A-K-R-: When an Immigration Judge Can Refuse More Time to Find a Lawyer

An empty counsel chair across from a blank open folder.

An immigration judge may refuse further time to find a lawyer when the person has not shown good cause, the Board of Immigration Appeals held in Matter of A-K-R-, 29 I&N Dec. 839 (BIA 2026), a published decision of August 14, 2026. The Board also modified its 2012 decision in Matter of C-B-: The only statutory or regulatory time requirement needed to protect the privilege of counsel is that the first hearing not be set earlier than 10 days after the notice to appear is served.

The result turned on the record: He had two continuances, and nothing showed his efforts to find a lawyer were about to succeed.

What he asked for and what he got

The respondent, from India, was detained and issued a notice to appear on January 8, 2026. At his first hearing, on February 3, the judge gave him two weeks to find counsel or file for relief. On February 17 he got two more weeks, with a warning to have a lawyer by the next hearing or represent himself.

On March 2 he appeared alone and admitted the allegations in his notice to appear. The judge sustained the charge of removability. He said he feared return to India. The judge told him he might qualify for withholding of removal or Convention Against Torture protection and set a March 18 deadline to file. On March 18 he had no application, said he could not get documents and asked for another continuance. The judge denied it, deemed his opportunity to apply abandoned and ordered him removed.

On appeal he cited a lack of money, outside help and education. He still had filed no completed application.

Why the Board found no good cause

A judge may grant a continuance “for good cause shown” under 8 C.F.R. § 1003.29, which the Board cited in its 2020 form. His first hearing came 26 days after service, and he got two continuances to seek counsel.

He said he could not reach lawyers or family, yet also that he had discussed his case with a previous attorney and that the attorneys his family contacted required more documents. And the judge had told him about free or low-cost legal services. The Board wrote that “[t]here is no indication that any of the respondent’s efforts to obtain counsel would have been imminently successful.” As for the application, he gave no specifics “as to what diligent steps he took, if any,” to complete it or find help.

The Board concluded that the judge “could have proceeded without granting a second continuance” and dismissed the appeal. Citing Fifth Circuit law, where the case arose, including a decision that one month sufficed for a detained person to find counsel, it found no reasonable argument that he was denied due process or the privilege of counsel.

What changed in C-B-

In Matter of C-B-, 25 I&N Dec. 888 (BIA 2012), a detained, unrepresented man had one hearing, eight days after his notice to appear. He asked for time to get a lawyer; the judge never ruled. The Board sustained his appeal and stated that a judge “must grant a reasonable and realistic period of time to provide a fair opportunity for a respondent to seek, speak with, and retain counsel.”

A-K-R- says C-B- cited no authority for that sentence and never mentioned the 10-day statute, which the eight-day hearing had violated. It called the sentence dicta that departed from the statutory text and withdrew it “as setting forth a statutory or regulatory mandate.” It also sided with the dissent in Rodriguez-Solis v. Blanche, a 2026 Fourth Circuit decision whose majority had relied on C-B-.

The 10-day rule and the rest of the statute

Under 8 U.S.C. § 1229(b)(1), “the hearing date shall not be scheduled earlier than 10 days after the service of the notice to appear, unless the alien requests in writing an earlier hearing date.” The notice must also list available pro bono counsel. Section 1229(b)(3) says the subsection does not prevent proceedings once the 10 days pass and the person “has failed to secure counsel.”

At the hearing’s opening, 8 C.F.R. § 1240.10(a)(1)–(2) requires the judge to advise the person of the right to a lawyer of his or her own choice, at no expense to the government, to “require the respondent to state then and there whether he or she desires representation,” and to confirm receipt of the pro bono list.

California and the Ninth Circuit

As a published precedent, A-K-R- binds immigration judges under 8 C.F.R. § 1003.1(g). But the Board has “historically followed” a federal court of appeals’ precedent “in cases arising in that circuit,” as it explained in Matter of Anselmo, 20 I&N Dec. 25, 31 (BIA 1989). California cases arise in the Ninth Circuit, and A-K-R- discussed only Fourth and Fifth Circuit law.

The Ninth Circuit’s published decision in Biwot v. Gonzales, 403 F.3d 1094 (9th Cir. 2005), says judges “must provide aliens with reasonable time to locate counsel and permit counsel to prepare for the hearing.” With “[n]o bright line,” it weighs the realistic time needed, the timing of requests, the number of continuances, barriers such as detention or language, and bad-faith delay. There, a detained man working with free providers got five business days and was refused two more weeks. The court held that denial was “tantamount to denial of counsel” and that he was “denied his statutory right to counsel.”

The decisions differ. Biwot treats a realistic time to find counsel as part of the statutory right; A-K-R- says the 10-day rule is the only statutory or regulatory time requirement. Biwot remains published Ninth Circuit precedent. Our reading: Its factors likely still matter in California cases.

Preparing for the first hearing

These points are our reading.

See also our guides to immigration court continuance motions and documents to bring an immigration lawyer.

Need more time to find a lawyer, or already denied it?

Bring your notice to appear, every hearing notice, the pro bono list you received and a list of each lawyer or provider you contacted, with dates. If you were ordered removed after a denial, bring the order and its date. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.