WCAB Protects a Separate Medical Evaluation in Police Officer ADR Claim

Decision: Dunne v. City and Cnty. of San Francisco, No. ADJ22209281 (WCAB July 10, 2026).

Professional medical evaluation setting representing an ADR carve-out workers compensation dispute
Alternative dispute-resolution agreements remain subject to WCAB review and basic due-process protections.

A July 2026 panel decision examines how California’s workers’ compensation system reviews disputes arising under a collectively bargained alternative-dispute-resolution program.

Read the official WCAB panel decision.

Authority: This panel decision is persuasive rather than binding en banc precedent.

A Police Officer’s New Cumulative Injury Claim

Christopher Dunne, a San Francisco police officer and sergeant, alleged cumulative injury to his lower extremities and circulatory system in the form of varicose veins. His claim proceeded under a Cal. Lab. Code § 3201.7 ADR program created by collective bargaining.

Dunne had used one independent medical examiner for earlier knee and lumbar injuries. For the new cumulative claim, the parties disputed whether that physician also had to serve as the evaluator.

The WCAB Could Review the Arbitrator’s Order

The City argued that the carve-out agreement and Labor Code did not authorize WCAB removal review of the arbitrator’s decision. The Board rejected that reading. The agreement allowed appeals to the WCAB in the same manner as reconsideration, and nothing in section 3201.7 categorically barred review.

The decision is a reminder that ADR programs can alter procedure, but they do not erase statutory oversight or fundamental due process.

A Separate IME Was Necessary for the New Claim

The record did not establish a stipulation that the first evaluator would handle every later injury. Dunne had removed information about the cumulative claim from a cover letter because the parties anticipated a different evaluation. Forcing the original evaluator onto the new claim would prevent Dunne from fully presenting his position and questions concerning compensability.

The Board upheld designation of a separate physician. Because the ADR agreement had no specific rule for selecting examiners across multiple claims, it used Navarro v. City of Montebello (2014) 79 Cal.Comp.Cases 418 as guidance by analogy. It did not simply replace the negotiated ADR process with the ordinary QME selection rules. The parties’ removal of this cumulative claim from the earlier cover letter was central to the result. Dunne, slip opinion, pages 7–8.

Efficiency Cannot Override Due Process

The Board emphasized that administrative speed cannot come at the expense of a meaningful opportunity to present evidence. Each distinct claim may present different medical questions. But Dunne also discussed the requirement that an evaluator address claims reported before the evaluation. It does not give every later allegation an automatic right to another examiner; the claim timing, agreement and conduct of the parties matter.

Practical Lessons for Carve-Out Claims

Review your ADR carve-out medical evaluator dispute

Mishra X Trial Lawyers represents injured workers in California handling collective bargaining carve-out programs and medical evaluator disputes. Bring your labor agreement ADR rules, panel/IME selection letters, and medical evaluation reports. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.