Davodyan: A Treating Doctor’s Reports Raised a Separate Question About Payment for Care

A clinician places a body-diagram sheet and a separate clipped report side by side in an exam room.

Ariga Davodyan’s workers’ compensation claim was denied, and the employer furnished no treatment. At a later lien hearing, the judge found the injury compensable but rejected several charges from the treating doctor. The Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board agreed that three of the disputed reports did not qualify as medical-legal expenses. It sent the matter back so the judge could decide whether the same services were reasonably required treatment the employer should have provided. Davodyan, pp. 1–2, 6–9

The November 16, 2026 decision is a regular WCAB panel decision. Its reasoning is persuasive authority to the extent it fits the record in another case. Davodyan v. Printograph, Inc., No. ADJ13441476 (Cal. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd. Nov. 16, 2026). WCAB panel decisions and status

Why the denial did not establish that every report qualified

Printograph’s insurer denied the claim in August 2020. Davodyan designated chiropractor Arbi Mirzaians as the primary treating physician in February 2022. The panel recognized the claim was contested when the remaining reports were prepared. For medical-legal reimbursement, that answered only part of the question. Labor Code section 4620 and Rule 9793 direct attention to what the report was obtained to establish and whether it addresses a disputed medical fact. Davodyan, pp. 4–6 · Rule 9793(h)

The panel agreed with the judge on two points about the May 31 and December 7, 2022 and February 1, 2023 reports. None was issued at any party’s request, and their substance duplicated one another and earlier reporting. The reports might have been capable of addressing a disputed medical fact, but the panel did not treat that capability alone as sufficient on this record. Davodyan, pp. 5–6

The Board treated the other billing dates separately

The employer remained liable for medical-legal exams on March 16 and April 19, 2022. The Board directed the parties to calculate the amounts owed, including penalties and interest, less prior payments, with jurisdiction reserved over disputes.

An October 25, 2022 charge was different. The insurer had already paid it without objecting first, and the lien claimants did not seek payment of the principal twice. The Board’s amended finding treated that payment as final and held that the insurer could not recover it. The order turned on the payment and objection record for that charge. Davodyan, p. 4 and p. 8, finding 8

What the judge still has to decide

The judge had disallowed and dismissed the remaining charges without deciding whether the services were treatment. Labor Code section 4600(a) calls for an employer to provide treatment reasonably required to cure or relieve the effects of the injury. When the employer neglects or refuses to do so, the provision addresses liability for reasonable expenses incurred in providing that treatment. Those questions remained open because the judge found the injury compensable for purposes of the lien proceeding and found the employer had furnished no care. Davodyan, pp. 6–7

The panel explained that making the treatment findings itself would deprive the parties of a fair hearing. It granted reconsideration, amended the findings and order in part, and deferred all issues concerning the three dates, including the treatment question and any penalties or interest. The judge can develop the record as appropriate on remand. Davodyan, pp. 7–9

The worker’s claim had already been resolved by a compromise and release approved in April 2023. An earlier panel decision had returned the lien dispute for development of the record on the post-termination defense. The 2026 remand concerns what remains of the provider’s charges. 2025 Davodyan decision, p. 6 n.4 and pp. 9–10

The paperwork serves different purposes. A report requested to answer a disputed medical question and a note documenting treatment may both come from the same doctor. Review what each service was for, who requested it, whether the employer furnished care, and what the billing record shows before drawing a conclusion about reimbursement.

This article provides general information about California law.

Questions about medical bills in a workers’ comp claim?

Bring the treatment records, any requests for medical-legal reports, the bills and the insurer’s written response. We can review the paperwork with you. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.