Garcia-Rojas v. FTB: FTB Did Not Show a Remote One-Person Practice Was a Unitary Business

A Texas radiologist who read California patients’ scans from his home office won reversal of a judgment that denied his California tax refund. In Garcia-Rojas v. Franchise Tax Board, 120 Cal. App. 5th 347 (2026), review granted, No. S297035 (Cal. Sept. 3, 2026), the Court of Appeal held that the Franchise Tax Board had not shown his one-person practice was a “unitary business.” He did one kind of work for one company. Without that showing, FTB could not win summary judgment under the regulation it relied on. The court left open whether FTB can tax the income another way, and the California Supreme Court has granted review.
A Texas home office, California scans and a refund suit
Xavier Garcia-Rojas lives in Texas. In 2017 he agreed to work as an independent contractor for Stat Radiology Medical Corporation, or StatRad, which sent him imaging studies from medical facilities in California and other states. He read them at home and filed reports through StatRad’s software. StatRad required licenses in 28 states, including California, paid every licensing fee except Texas’s, and supplied the hardware, credentialing, a phone number, a California mailing address, training and California malpractice insurance. It paid him monthly for the images he read: about $305,000 in 2018, $410,000 in 2019 and $382,000 in 2020, on Forms 1099. He reported the income on Schedule C as a sole proprietor.
In July 2019 FTB asked him to file California returns. He filed for 2018 through 2020, paid and claimed refunds, which FTB never answered. He and his wife sued in May 2023, and in September 2024 the San Francisco Superior Court granted FTB summary judgment.
The rule FTB used: regulation 17951-4(c)
The May 1 opinion explained that California taxes a nonresident only on income from California sources and uses FTB’s regulations to divide a nonresident’s business income. Under regulation 17951-4(c), when a nonresident’s sole proprietorship “carries on a unitary business, trade, or profession within and without the state,” its California-source income is computed under the Uniform Division of Income for Tax Purposes Act, the formula rules California uses for multistate businesses.
The trial court held that Garcia-Rojas carried on a unitary business as a matter of law. It reasoned that he did the same type of work for California and non-California patients and used StatRad’s software and resources the same way whatever state’s report he was working on.
What “unitary business” means, and the cases FTB cited
As the party moving for summary judgment, FTB had to show that no material fact was in dispute and that it was entitled to judgment as a matter of law; the Court of Appeal reviewed the ruling independently. That put the regulation’s premise on FTB: It had to establish that this proprietorship was a unitary business.
The court described the term as having a long-settled meaning. It means, in words the court quoted from Bunzl Distribution USA, Inc. v. Franchise Tax Board (2018) 27 Cal.App.5th 986, 991, “two or more business entities that are commonly owned and integrated in a way that transfers value among the affiliated entities.” None of the cases FTB cited applied the theory to a single person or a sole proprietorship engaged in one business activity. They involved multinational banking and manufacturing groups in Barclays, a wholesaler with seven distributing houses in Butler Brothers, one of 15 subsidiaries in Edison California Stores, and a metals company and its subsidiary in A.M. Castle.
One person, one activity, one payer
FTB cited no authority treating a sole proprietor who does one business activity and is paid by one corporation as a unitary business, even when that corporation’s clients are in and outside California. The court’s own research pointed the same way. At most, Garcia-Rojas operated a sole proprietorship engaged in one business activity, and neither the California Supreme Court nor any Court of Appeal had applied the theory to facts like these.
In our reading, that is why the trial court’s facts did not carry the motion. The same work, the same StatRad tools and patients in many states describe one activity performed for clients in several places. They do not identify two businesses that could be combined.
Why the court rejected Bindley and regulation 25120(b)
FTB relied on Appeal of Bindley (Cal. OTA, May 30, 2019, No. 18032402), in which the Office of Tax Appeals treated a self-employed Arizona screenwriter as a unitary business taxable under the same regulation. The court said an OTA decision does not bind it and found Bindley unconvincing: It applied the tests for whether two businesses are unitary while ignoring that there must be separate business activities to unite. Regulation 25120(b) did not fill the gap, because by its terms it applies only when there are “two or more businesses of a single taxpayer.”
What the reversal decides, and Supreme Court review
The court reversed the judgment and the order granting summary judgment, remanded for further proceedings, and awarded the taxpayers their costs on appeal. It expressed “no opinion as to whether the Board can tax Garcia-Rojas under a different legal theory,” and, having reversed, did not reach his other arguments. The opinion ends FTB’s summary-judgment win under regulation 17951-4(c); it does not decide the refund.
On September 3, 2026, the California Supreme Court granted review in No. S297035 and denied a request to depublish the opinion. The order described the opinion as published in part; its citation permission covers only the published portions. This account describes the May 1 opinion’s reasoning, without treating every passage of the archive copy as published authority. Under that order and California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(e), the published opinion may be cited while review is pending for its persuasive value and to establish a conflict in authority, which would let trial courts choose between sides of any such conflict. Outside that limited conflict setting, it has no binding or precedential effect during review. The court’s November 13, 2026 pending-issues list still listed the case and the sole-proprietorship question.
What this means for a remote professional with California clients
The May 1 opinion highlights factual questions when FTB calls a nonresident’s single practice unitary under regulation 17951-4(c). Document the facts the court looked at: where you did the work, how many distinct business activities you run, who pays you, and what the payer supplies. Check the theory FTB actually asserts and any later California Supreme Court ruling. Our guide to nonresident contractor records covers gathering those documents.
If FTB has asked you to file California returns for work done outside the state, our tax team can review the FTB letters, your returns, contracts and 1099s, and advise on a refund claim or the next step in a dispute.
Questions about Garcia-Rojas
Does the decision mean the radiologist gets a refund?
The Court of Appeal did not order a refund. It reversed FTB’s summary judgment without deciding the refund or any other theory of taxation; the Supreme Court granted review on September 3, 2026.
What did FTB have to prove to win without a trial?
That this sole proprietorship was a unitary business under regulation 17951-4(c). The court held that FTB’s cases, Bindley and regulation 25120(b) did not establish that for one person carrying on one business activity.
Questions About an FTB Nonresident Tax Bill?
Mishra X Trial Lawyers can review FTB’s request, your nonresident returns and the work records behind them. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.