California Fair Chance Act: Background Checks After a Job Offer, the Individualized Assessment and Your Time to Respond

If a California employer with five or more employees offered you a job and then ran a background check, it cannot simply withdraw the offer because of your record. Under the Fair Chance Act, it must first decide, after an individualized assessment, whether your conviction history has a “direct and adverse relationship with the specific duties of the job,” send you a written preliminary notice, and give you at least five business days to respond. The law exempts positions where a criminal background check or a criminal-history restriction is required by law, positions with criminal justice agencies, and positions as farm labor contractors.
Before the offer
Government Code section 12952(a) bars covered employers from asking about conviction history on an application, and from asking about or considering it at all, “until after the employer has made a conditional offer of employment to the applicant.” The Civil Rights Department’s Fair Chance Act fact sheet adds that most employers cannot run a background check or an internet search for criminal history before an offer, or post ads saying “No Felons” or “Must Have Clean Record.” The fact sheet says the law “applies to public employers and private employers that have five or more employees,” and that it also covers people who start work before the check is run, employees up for promotion and employees otherwise undergoing a check.
After a conditional offer, a background check is allowed. Some cities and counties have their own fair-chance rules, which section 12952(e) leaves in place.
What the employer cannot consider
Even after an offer, section 12952(a)(3) forbids considering:
- an arrest that did not lead to a conviction, with narrow exceptions;
- referral to or participation in a pretrial or posttrial diversion program; and
- convictions that were sealed, dismissed, expunged or statutorily eradicated, and convictions for which you received a full pardon or a certificate of rehabilitation.
The department’s fact sheet also lists “Conviction history that is more than seven years old based on the date of disposition (the conviction date), date of release from prison or jail, or date of parole” among the information an employer can never consider. That limit comes from the department’s guidance, not the text of section 12952. Our advice: If the report you receive includes any of these items, raise that first.
The individualized assessment
If the employer intends to deny the job “solely or in part” because of conviction history, section 12952(c)(1) requires an individualized assessment of whether your record has a direct and adverse relationship with the specific duties of the job. The employer must consider three factors:
- the nature and gravity of the offense or conduct;
- the time that has passed since the offense or conduct and completion of the sentence; and
- the nature of the job held or sought.
The department’s fact sheet says an employer “cannot refuse to hire someone just because they have a criminal record,” or just because of a particular kind of conviction, such as a violent crime or sex offense. It also explains the factors in more detail: your age at the time, the specific conduct, whether property or people were harmed, and whether a disability, trauma, domestic or dating violence, sexual assault, stalking, human trafficking or duress contributed to the conviction. The employer does not have to put its assessment in writing.
The preliminary notice and your deadline
If the employer makes a preliminary decision that your record disqualifies you, section 12952(c)(2) requires written notice containing:
- the conviction or convictions that are the basis for the decision;
- a copy of the conviction history report, if any; and
- an explanation of your right to respond before the decision becomes final, the deadline to do so, and that your response may challenge the accuracy of the report, show rehabilitation or mitigating circumstances, or both.
The employer does not have to explain its reasoning in the notice, although the department encourages it.
You then have “at least five business days to respond” before the employer may make a final decision (section 12952(c)(3)). If, within those five business days, you notify the employer in writing that you dispute the accuracy of the report and are taking specific steps to get evidence, you get five additional business days. Under the department’s regulations, untracked mail to a California address is treated as received five calendar days after mailing. Email is treated as received two business days after sending.
Our advice: Keep the notice, report and proof of delivery. Dispute errors in writing within the first five business days and say what evidence you are seeking.
What to send
You do not have to respond, but the employer must consider what you submit before deciding (section 12952(c)(4)). The fact sheet lists evidence of rehabilitation or mitigating circumstances, including:
- your job history;
- school, job training, counseling, community service, treatment or rehabilitation programs;
- successfully following the rules of probation or parole; and
- whether you are bonded under a federal, state or local bonding program.
Proof can include program certificates and letters of support. Our advice: Connect your response to the job you were offered. If the conviction is old, unrelated to the job’s duties, or followed by years of steady work, say so directly and attach the proof. If the report is wrong, such as a dismissed charge or someone else’s record, attach the court document that shows it.
The final decision and a complaint
If the employer still denies the job because of your record, section 12952(c)(5) requires a written final notice that states the denial, describes any procedure the employer has to challenge it or request reconsideration, and tells you of your right to file a complaint with the Civil Rights Department. Under section 12960(e)(5), a complaint about a Fair Chance Act violation generally must be filed within three years of the unlawful practice. The department can then investigate; our City of Torrance analysis shows how an employer’s compliance claim opened its assessments to review.
Save the response you would have sent. In McInerney, UCLA decided before the five business days ran. The jury found more time would not have changed the decision, so the applicant did not recover on that violation. The opinion was filed September 18 and certified for publication October 13, 2026. Review and depublication requests were pending on November 20, 2026.
- Government Code section 12952 — Fair Chance Act
- Government Code section 12960 — complaint deadlines
- Civil Rights Department — Criminal History and Employment Fact Sheet (June 2025)
- Civil Rights Department — Fair Chance Act guidance and sample forms
- 2 C.C.R. § 11017.1(c)(2)(E) — response deadlines, p. 19
Received a preliminary notice withdrawing your offer?
Bring the notice, the background report and the date you received them, and we can help you prepare a response within the deadline or assess a complaint if the offer was already withdrawn. Call (949) 343-9735 or email office@mishrax.com.