Diaz Hernandez: A Vacated Dismissal Left the Case on the Calendar

A worker pins a fresh appointment slip above an older notice marked through.

A workers’ compensation judge dismissed Maria Diaz Hernandez’s case after the employer represented that it had received no objection. When her lawyer objected and said she was still receiving treatment and wanted to pursue the case, the judge set the dismissal aside and scheduled a status conference. The employer challenged that step. The Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board dismissed the petition for reconsideration because the order left the dismissal question open, then denied extraordinary review by removal. The next step remained a conference where both sides could be heard. Diaz Hernandez, pp. 1–2, 4, 6–7

The November 16, 2026 order is a regular WCAB panel decision. Other panels and judges may consider it for the persuasiveness of its reasoning. Diaz Hernandez v. Kendall Farms, No. ADJ19811349 (Cal. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. Nov. 16, 2026). WCAB panel decisions and status

Two orders had different effects on the case

According to the judge’s report, the employer first petitioned to dismiss the case in January 2026. That request was denied after service at an incorrect address. The employer renewed its request in May, and a notice of intent to dismiss issued the same day. On July 15, the judge dismissed the case without prejudice based on the representation that no objection had been served on the employer or the court.

On August 13, Diaz Hernandez’s lawyer filed an objection and a petition for reconsideration. The judge’s August 25 order vacated and rescinded the dismissal and set a conference. As the judge explained, the conference would address the objection and help determine whether the dismissal should stand. The first order terminated the proceeding before the judge. The second restored it to the calendar so the judge could address a disputed procedural step. Diaz Hernandez, pp. 1–2

The August order left the parties’ rights for later decision

Reconsideration is available for a final decision affecting a substantive right, liability, or threshold issue fundamental to benefits. The Board held that the August order decided none of those things. It cleared the way to hear from both sides. The availability of reconsideration turned on what the August order actually did, even though the order dealt with an earlier dismissal. Diaz Hernandez, pp. 3–4

The Board separately found that it acted within the time allowed under section 5909(a). The judge transmitted the case on September 15, 2026, and the 60th day fell on a Saturday, so the Board applied its next-business-day rule and issued the decision on Monday, November 16. Diaz Hernandez, pp. 2–3 & n.2

The employer argued that the worker’s earlier reconsideration petition was late and that Rule 10961 therefore deprived the judge of power to act. The panel left the timeliness question unresolved. The panel relied on the Board’s authority under Labor Code section 5803 to revisit an order for good cause after notice and an opportunity to be heard. The panel quoted Rule 10966, which permits a judge to amend a decision for good cause before a reconsideration petition is filed, subject to Labor Code sections 5803 and 5804. In the next page of the opinion, the panel’s paraphrase gives sections 5903 and 5904. The published rule and the panel’s own quotation both list sections 5803 and 5804. Rule 10966 The panel concluded that an asserted filing defect under the procedural rules did not displace the continuing jurisdiction it recognized here. The status conference gave the parties a chance to make their arguments before a decision on the dismissal. Diaz Hernandez, pp. 5–6

Removal required a showing the employer did not make

The Board treated the employer’s challenge as a request for removal. Rule 10955(a) requires significant prejudice or irreparable harm and a showing that reconsideration after a final decision would be inadequate. The panel explained that the employer could present its concerns at the conference and seek review after a final adverse decision if appropriate. The employer failed to show why that process would be insufficient on this record. Rule 10955 · Diaz Hernandez, pp. 4–6

If a dismissal is vacated in your case, read the new order for the precise ruling and the next scheduled proceeding. Keep both orders and their service records. If the new order calls for a conference, make sure your lawyer has any notice or objection that bears on what the judge will consider. A ruling on the dismissal and a ruling on entitlement to benefits answer different questions.

This article provides general information about California law.

Did a judge dismiss your workers’ comp case?

Bring the dismissal order, any later order and the documents showing when each was served. We can review those documents with you. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.