the protection against being sent to a country where the person would face persecution. For offenses like this one, the agency decides case by case, considering the nature of the conviction, the underlying facts and the sentence to see whether they justify a presumption of danger to the community. Those facts include, the court said, quoting Gomez-Sanchez v. Sessions, 892 F.3d 985 (9th Cir. 2018), “the defendant’s mental condition at the time of the crime.”
G.C. argued that the agency looked only at his PTSD and required hallucinations. The court disagreed. Under Benedicto v. Garland, 12 F.4th 1049 (9th Cir. 2021), the court quoted, considering mental illness “is required only where the petitioner . . . presents . . . evidence directly attributing the crime to his mental illness.” G.C. attributed the attack to the insult, and the judge made that connection to his childhood abuse. The court refused to require a diagnosis-by-diagnosis analysis. It also said the agency had not invented a hallucination requirement. Evidence of hallucinations could have been a mitigating factor, but the record contained none from the time of the offense.
The court added that his reaction to the word “only magnifies the danger he poses,” given a relatively minor provocation. Dangerousness is the “essential key” to this inquiry, the court said, quoting Gomez-Sanchez, and the agency plausibly concluded that his illnesses did not make the assault a less reliable indicator of it. On abuse-of-discretion review, under which the court checks only that the agency used the right factors and evidence, the court could not reweigh that judgment.
Torture must involve the country of removal
CAT protection requires showing that torture is more likely than not, and that it would be inflicted by or with the consent or acquiescence of a public official. G.C. argued that his childhood abuse counted as past torture, pointing out that the withholding regulation refers to past persecution “in the proposed country of removal” while the CAT regulation has no such limit.
The court agreed with the government. The regulatory definition of torture requires involvement or acquiescence by an official of the country of removal, it said, and nothing suggested a Mexican official inflicted, instigated or acquiesced in the abuse, so it was not “past torture.” The evidence might show his father’s intent, the court said, but “it says nothing at all about the Mexican government’s willingness to acquiesce in such torture.” The court distinguished Xochihua-Jaimes v. Barr, 962 F.3d 1175 (9th Cir. 2020), because the abuse there occurred in both Mexico and the United States.
Future risk, and the dissent
The immigration judge and the Board found it was not more likely than not that his father would torture him, relying on the passage of time, unfulfilled death threats and unclear motives. Under the substantial evidence standard, agency findings stand unless any reasonable adjudicator would be compelled to conclude otherwise, and the court held that the record compelled no different conclusion. Because failure on either CAT requirement is fatal, the court did not decide whether the Mexican government would acquiesce.
Judge Sanchez agreed on the particularly serious crime but would have found CAT protection compelled. In a footnote, the majority said it did not read Judge Sanchez to disagree about what the definition requires. Judge Sanchez argued that significant past harm remains highly probative when the perpetrator is now in the country of removal. The majority responded that the agency did consider the history of abuse. It simply did not treat it as past torture.
What this means for a case
These steps are our practical reading of Edgar G.C.
- Tie the illness to the offense. In our view, a declaration and an expert should explain how the condition drove the conduct, because the court limited this inquiry to illness the person directly connects to the crime.
- Do not rely on past harm here alone to prove torture there. In our view, a CAT claim needs evidence about officials in the country of removal.
- Still present the abuse. In our view, it belongs in the record. The court left open how far it bears on future risk, and it noted that the agency had considered it.
- Raise every theory before the Board. In our view, nothing should be held back. His claim about torture by police on account of tattoos and his claim about Mexican jails and mental institutions were not preserved, meaning not properly argued to the Board, so the court did not consider them.
For representation in protection claims, see our deportation defense practice.
Does a conviction threaten your protection claim?
Bring the conviction records, mental health records and your immigration papers. We can review how the evidence connects to the offense and to the risk you face. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.