Eagleman: An Employee’s Request for More Leave Outlasted the FMLA Clock

A worker makes a phone call with papers and an envelope on the kitchen table.

Sally Eagleman gave NaphCare two doctor’s notes asking for more time off, with the second extending through June 6, 2022. NaphCare fired her the day after its designated Family and Medical Leave Act leave ended. The Ninth Circuit reversed summary judgment on four California disability-related claims. A jury could find that a finite period of additional leave would have let her return and that NaphCare terminated her instead of meaningfully considering it. Memorandum at 3–7.

The record at termination supported a possible return

Eagleman’s first note requested leave through May 5, 2022. After sending the second note through June 6, she emailed her supervisor that she had tried to call and nobody was available. The court took her daily calls to check on jail operations as evidence that she wanted to return. NaphCare discussed internally whether it had to hold her position open and terminated her. Memorandum at 3–4.

The district court relied on Eagleman’s later wrist surgery and the fact that she was not cleared to return until January 2023. The Ninth Circuit had to read disputed evidence in Eagleman’s favor at summary judgment. On that reading, neither side anticipated the later surgery and long recovery when NaphCare fired her. A jury could find she could have done the essential work after additional leave. That evidence mattered to the disability-discrimination claim because she bore the burden of showing she could perform the essential functions with or without accommodation. California’s qualification standard separates the required skills, experience and education from the ability to perform the job’s essential functions. The parties agreed she had a disability, and they did not dispute that she met those other job requirements. See title 2, section 11065(o) of the California Code of Regulations. Memorandum at 2–4.

More leave was itself an accommodation to consider

California Government Code section 12940(m)(1) requires reasonable accommodation of a known disability unless the employer shows undue hardship. Continued leave can qualify if it is likely to let the employee return when the leave ends, as the panel explained under title 2, section 11068(c) of the California Code of Regulations. Eagleman’s evidence supported a request for about one more month of leave, with a scheduled June 6 return date. NaphCare argued the earlier extension meant the request was indefinite. The panel treated that dispute as one for a jury. General assertions that it would be burdensome to hold the job open also left a factual dispute over undue hardship. Memorandum at 4–5.

The termination timeline also mattered to retaliation

For retaliation under Government Code section 12940(h), the panel asked whether Eagleman engaged in protected activity, suffered an adverse action, and had evidence linking the two. It rejected the district court’s use of the discrimination claim’s qualification requirement to dispose of retaliation. The request for accommodation was protected under section 12940(m)(2) whether or not NaphCare granted it. Evidence that NaphCare began planning termination after the additional-leave request and before the designated federal leave ran out, followed by termination the next day, created factual disputes over causation and whether the employer’s stated reason was a pretext. Memorandum at 5–6.

The request triggered a duty to talk through options

Government Code section 12940(n) requires a timely, good-faith discussion about accommodation. The panel explained that the employee generally initiates it by identifying the disability and resulting limits and suggesting an accommodation, unless the condition and limits are obvious. The parties disputed obviousness. Eagleman had still informed NaphCare of the disability and asked for extra leave. The panel concluded that the employer then had a duty to discuss possible accommodations. It held a reasonable jury could find that NaphCare failed to do so and that the failure caused harm. The discrimination claim’s qualification requirement did not govern this claim either. Memorandum at 6–7.

Keep the dates and responses together

The notice ending designated federal leave is one document. The medical note with an anticipated return date, the request for additional leave as an accommodation, and the employer’s replies or attempts to discuss it can show what each side knew before the employment decision. Keep those items together so you can reconstruct the timeline if there is a dispute.

Decision

Eagleman v. NaphCare, Inc., No. 24-5666 (9th Cir. Nov. 20, 2026). The Ninth Circuit issued an unpublished memorandum. The decision generally has no precedential effect under Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3. The panel reversed summary judgment and sent the case back to the Central District of California on all four claims. It left Eagleman’s punitive-damages claim and assertion of judicial estoppel for the district court to address in the first instance. Memorandum at 7 & n.1.