California’s Knee Treatment Guideline Stayed in Place After the November Withdrawal

If a workers’ compensation reviewer denied or cut back your knee treatment, look at the guideline named in the written decision. California withdrew a proposed update on November 17, 2026. The knee guideline incorporated into the state’s Medical Treatment Utilization Schedule (MTUS) remains the American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine guideline dated December 3, 2019. Check the service date on your decision, too. The withdrawal concerns the proposed guideline and does not change the time to challenge a decision on your own treatment. DWC withdrawal notice · Cal. Code Regs. tit. 8, § 9792.23.6
The July 2026 edition was proposed for adoption
California’s Division of Workers’ Compensation proposed incorporating the July 8, 2026 edition of the knee guideline. It canceled the planned December 1 adoption after learning that the guideline’s publisher expected to revise its recommendations further. The Division said it would begin a new rulemaking after receiving the revised guideline. People who commented on the withdrawn proposal would need to resubmit those comments in the new proceeding. DWC withdrawal notice
Section 9792.23.6 still incorporates the December 3, 2019 edition. The amendment adopting that edition became operative on September 21, 2020. This history matters if a decision refers to an edition by its publication year or by the year California adopted it. Match the full reference to the rule before concluding the reviewer cited the wrong version. California knee treatment regulation
What to look for in your written treatment decision
A utilization-review decision based on medical necessity must identify the relevant medical criteria or guidelines. When a physician cites the MTUS, the citation rule calls for the guideline’s effective year and its chapter and section. Read the guideline reference alongside the clinical reason and the treatment actually requested. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 8, §§ 9792.9.5(e)(7)–(8) and 9792.21.1(d)(1)(A)–(C)
Suppose your doctor requests additional physical therapy after a work-related knee injury. If the reviewer calls the July 2026 proposal the adopted California guideline, flag that passage for your doctor or attorney. If the reviewer identifies the operative guideline but says the request lacked an examination finding or treatment history, the next question is what the medical record actually shows. Keep the request and the full response together so your doctor can compare them.
When the doctor can rely on other medical evidence
The MTUS is the primary source for the scope and extent of care, and its recommendations are presumed correct. If the schedule does not address the condition or injury, that alone cannot justify a denial. California has a sequence for finding other guidelines or peer-reviewed studies in that situation. When the MTUS does address the case and a doctor seeks a departure, the doctor carries the burden of rebutting the presumption that the schedule is correct with a preponderance of scientific medical evidence. The evidence must show a departure is reasonably needed to cure or relieve the effects of the work injury. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 8, §§ 9792.21(c)–(d) and 9792.21.1
Preserve the deadline while you check the guideline
If utilization review denied or modified treatment on medical necessity grounds, check the independent medical review form included with the decision. For a dispute over non-drug knee treatment, the general deadline is 30 days from service of the written decision. The rule sets different start dates if the administrator also disputes liability for the treatment on another ground or if the decision lacks required elements. Get any deadline question reviewed promptly and keep a copy of the written decision and the service information. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 8, § 9792.10.1(a), (b), (e) · DWC Form IMR