Goulart v. Garland: Diligence After a Change in Immigration Law

Goulart v. Garland, 18 F.4th 653 (9th Cir. 2021), shows why a favorable change in immigration law does not, by itself, excuse a late motion to reconsider a removal order. The Ninth Circuit recognized that a legal change can support equitable tolling of the ordinary 30-day deadline. It nevertheless upheld the Board of Immigration Appeals’ denial because the motion offered no evidence of Goulart’s efforts to pursue relief during the years before he learned of the change. Goulart, 18 F.4th at 654–55.
The removal order and later change in law
Goulart was removed in 2013 after the BIA treated a prior conviction as a crime of violence under 18 U.S.C. § 16(b). In 2015, the Ninth Circuit held that provision unconstitutionally vague; the Supreme Court affirmed in Sessions v. Dimaya in April 2018. Goulart learned of the Supreme Court decision on June 9, 2018, and filed a motion to reconsider on July 16. Because the motion came years after the original order, he needed equitable tolling. Goulart, 18 F.4th at 654–55.
What the majority actually decided
The court applied abuse-of-discretion review to the BIA’s tolling decision. Goulart’s motion lacked a declaration or other evidence explaining what he had done to investigate or pursue relief between removal in 2013 and June 2018. Filing after learning of the Supreme Court ruling addressed the later period but left the preceding years unexplained. Goulart, 18 F.4th at 654–55. The Ninth Circuit’s immigration motions guide (current through September 2, 2026) still cites Goulart on that evidentiary point.
Why the 2015 and 2018 decisions mattered
The court noted that the Ninth Circuit had reached the relevant constitutional conclusion in 2015, three years before the Supreme Court affirmed it. Even assuming Goulart did not know about the earlier decision, the BIA could reasonably find inadequate diligence because he presented no account of his efforts over the intervening years. That reasoning concerns this evidentiary record: Reasonable diligence depends on the person’s documented efforts over the relevant interval, not merely the filing date of an appellate opinion. Goulart, 18 F.4th at 655.
The concurrence and dissent sharpen the dispute
Judge VanDyke concurred in the judgment and emphasized that lack of actual knowledge of new law does not alone establish diligence. Goulart, 18 F.4th at 655–60 (VanDyke, J., concurring). Judge Korman dissented, arguing that the majority demanded too much of a removed layperson who sought reconsideration after learning of the Supreme Court’s ruling. Goulart, 18 F.4th at 660–65 (Korman, J., dissenting). Those separate opinions illuminate the disagreement, but the majority opinion controls the outcome.
What a motion record should address
A person seeking reconsideration after a legal change should first calendar the statutory deadline and identify the particular order and legal error. If the filing is late, the tolling request needs a supported chronology: when the person learned of the relevant error, what steps were taken to investigate and obtain advice, what obstacles prevented earlier filing, and what happened after discovery. Goulart is a warning about an unexplained gap, not a promise that any particular showing will succeed. The governing inquiry remains fact-specific, and the court reviewed the BIA’s exercise of discretion. Goulart, 18 F.4th at 654–55.
Key takeaways
- A change in law may permit equitable tolling of the 30-day reconsideration deadline, but does not automatically do so.
- A prompt filing after discovery may still fail if earlier years of diligence are left unexplained.
- Declarations, correspondence, and a dated account of investigation can support a diligence finding.
- The majority affirmed denial on this record; the concurrence and dissent are not the holding.
Evaluate your equitable tolling and diligence record
Our firm reviews BIA decisions, removal orders, and post-removal chronologies for potential motions to reconsider or reopen. Please bring your prior immigration decisions, proof of when you learned of legal developments, and records showing your steps to seek legal advice. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.